Heisman Trophy index: Arch Manning bounces back in Week 2 amid injury buzz

In this story:
Arch Manning was able to take advantage of a “get-right” game in Week 2.
No. 7 Texas drove past San Jose State Saturday to notch its first win of the season. Manning was a major factor in that, scoring five touchdowns, with four in the air and one on the ground.
His biggest highlight of the day may have been his rushing score, weaving through the Spartans' defense on a 20-yard scramble.
Manning’s play wasn’t all peachy, though. He threw another pick in the win and he only finished with two more completions on as many attempts as he had in the Longhorn’s Week 1 loss to Ohio State.
The effort was important for his Heisman case, though. Entering the week at +1600 odds to win it, he’s gotten himself back into the mix now at +1200, according to BetMGM.
Heisman Trophy betting data from @BetMGM🏆
— BetMGM News (@BetMGMNews) September 8, 2025
Line movement (opening to current)
- Garrett Nussmeier +850 to +700📈
- John Mateer +2500 to +800📈
- Arch Manning +900 to +1200📉
- LaNorris Sellers +1800 to +1500📈
- Jeremiah Smith +1300 to +1500📉
- Cade Klubnik +1100 to +2500📉 pic.twitter.com/VF17QwVUQp
Manning will be must-watch TV, whether he’s succeeding on the field or not. But one thing that may be impacting his performance on the field is his health.
Several clips over the weekend showed shots of Manning grimacing while letting the ball go or using a different throwing motion than before. And while he may be healthy enough to play, his up-and-down accuracy through two games could point to something going on under the hood.
“You know how many clowns on the internet ripped me for ‘diagnosing,’ him with a [shoulder] injury because I’m ‘not a doctor,’” said former NFL and Virginia QB Kurt Benkert in a series of posts on X. “Arch clearly has a shoulder injury. They definitely aren’t disclosing it.”
https://t.co/6JE6bBsu1Q https://t.co/T9Surp2cnk
— Kurt Benkert (@KurtBenkert) September 7, 2025
Who knows how soon we get the truth on whether or not Manning is in fact dealing with an injury. But if it is something legit that Manning is trying to keep under wraps, who knows how hurtful playing through pain will be for his performance and if he can get back into the Heisman Trophy race.
We’ll have to wait and see what he’s able to do here in Week 3, as Texas faces off with UTEP.
Game odds refresh periodically and are subject to change. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem and wants help, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Khari Demos is an award-winning sports media creator and is a contributor for Bills On SI. He has written sports betting article covering the NFL for The Athletic and has written pieces about the NBA, MLB, college football and basketball, and more, throughout his career.