Brady vs Manning Rivalry Lives On in 1/1 Dual Auto Card
In this story:
That AFC Championship game between the Patriots and Broncos was a nail-biter, especially once conditions took a turn for the worse in the second half at Empower Field in Denver. It brought back memories of defensive slug fests, like the 2001 "Snow Bowl" between the Patriots and Raiders. It also brought back memories of the legendary duels between Patriots quarterback Tom Brady and Broncos (and Colts) quarterback Peyton Manning.
RELATED: $10K worth of cards stolen from Tom Brady's NYC CardVault store
This Brady/Manning dual auto is live on eBay for the next two days and could become the highest-selling card of its kind.
PSA 9 2016 Classic Clashes Peyton Manning and Tom Brady Dual Inscriptions Auto (#6)
Graded a PSA 9 with a PSA 10 autograph grade, the above 2016 Panini Classic Clashes card features a cheeky little back and forth between Brady and Manning. Beneath his signature, Brady includes the words "You win some you lose some" to which Manning replies "I agree!".
RELATED: Does Josh Allen Need a Super Bowl Win to Raise His Card Values?
As of Monday, this card already has close to 200 watchers and over 60 bids. The bid price has plateaued at just over $11K for now, but as every eBay card buyer knows, this one is sure to pop in the closing hours.
The Tom Brady and Peyton Manning Rivalry
The rivalry between Tom Brady and Peyton Manning is one of the best in football and arguably all of sports. For overall games, Brady has the edge winning head-to-head matchups 11 to 6. However, Manning has the most wins in the AFC Playoffs, winning three of their four matchups.
These two have great respect for one another, despite their epic on-field rivalry. Brady attended Manning's 2021 induction into the Pro Football Hall of Fame, and Manning even referred to Brady as his "good friend" during his acceptance speech.
PSA 9 2016 Panini Classic Clashes Eli Manning and Tom Brady Dual Inscriptions Autograph #18
There isn't much in the way of card sale history for this Brady and Peyton Manning Classic Clashes card on Card Ladder. However, there is one sale of a similar card featuring Brady and Peyton's brother Eli Manning: the Classic Clashes #18 seen above. This card also has a PSA 9 grade with a PSA 10 autograph grade.
This Classic Clashes card #18 sold for $14.4K on March 2, 2025. Much like the other Classic Clashes card, this one also has a little extra added with the autograph. Brady includes the words "Congrats, you earned it!" to which Eli Manning adds, "Hard fought game". Pure class.
The highest selling Tom Brady & Peyton Manning dual autograph
The Peyton Manning and Tom Brady Classic Clashes dual autograph card doesn't have a long way to go to set the record for highest-selling dual autograph featuring just these two quarterbacks. The highest selling dual autograph to date is the PSA 10 2016 Panini Playoff Pairings card above that sold for $18K on March 14, 2022.
The featured Classic Clashes card selling on eBay, with the extra inscription plus the on card autographs, is the cooler card. Despite the slightly lower grade, this one could easily set the record for a dual autograph featuring these two legends.
Conor is a life long sports card enthusiast who started collecting in the early ’90s, inspired by hometown heroes like Larry Bird, Paul Pierce, Tom Brady, and David Ortiz. Like many ’90s hoops fans, he also started building (and continues to build) a modest Michael Jordan collection.