Surf, Sand, and Stardom: Collecting Baywatch
Surf, Sand, and Stardom: Collecting the Women of Baywatch
During its era from 1989-1999, Baywatch ruled the global airwaves. With its sun-drenched lifeguards, slow-mo beach runs, and over-the-top rescues, the series wasn’t just a hit—it was a phenomenon. At its peak, Baywatch was broadcast in over 140 countries, making its stars among the most recognizable faces on the planet. And while the show had plenty of muscle-bound action, it was the women of Baywatch who became true icons.
The documentary After Baywatch: Moment in the Sun (Disney+, Hulu) renewed interest it the cast and their collectibles. From red swimsuits to red carpets, these actresses built careers that stretched far beyond the shoreline—and for collectors, their trading cards offer a nostalgic, high-gloss look back at the golden era of ‘90s TV fame.
RELATED: 'The Dukes of Hazzard': Iconic Characters and Collectibles
Pamela Anderson: The Global Icon
Pamela Anderson didn’t just star in Baywatch—she defined it. As C.J. Parker, she became the show’s breakout star and one of the most recognizable faces of the 1990s. Her time on Baywatch turned her into a global phenomenon, helping the series become one of the most-watched television shows in the world. Anderson leveraged that fame into a multifaceted career—gracing the cover of Playboy a record number of times, headlining films like Barb Wire, and later becoming a prominent voice for animal rights and environmental activism.
What to Collect: Fans have lots of choices, including cards based on her appearance as the title character in the 1996 film Barb Wire to multiple appearances (and autos) in Leaf Pop Century, 2011 Donruss Americana and 1997 Benchwarmers, auto typically running +$200.
RELATED: Olympians in the Swimsuit Issue and Their Cards
Traci Bingham: Breaking Ground and Making Waves
Traci Bingham made history as the first African-American actress to have a regular role on Baywatch. As lifeguard Jordan Tate, she brought both sex appeal and smarts to the team. Bingham parlayed her Baywatch fame into roles in reality TV and regular game show appearances—and continued work with Playboy.
What to Collect: Like Anderson, Bingham has a lot for collectors to go after. She’s in current releases like Wild Cards’ Decades release and 2025 Leaf Pop Century (about $40 with auto), as well as previous releases in multiple Benchwarmers releases (about $20 signed).
RELATED: Power Players: Female Athlete Influencers Making Waves in Collectibles
Carmen Electra: The Pop Culture Chameleon
Although Carmen Electra joined Baywatch later in its run, her impact was immediate. Already known for her music career and Prince's mentorship, she brought a bold, sexy edge to the show as lifeguard Lani McKenzie. But it was her MTV era—hosting Singled Out, ruling Spring Break, and starring in countless Y2K specials—that made her a fixture of late-’90s pop culture.
Electra parlayed that fame into a string of parody film roles (Scary Movie, Date Movie, Meet the Spartans), often playing exaggerated takes on her public persona. More recently, she’s resurfaced through reality TV (The Surreal Life, Celebrity Dating Game), a headline-making OnlyFans debut, and viral social media moments that have introduced her to a new generation.
What to Collect: At the risk of sounding like a broken record, Electra has a lot to offer collectors. She made her “rookie” debut in 2005-06 Topps Basketball alongside other celebs (under $10 raw) and has multiple cards in Wild Cards’ Decades release and Leaf Pop Century and Continuum (around $50).
Riding the Wave of Nostalgia
For many, Baywatch is more than a show—it’s a time capsule. And the trading cards tied to its stars offer a unique way to dive back in. Whether it’s a foil-stamped Pamela Anderson card or a rare Camen Electra insert, these collectibles reflect a specific cultural moment: bold, beautiful, and impossible to miss. More Baywatch stars to come—stay tuned for a future article!
Lucas Mast is a writer based in San Francisco East Bay, where he’s a season ticket holder for St. Mary’s basketball and a die-hard Stanford athletics fan. A lifelong collector of sneakers, sports cards, and pop culture, he also advises companies shaping the future of the hobby and sports. He’s driven by a curiosity about why people collect—and what those items reveal about the moments and memories that matter most.