Social media reacts to John Mateer, Oklahoma beating No. 15 Michigan

In this story:
The No. 15 Michigan Wolverines took their first loss of the season on Saturday when they fell to No. 18 Oklahoma in Norman, 24-13. It was all Oklahoma right from the start. The Sooners took the first drive right down the field for a score, but Oklahoma did whatever it could to keep Michigan in the game. Between John Mateer throwing an interception, the Sooners missing a FG, and Oklahoma muffing a punt -- Michigan had its chances.
But the Wolverines' line play was poor on both sides. Michigan didn't give the Wolverines' running backs many holes to run through -- other than Justice Haynes' 75-yarder -- and Bryce Underwood had very little time to go through progressions before a Sooner was in his face. The five-star phenom threw for 142 yards on 9-of-24 attempts.
QB John Mateer stole the show on Saturday. The Washington State transfer was fantastic and Michigan had zero answers for him. He showed why he was the top-ranked transfer in the portal, and why the Sooners wanted him badly. Mateer threw for 270 yards and a score, and he added 74 yards on the ground with two scores. Mateer was able to move around in the pocket, extend plays, and find the weak spot in Michigan's zone.
To make matters worse, the Wolverines have been hit by the injury bug. Michigan was already without several players heading into the game like Rod Moore, Marlin Klein, Chase Anderson, and Shamari Earls, among others, but during the game, Michigan lost Giovanni El-Hadi and Zeke Berry. As of now, it's not known how serious either injury was. Players like Brady Norton, Jaishawn Barham, Semaj Morgan, and Brandyn Hillman were banged up and missed a few plays.
Following the game, social media had their say and shared their feelings on Michigan's performance against Oklahoma. Here are some of the top social media reactions.
Michigan wasn't great on offense, defense, special teams, or coaching, but still did enough, and got enough breaks, to have a chance to win with a freshman QB.
— John U. Bacon (@Johnubacon) September 7, 2025
Underwood can only develop through games like that.
They'll have to trust him to throw and run, and work on the OL too.
Don't agree with Herbstreit's analysis at all. Receivers and tight ends have been plenty open tonight. Offensive line is giving ZERO time to Underwood and not allowing the run game to develop outside of a home run shot.
— Josh Henschke (@JoshHenschke) September 7, 2025
Oklahoma was the better team tonight, hats off to them for the win. Y'all have been good sports on here.
— Swanky Wolverine (@swankywolverine) September 7, 2025
Michigan has work to do. Get home, get healthy and fix it.
Back in the Big House next week, let's get back on track. Always go blue.
Oklahoma finishes off Michigan. But it's lovely that Sherrone Moore got to visit his alma mater before being suspended for the next two games.
— Pat Forde (@ByPatForde) September 7, 2025
Hats off to OU, but wtf on the play calling tonight for the offense.
— Luke D'Mello (@mello2189) September 7, 2025
Michigan fell on the road in Oklahoma, 24-13.
— Brad Galli (@BradGalli) September 7, 2025
Sooners QB John Mateer was too much for U-M’s defense. pic.twitter.com/akyEbDAHhH
Oklahoma QB John Mateer vs Michigan:
— PFF College (@PFF_College) September 7, 2025
🔴 21/34
🔴 344 Total Yards
🔴 3 Total Touchdowns
🔴 1 Interception@OU_Football pic.twitter.com/WbOjj1YC4o
Bottom line: Michigan didn’t play well enough to win tonight. They fought hard, but the details — or lack thereof — caught up to them tonight.
— Don Thomas (@REALDonThomas) September 7, 2025
Still, lots of room to get better — and they will. Bryce Underwood will be a star at Michigan.
Onto Central Michigan. #GoBlue
Michigan lost the battle up front all night, and it was evident from the jump. Sherrone & Chip need to get together and figure out what the identity of this offense is.
— Brandon Justice (@BrandonJustice_) September 7, 2025
If you’re starting the freshman, you can’t constantly show him you don’t trust him yet with what you call.
Hat tip to OU. Sooners won every phase of this game tonight. Michigan, meanwhile, obviously has some work to do. We'll discuss live in the postgame recap after the presser
— Sam Webb (@SamWebb77) September 7, 2025
Gio El-Hadi has a boot on his left foot. The situation doesn’t look very promising. Hope to get an update here coming shortly.
— Tony Garcia | Detroit Free Press (@RealTonyGarcia) September 7, 2025
More Michigan News:
Takeaways: Oklahoma bullies Michigan in a top-20 showdown
3 predictions for Michigan vs. Oklahoma
Staff predictions: Top 20 showdown between Michigan vs. Oklahoma
Fox's Joel Klatt breaks down and predicts score of Michigan vs. Oklahoma game
Michigan commits, targets predict outcome between Wolverines vs. Oklahoma

Trent began writing and covering Michigan athletics back in 2020. He became a credentialed member of the media in 2021. Trent began writing with Sports Illustrated in 2023 and became the Managing Editor for Michigan Wolverines On SI during the 2025 football season. Trent also serves as the Publisher of Baylor Bears on SI. His other bylines have appeared on Maryland on SI, Wisconsin on SI, and across the USA TODAY Sports network. Trent’s love of sports and being able to tell stories to fans is what made him get into writing.
Follow @trentknoop