Pat McAfee Reveals Why His First Match Was In WWE And Not The Indies

Pat McAfee says that he was ready to hit the indies to find out if he could wrestle prior to having his first match in WWE.
In the most recent episode of Stephanie's Places on ESPN+, McAfee spoke openly about his early WWE days. He told McMahon that Triple H was the one who encouraged him to have his first match in NXT against Adam Cole rather than start on the independent circuit.
“I was like, ‘Hey, I’m gonna go hit the indies and see if I can do this or not,’" McAfee said on the show. "He (Triple H) was like, ‘Don’t you even think about it. You need to be doing it with us if you’re going to do it at all. Let’s just figure out a good time for it.’"Pat McAfee (h/t Fightful)
McAfee ended up starting a feud with Adam Cole soon after, which culminated in a match at NXT TakeOver XXX. McAfee was unsuccessful in the match, but it kickstarted what would be a long tenure with the WWE.
MORE: Pat McAfee To Face Gunther At WWE Backlash
McAfee has been a commentator for the Smackdown brand and now is the color commentator next to Michael Cole for WWE Raw on Netflix. He has also competed against and defeated both Austin Theory and The Miz in WrestleMania matches.
McAfee will step up in competition this weekend when he takes on Gunther at WWE Backlash. McAfee challenged Gunther to a match after he attacked Michael Cole and the match was made official soon thereafter.
WWE Backlash airs live on Peacock and Netflix internationally this Saturday, May 10 from St. Louis. Other matches on the show include John Cena vs. Randy Orton for the Undispted WWE Championship and Becky Lynch vs. Lyra Valkyria for the WWE Women's Intercontinental Championship.
The Latest On WWE, AEW & More
Will Ospreay On WWE: "On my worst day I'm better than a lot of the guys in-ring"
First Official History Of AEW Book Reportedly To Be Released In 2025
Drew McIntyre Reveals His Greatest Matches Of All Time List
WWE Advertising John Cena's Final Appearances In Europe Ahead Of Huge Summer Tour

Zack Heydorn has been covering the pro wrestling industry for a decade and writes news, features, and interviews for The Takedown On SI. He also hosts and cohosts a variety of WWE and AEW shows on YouTube. Heydorn is a former Assistant Editor of PWTorch and Managing Editor of SEScoops. Zack is also the author of the Hybrid Shoot book Stunning: The Wrestling Artistry of Steve Austin, which is available on Amazon. You can follow Zack on X and Bluesky.
Follow Zack_Heydorn