Christian McCaffrey's Top 4 49ers' Cards Could Climb in Price After Playoff Win
In this story:
Christian McCaffrey and The San Francisco 49ers' Wild Card win against the Eagles isn’t a one-game spike or a surprise resurgence. The win was the latest confirmation that, when healthy, CMC remains one of the most complete and valuable players in football—and one whose career arc continues to resonate with collectors tracking long-term value. And as fans of The Chicago Bears' heroics can attest, big wins can have a big impact on cards.
RELATED: Goldin and Netflix Tower Over The Hobby with Cards, Comics and More
From Stanford Record-Breaker to NFL Cornerstone
McCaffrey’s rise began at Stanford, where he redefined what an all-purpose back could be. In 2015, he set the NCAA single-season all-purpose yards record with 3,864 yards, finishing second in Heisman voting and becoming a national phenomenon built on versatility rather than pure power. That resume, combining elite production and a cerebral, detail-driven style, laid the foundation for early demand around his college and pre-draft cards, many of which remain key entry points for long-term collectors.
Drafted eighth overall by the Carolina Panthers in 2017, McCaffrey quickly evolved from a matchup weapon into a true offensive engine. His 2019 season, with 1,000 rushing yards and 1,000 receiving yards put him in exclusive company and pushed his card market into blue-chip territory for modern running backs.
Injury, Doubt, and the San Francisco Reset
Then came the stretch that reshaped his narrative. Injuries limited McCaffrey to just 10 games across the 2020 and 2021 seasons, the kind of downturn that often permanently dampens expectations at the position. For collectors, that period cooled the market, but didn’t erase belief. The trade to San Francisco in 2022 offered a reset, placing McCaffrey in an offense designed to maximize vision, patience, and versatility.
By 2025, he was again handling elite volume, leading the league in touches from scrimmage and becoming the unquestioned focal point of Kyle Shanahan’s offense. That renaissance matters in the collectibles world: comeback seasons, especially those tied to contending teams, tend to define how careers are remembered.
The Eagles Game and What It Signaled
Against Philadelphia, McCaffrey didn’t need explosive highlights to control the game. With San Francisco leaning heavily on tempo and ball control, he dictated defensive alignments, converted late downs, and kept the 49ers on schedule with two receiving touchdowns in a tight postseason win. Performances like this, where influence outweighs raw stats, are often the ones that age best historically, especially when attached to playoff success.
Leadership, Legacy, and the Super Bowl Factor
Inside the locker room, McCaffrey is widely viewed as a tone-setter, a reputation built on preparation as much as production. That leadership profile adds another layer to his appeal as San Francisco continues its postseason push.
There’s also a broader stage looming. With Super Bowl LIX set to be hosted in San Francisco this February, the stakes feel amplified. Deep playoff runs that intersect with hosting cities tend to linger in league history and in the hobby. Should the 49ers continue to advance, McCaffrey’s cards won’t just reflect a great season or a comeback narrative; they’ll be tied to a moment when the league’s biggest game and the team’s most important player converged at home.
RELATED: 5 Cameron Brink Card Sales from 2025: Is it too late to get in on This Star?
For collectors, that convergence matters. McCaffrey’s top cards—Stanford issues, early Panthers standouts, and key 49ers releases from this renaissance phase track a career defined by resilience, adaptability, and sustained excellence. And with San Francisco still chasing a title, the story may not be finished yet.
Lucas Mast is a writer based in California’s Bay Area, where he’s a season ticket holder for St. Mary’s basketball and a die-hard Stanford athletics fan. A lifelong collector of sneakers, sports cards, and pop culture, he also advises companies shaping the future of the hobby and sports. He’s driven by a curiosity about why people collect—and what those items reveal about the moments and memories that matter most.
Follow sneakrz