Colorado Buffaloes Greats Sound Off On Shedeur Sanders And Travis Hunter's Number Retirement

In this story:
The Colorado Buffaloes' recent decision to retire quarterback Shedeur Sanders and Heisman Trophy winner Travis Hunter's respective jersey numbers during Saturday's spring football game isn't exactly sitting well with some of the program's recent all-time greats.
While most believe Sanders' No. 2 and Hunter's No. 12 are deserving of retirement, doing so four months after their college careers ended may be too soon. Only four numbers are retired by Colorado: Joe Romig's No. 67, Byron White's No. 24, Bobby Anderson's No. 11 and Rashaan Salaam's No. 19. However, offensive lineman Kahlil Benson wore No. 67 last year and defensive back Preston Hodge currently sports No. 24. Anderson's No. 11 is also being worn by safety Tawfiq Byard this spring.

Former Colorado running back Phillip Lindsay, who set 24 school records during his time with the Buffs from 2013-17, recently spoke on the controversy during his 104.3 The Fan radio show, "The Drive." Lindsay said that several all-time great players from Colorado's late 1980s and 1990s glory days don't have their numbers retired. "You don't erase history," Lindsay noted.
"These players that have pretty much led us and set a standard, they don't even have their jerseys retired," Lindsay said. "You don't have Darian Hagan's jersey retired, who's No. 3. You don't have Eric Bieniemy's number retired, who's No. 1. You don't have Alfred Williams', 'Big Al,' jersey retired, and they won national championships. Why all of a sudden are we starting now? Why are we skipping them?
"I'm not saying, Zach (co-host Zach Bye), that Travis Hunter or even Shedeur Sanders shouldn't have their jerseys retired because I know Travis Hunter is gonna get his jersey retired. The man is just different. But what was the rush? Why are we skipping people that earned the right to have that moment?"
MORE: Deion Sanders, Colorado Buffaloes Hosting Transfer Portal Standout From Missouri Tigers
MORE: Deion Sanders Gives Concrete Answer On Nico Iamaleava, Colorado Buffaloes Transfer Portal
MORE: Colorado Buffaloes Spring Football Game Storylines: Deion Sanders Introduces New-Look Squad
What does one of the legends of Colorado Football think about the schools decision to retire Travis Hunter and Shedeur Sanders jerseys?@byesline | @I_CU_boy pic.twitter.com/qbq4R7P3w0
— Denver Sports 104.3 (@DenSports1043) April 15, 2025
Former Colorado quarterback and current Fox Sports analyst Joel Klatt shared a similar sentiment while appearing on "First Things First."
"Not a good look," Klatt said. "I don't know of anybody anywhere that has been a more staunch supporter of what has gone on at Colorado, and still am, by the way... I just think that it cheapens what you're trying to do. You're trying to honor Shedeur Sanders, you're trying to honor Travis Hunter... With Shedeur, it's way too easy from the outside looking in to say, 'Would this happen if he had a different name on his back?'"
Klatt added that Colorado coach Deion Sanders didn't purvey the decision to retire Shedeur and Hunter's numbers on Saturday.
"This did not come from Deion (Sanders)," Klatt said. "This has to get signed off by the athletic director (Rick George). I talked to him today and told him I didn't agree with this. He said listen, 'This guy, Shedeur Sanders and Travis Hunter changed the trajectory of our program.'"
All-time great Colorado linebacker Chad Brown would've liked to see a longer "waiting period" before the numbers get retired.
Ok…
— Chad Brown (@chadbrown94) April 15, 2025
You win the Heisman, I get it. But at least a waiting period please.
As far as a CU #2, that will always be Deon Figures for me. Thorpe Award winner. CU HOF. College Football HOF. Massive part of bringing the National Championship to CU. Sealing int in the Orange Bowl. https://t.co/7sugqoE05K
Former Colorado all-conference offensive lineman David Bakhtiari also mentioned Figures while sharing his thoughts on the controversy.
For context:
— David Bakhtiari (@DavidBakhtiari) April 15, 2025
Deon Figures, CB
(who also wore #2 for CU) resume:
-1990 national champion
-Jim Thorpe award winner
-Jack Tatum award
-consensus all American
-big 8 def player of the year
-1st round pick
-6 year NFL career
-college football Hall of fame. https://t.co/ckNW1jI7bR

Jack Carlough is lead reporter for Colorado Buffaloes on SI. Jack graduated from the University of Colorado with a bachelor's degree in journalism and minors in business and sports media. Born and raised in the Boulder area, Jack began covering Colorado athletics in 2018 and was the head sports editor of the CU Independent during his college career. More recently, he spent over three years as the managing editor of the USA Today Sports Network's Colorado Buffaloes Wire, where he covered Colorado's hiring of head football coach Deion Sanders. Other publications Jack has written for include the Boulder Daily Camera, Left Hand Valley Courier and SB Nation’s Ralphie Report. In 2022, the Colorado Press Association awarded Jack second place in its annual Class 5 Best Sports Column Writing category.