Former FSU football star insists Seminoles' problems go beyond talent

The Florida State Seminoles appear to be in a tailspin, dropping three straight matchups and still searching for their first conference win of the season. Saturday’s 34-31 loss to Pitt was one many expected to be a get-right moment, but instead it raised more questions than answers.

It was supposed to be a rebound opportunity after back-to-back setbacks against Miami at home and Virginia on the road, yet the growing sentiment is that something continues to feel off.

Former Florida State cornerback (2000-04) and CBS analyst Bryant McFadden didn’t mince words when asked about the program’s current mentality. Drawing from his own experience playing under a different standard, he reflected on the accountability that defined his era.

McFadden Lashes Out After Florida State Upset

Oct 11, 2025; Tallahassee, Florida, USA; Pittsburgh Panthers quarterback Mason Heintschel (6) runs the ball in the first quarter against the Florida State Seminoles at Doak S. Campbell Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Melina Myers-Imagn Images | Melina Myers-Imagn Images

Accountability has been a buzzword around Florida State in recent weeks, but for former Seminole Bryant McFadden, it isn’t just a phrase but a culture you either enforce or lose.

"When I played at Florida State, and even when I got drafted to Pittsburgh... I was afraid to mess up. If I missed a tackle in the first quarter, I (was) afraid that I might not play again and get cursed out in front of everybody," McFadden said. "If I missed a tackle and if I didn't have proper containment and got beat deep, oh no. I don't even wanna go over to the sideline because I know coach is waiting for me."

"I know it is a different day and age in terms of coaching football, but I couldn't care less," McFadden added. "You set the standard for what you will allow. Never allow something in a win that you won't allow in a loss."

"A true freshman came into Doak and put up 34 points and 400 yards of total offense. It ain't got nothing to do with talent."

Former Seminole @BMac_SportsTalk goes off after FSU's loss to Pitt pic.twitter.com/EBIkyROCwB
— CBS Sports College Football 🏈 (@CBSSportsCFB) October 11, 2025

A Standard Ignored Is a Standard Lost

Oct 11, 2025; Tallahassee, Florida, USA; Pittsburgh Panthers running back Desmond Reid (0) runs the ball during the first quarter against the Florida State Seminoles at Doak S. Campbell Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Melina Myers-Imagn Images | Melina Myers-Imagn Images

The Seminole defense has given up 108 points through three games in conference play after toppling Alabama in Week 1 and running over Kent State and East Texas A&M. McFadden made it clear that the scoreboard shouldn't dictate the standards, and that’s where he believes the cracks begin to show.

"That's the thing, because when you win, sometimes you allow certain things and (are like) we're not really gonna harp on that, but never allow something in a win that you won't allow in a loss. These are unexcusable issues."

Pitt true freshman Mason Heintschel threw for 321 yards and connected with running back Desmond Reid on a pair of touchdown passes and two interceptions while adding another 64 yards on the ground. McFadden pushed back on the idea that growing pains were to blame. In his eyes, the problem was far more fundamental.

"Once again, a true freshman came into Doak and put up 34 points and almost 400 yards of total offense. It ain't got nothin' to do with talent. "

Florida State doesn’t lack athletes or recruiting stars. What it lacks, at least in McFadden’s eyes, is the urgency that once made wearing garnet and gold feel like a privilege you could lose at any moment. Until that edge returns, the conversation won’t be about talent but about identity.

Stick with NoleGameday for more FREE coverage of Florida State Football throughout the 2025 season

Follow NoleGameday on and Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok

More Florida State News

Former FSU football star Jordan Travis has strong words on Mike Norvell

FSU football's struggles lead to exit from AP Top 25 Poll

Mike Norvell sounds off after FSU football's loss to Pittsburgh: 'Still too many mistakes'

Florida State football huge betting favorite in ACC trip to Stanford Cardinal