USC’s College Football Playoff Chances Will Rise or Fall With Jayden Maiava

In this story:
The No. 17 USC Trojans need quarterback Jayden Maiava to play his best football of the season—and they need it now. ESPN’s latest ranking of every Power 4 quarterback placed the Trojans’ starter at No. 5 after two months, a slight drop from his No. 1 spot just a few weeks ago.
The decline isn’t dramatic, but it is a sign that Maiava has entered the most scrutinized stretch of his USC career as the Trojans enter a must-win November.
A Strong Season That Hit a Midseason Speed Bump

Maiava’s statistical profile still ranks among the nation’s best. Through four games, he posted a 93.4 QBR, 1,587 passing yards, 80 rushing yards, and 15 total touchdowns. After eight games, those numbers climbed to a 90.7 QBR, 2,614 passing yards, 175 rushing yards, and 23 total touchdowns. His second month included 1,027 passing yards, 95 rushing yards, and seven additional scores. The efficiency dip was minimal. But the turnovers changed the conversation.
After opening the season with four turnover-free performances, Maiava has thrown interceptions in five straight games—including two costly interceptions during USC’s 34–24 loss to the No. 9 Notre Dame Fighting Irish. Those giveaways, more than anything, have fueled his drop in ESPN’s rankings and allowed Big Ten rivals Fernando Mendoza and Julian Sayin to surge past him.
MORE: Weather Concerns Mount For USC's Game vs. Iowa Hawkeyes
MORE: Why USC's Success Has Major Impact On Record Crowd vs. Nebraska Volleyball
MORE: Why USC Trojans Could Be On Upset Alert Against Iowa
The Home Stretch Will Decide Everything

Despite the turnover spike, Maiava remains undeniably elite. He ranks 11th nationally in passing yards, fourth in yards per completion (9.7), and ninth in passer rating (164.2). His completion percentage has jumped from 59.8 percent in 2024 to 68.1 percent this season. He is reading the field faster, throwing in rhythm, and operating Lincoln Riley’s offense with command.
But USC’s margin for error is gone. The No. 21 Iowa Hawkeyes allow just 146.7 passing yards per game and have surrendered only four passing touchdowns all season. The No. 8 Oregon Ducks are even stingier, giving up 126.1 passing yards per game and only five passing touchdowns. Both units rank top-10 in passing defense. Both will challenge Maiava’s decision-making, timing, and discipline.
These are the types of games where elite quarterbacks separate themselves. And they’re the games that determine which teams stay in the College Football Playoff conversation once November hits.
Everything USC Wants Still Runs Through Maiava

The good news? USC still controls its fate. Maiava doesn’t need to be perfect—he just needs to return to the version of himself that opened the season with surgical accuracy and mistake-free football. USC’s offense remains No. 1 in SP+, and the Trojans are still a top-10 scoring team. The structure is in place for a late-season surge. Now the quarterback must rise to meet the moment.
If Maiava steadies the turnovers and leans into his strengths—quick throws, rhythm passing, and calculated aggression—USC will remain firmly in the Playoff race. But if the giveaways continue, the Trojans risk watching November opportunities slip away.

Jalon Dixon covers the USC Trojans and Maryland Terrapins for On SI, bringing fans the stories behind the scores. From breaking news to in-depth features, he delivers sharp analysis and fresh perspective across football, basketball, and more. With experience covering everything from the NFL to college hoops, Dixon blends insider knowledge with a knack for storytelling that keeps readers coming back.