Baylor fans believe there is only one option on the table following loss to Cincinnati

In this story:
Things continue to spiral for Baylor. After suffering a loss last week in Fort Worth, the message among Baylor coaches and players were to respond and start quickly against Cincinnati -- but it was far from that. The Bearcats went right down the field on their first two possessions of the game to take a 14-0 lead over the Bears.
After going down 24-0, Baylor had a solid drive to end the second quarter to go into halftime down 24-6, but it was too late. Baylor came out of halftime and grinded to get the game within seven points to start the fourth quarter, but once again, the Baylor defense couldn't stop Brendan Sorsby or Tawee Walker on the ground.
Following a Kole Wilson fumble on a kick return, Baylor was set to lose yet another game. The Bears fell to the Bearcats, 41-20, and move to 4-4 on the season. Baylor gave up 376 yards to Cincinnati on Saturday, and the Bears gained just 266 yards. Robertson was only able to rattle off 137 passing yards -- his lowest of the season. Once again, the Bears turned the ball over twice -- which has been an issue all game.
Baylor entered the season with both College Football Playoff and Big 12 Championship aspirations, but the season has been anything but successful. Despite veteran players and a veteran coaching staff, Baylor struggles with fundamentals and the Bears' defense can't stop any competent defense.
Baylor appears to be at a crossroads in head coach Dave Aranda's tenure in Waco. Either stay the course and hope there is improvement, or do what other colleges are doing and look elsewhere. One thing is clear, the fanbase has their own opinion on what Baylor should do.
Following the loss to Cincinnati, social media made its feelings known on what transpired in Ohio.
The theme for this season has been the slow starts from Dave Aranda's team
Takeaways from Baylor’s loss to Cincy
— Grayson Grundhoefer (@GrayGrundhoefer) October 25, 2025
-Another HORRIBLE start, theme of this era
-Offense scored zero points first 29 minutes
-Turnover margin -10 in Big 12 play
-Players meeting, bye week, backs against the wall, etc. None of it has mattered for this very flawed team.
Bears lose second straight game, go 0-2 on road trip coming out of bye as they call 41-20 against Cincinnati.
— BearsIllustrated (@BaylorBears247) October 25, 2025
Despite the lofty expectations entering the season, Baylor is now striving to make a bowl game
When the final whistle blows, Baylor will fall to 17-25 against FBS programs since the 2021 season.
— Jackson Posey ✞ (@ByJacksonPosey) October 25, 2025
2022: 5-7
2023: 2-9
2024: 7-5
2025: 3-4
UCF, Utah, Arizona, Houston remain on the schedule. The Bears need two more wins to secure bowl eligibility. #SicEm
Is Dave Aranda doing too much trying to coach the defense AND be the head coach?
Baylor has the WORST defense in the country. Either our offense is perfect or we lose every game.
— The Baylor Observer (@BaylorObserver) October 25, 2025
And there goes the D. Smh. Aranda knew he couldn't be a DC and HC and yet he didnt hire someone. Smh
— T-REX (@T_REX1991) October 25, 2025
Dave Aranda’s tenure at Baylor pic.twitter.com/iFUCB5T5rl
— Jack 🐻 (@Jack_BenderBU) October 25, 2025
I really can’t stand this defense man
— jared 🐻 (@jaredismyname_) October 25, 2025
We are so poorly coached that it's almost funny. We make the wrong decisions on special teams constantly. We have no defense to speak of. We take a half or more to get going offensively. And we are about to be 4-4.
— OMG (@OsoMediaGroup) October 25, 2025
Firing Dave Aranda isn’t enough.
— Zachary Miller (@_ZacharyMiller) October 25, 2025
Mack Rhoades needs to be fired, too. The decline of Baylor football is on him.
Live footage of the Baylor fanbase if Dave Aranda is allowed to coach another game pic.twitter.com/CoAskIRnWM
— BB (@baylor_bearss) October 25, 2025
It’s hard to blame @BUFootball fans for not supporting the team when it looks like the players don’t care about winning either.
— Trey Morris (@TreyMorris) October 25, 2025
They’ve quit on Dave.
It’s time for Aranda to go! #SicEm pic.twitter.com/JdIi6qC0iG
Baylor struggles to find any sort of identity following Aranda's promising start
In 2021 Baylor won the Big12 Championship.. that year the team had an identity of a TOUGH defense with multiple NFL talents..
— Sherman Young Jr. (@ShermStu_2) October 25, 2025
Baylor’s defenses since then:
2021: 2nd overall defense in Big12
2022: 5th
2023: 7th
2024: 8th
2025: 13th (currently)
This is quickly turning into A Situation for Baylor.
— Shehan Jeyarajah (@ShehanJeyarajah) October 25, 2025
There’s been almost zero positive signs this year for a team that came into the season with expectations, but this is on its way to a rock bottom moment. pic.twitter.com/1ho8tKCMkE
More From Baylor On SI:
-c6d300a6cd3bbc37e5025fa0d47bc7a7.jpeg)
Trent is the Publisher of Baylor Bears on SI and also serves as the Managing Editor for Michigan Wolverines on SI. His work has additionally been featured on Maryland on SI, Wisconsin on SI, and across the USA TODAY Sports network. Trent’s love of sports and being able to tell stories to fans is what made him get into writing.
Follow TrentKnoop