Rich Rodriguez Has Hit Big and Flopped Hard in Year One — WVU Could Do Either in 2025

In this story:
Year one of stint two for Rich Rodriguez at West Virginia is just days away from getting underway.
College football has certainly changed throughout the course of his career, and especially since he was last seen roaming the sidelines in Morgantown. The transfer portal and NIL make for way more attrition in year one than when he took the job here in '01, Michigan in '08, Arizona in '12, and to some extent, Jacksonville State in '22.
Despite the changes, it's still interesting to take a look back at how Rodriguez's teams performed in year one. Below is a look at each first season at every Division I head coaching job he's had, finished with some analysis on what year one here could look like.
2001 West Virginia

Record: 3-8
PPG (National Rank): 21.4 (90th)
PPG Allowed (National Rank): 24.4 (51st)
Total Offense (National Rank) 345.7 (80th)
Total Defense (National Rank): 349.9 (40th)
2008 Michigan

Record: 3-9
PPG (National Rank): 20.3 (95th)
PPG Allowed (National Rank): 28.9 (84th)
Total Offense (National Rank) 290.8 (109th)
Total Defense (National Rank): 366.9 (67th)
2012 Arizona

Record: 8-5
PPG (National Rank): 36.7 (18th)
PPG Allowed (National Rank): 38.3 (112th)
Total Offense (National Rank): 512.6 (8th)
Total Defense (National Rank): 527.8 (124th)
2022 Jacksonville State

Record: 9-2
PPG (National Rank): 36.2 (10th)
PPG Allowed (National Rank): 22.9 (33rd)
Total Offense (National Rank): 423.6 (27th)
Total Defense (National Rank): 389.7 (65th)
2025 West Virginia

The record
Projected record: 7-5
I've got the Mountaineers coming out of the gate hot in terms of wins and losses, going a perfect 3-0 in non-conference play. What won't be perfect is how they get to those three wins, but nonetheless, it will help build some momentum heading into league play. The Big 12 slate is challenging with games against Kansas, Utah, BYU, TCU, Arizona State, Texas Tech, and so on. Rich Rod finds a way to finish above .500 in year one.
The offense
Projected PPG: 27.5
Projected Total Offense: 418.7
WVU will put up some big numbers this Saturday against Robert Morris and potentially even against Ohio in Week 2, although they play some pretty salty defense — finished 10th in total defense a year ago. I do believe this unit will move the ball pretty well once they get into a rhythm, but I have a feeling they may struggle to finish off drives with touchdowns, which is why I have them averaging sub-30 per game.
The defense
Projected PPG Allowed: 26.2
Projected Total Defense: 355.3
Zac Alley is a brilliant defensive mind, but this is just the start of turning this side of the ball around. He doesn't have the type of depth he'd like to in all three levels, but has enough to work with to make it manageable. Because of the aggressive nature of Alley's defense plays, they'll give up their fair share of explosive plays. Combine that with a bunch of guys who haven't played much together, and you'll get an inconsistent product. The potential is there for this to be a top 50 unit, however.
MORE STORIES FROM WEST VIRGINIA ON SI
Jaylen Henderson Might Be the QB WVU Needs and Saturday Could Prove It
How Big Could Jahiem White’s Season Be in Rich Rod’s Offense? Here’s a Projection
West Virginia Officially Adds Wide Receiver Jeff Weimer to 2025 Roster
WVU Fans Voted on the Team’s Biggest Concern and the Results Were Not Even Close
MAILBAG: Starting QB, Jimmori Robinson's Status, Freshmen to Watch + More

Schuyler Callihan is the publisher of West Virginia On SI and has been a trusted source covering the Mountaineers since 2016. He is the host of Between The Eers, The Walk Thru Game Day Show, and In the Gun Podcast. The Wheeling, WV native moved to Charlotte, North Carolina in 2020 to cover the Charlotte Hornets and Carolina Panthers.
Follow Callihan_