Stock Up, Stock Down: Fox Emerges, Vaughn Re-Emerges, New O-Line Evaluation + More

A look at which Mountaineers played well and who didn't.

Oct 25, 2025; Morgantown, West Virginia, USA; West Virginia Mountaineers quarterback Scotty Fox Jr. (15) throws a pass during the first quarter against the Texas Christian University Horned Frogs at Milan Puskar Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Ben Queen-Imagn Images | Ben Queen-Imagn Images

Rich Rodriguez's West Virginia Mountaineers came oh so close to putting an end to their losing streak, but fell short to TCU by a 23-17 score.

Let's take a look at the latest stock report.

Stock up: QB Scotty Fox Jr.

The natural reaction is to jump the gun and say he's the answer for the future at the quarterback position. The same was said about Khalil Wilkins until he endured some struggles. I do believe he has the best blend of passing/rushing ability of the current room, thus giving him the highest ceiling. However, I want to see him put a few of these performances together and show some impressive things against better defenses. TCU's pass defense ranks in the bottom 25 nationally. Nevertheless, a huge boost in Fox's stock.

Stock down: The offensive line

From a pass protection standpoint, it was much better, but a lot of that can be attributed to Scotty Fox getting the ball out extremely quickly. There was nothing in the run game, though, and that put more pressure on the true freshman quarterback's plate. Donovan Haslam got the start at left guard in place of Walter Young Bear, and Malik Agbo started in place of Ty'Kieast Crawford — both showed some good things, but not nearly enough, as the same problems continued with clogged up running lanes.

Stock up: WR Cam Vaughn

It's been a long time since the Mountaineers were able to uncork Vaughn, and tonight, it finally happened. Fox established a connection with him early in the second half and made some big-time catches, while also drawing some flags on the defense.

Stock up: The tight ends

It's been a brutal season for this group in both aspects, receiving and blocking. Tonight was much better, particularly in the pass game. Grayson Barnes, Jacob Barrick, and Ryan Ward each got involved, becoming a bit of a security blanket for Fox at times.

Stock down: QB Khalil Wilkins

This probably seems unfair because he didn't play, but with the way Fox performed, it's hard to see Wilkins getting healthy and then overtaking him, assuming he continues to improve. Fox is much further along in his development as a passer despite being a year younger. WVU needs to have a true dual-threat operating this offense, and Fox gives them that.

MORE STORIES FROM WEST VIRGINIA ON SI

Pat McAfee Stepped Up After a Major Donor Failed to Deliver for WVU Football

Three Key Ingredients for West Virginia to Shock TCU This Weekend

WVU in the NBA: Javon Small Proves He Belongs, McBride Earns First Start of Season 

Honor Huff Caught Fire at WVU’s Ballin' at Woodburn with a Dazzling Shooting Display

Could Tonight be Max Brown’s Moment? Here’s What to Expect if WVU Keeps QB Trend Alive