Cleveland Browns' epic fail of new helmet feels staged based on video evidence

In this story:
The Cleveland Browns did the most Cleveland Browns thing ever with their new alternate helmet reveal today. Or they made a big splash.
Most of the headlines from today hit that kind of theme after a photographer fell into Lake Erie for the "Alpha Dawg" helmet reveal promotion for the cursed franchise's alternate uniform.
RELATED: Pittsburgh Steelers new alternate uniforms are ugliest ones in the NFL

At first, it seemed like an unintentional misstep from a club full of missteps, but now new angles of the mistake by the lake, part two, feel like it was all staged.
Most of the viral clips from today came from WKYC, a local Cleveland television station, showing the big reveal promotion.
RELATED: Browns' Shedeur Sanders posts cryptic midnight training video with QB battle lyrics
The Cleveland Browns can't even get an alternate helmet reveal right pic.twitter.com/zv1428HnEm
— NFL Memes (@NFL_Memes) July 23, 2025
But let's take a closer look at some other angles.
Suspicious angle No. 1 - footage released of the dude falling into Lake Erie
So this photographer, who accidentally fell into Lake Erie, is already uploading the first-hand angle?
RELATED: $230M Browns bust Deshaun Watson reveals first-hand details on his gaudy wedding
The Cleveland Browns' new helmet reveal was a real splash... pic.twitter.com/1WbsyRQR2y
— SportsLogos.net (@sportslogosnet) July 24, 2025
Sure today's smartphones are all water resistant, but that's awfully convenient that a perfectly clear version already found its way onto social media within hours of the original epic fail.
Suspicious angle No. 2 - the mascot looks ready to be shocked
Another angle, again, at the ready, has a perfect angle of the photographer falling in. Now look at the Browns mascot's reaction. It feels like Chomps knows it's coming and reacts accordingly, like hey, be ready for the photog to walk right off the barge into Lake Erie.
Safe to say the Cleveland Browns’ new helmet made a splash 😂pic.twitter.com/hVkHk7J13n
— NFL Retweet (@NFLRT) July 23, 2025
Suspicious angle No. 3 - a waverunner is there to immediately grab him
From the original WKYC footage, if you watch closely, the photographer that falls into the lake is immediately picked up by a very official looking waverunner.
Much to the delight of Chomps and the Dude Wipes mascot, a man who fell off the dock during the Cleveland Browns' "Alpha Dawg" helmet reveal was quickly rescued by a jet ski. pic.twitter.com/3XbcHb62BH
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) July 23, 2025
We are not the first outlet to suggest this, as Deadspin also had a tweet asking if it was staged,
This Cleveland Browns helmet reveal is staged, right? pic.twitter.com/EF7Li1WMB3
— Deadspin (@Deadspin) July 23, 2025
Based on the video angles, it seems like it had to be planned out beforehand. And hey, it worked. There was exponentially more coverage of the new alternate uniforms thanks to a photographer taking a little dip.
The #Browns announced their new all-brown alternate helmet that will be worn with an all-brown jersey combination during the 2025 season.
— FOX Sports: NFL (@NFLonFOX) July 23, 2025
(📸 via @Browns) pic.twitter.com/7XV4wniBFB
— Enjoy free dish of rich and fabulous players with The Athlete Lifestyle on SI —
Just like pops: Ayesha Curry shares baby Cai photo looking exactly like dad Steph
Cute couple: Paige Bueckers holds Azzi Fudd’s in adorable behind-the-scenes video
Speaking of…: Russell Wilson’s kids, wife Ciara do matching all-black fit photo for dad
Wowza: Serena Williams unrecognizable from playing days with new trimmed look
Awww: Brittany Mahomes gushes over cute baby Golden reunion after Miami trip

Matthew Graham has over 20 years of media experience and oversees The Athlete Lifestyle On SI. He has had previous leadership roles at NBC Sports, Yahoo, and USA TODAY, where he co-founded For The Win (named Best Mobile Site by Digiday). He has also written for ESPN, Cosmopolitan, US Weekly, People, E! Online, and FHM, covering major sports and entertainment events like the Oscars, the Golden Globes, NBA Finals, Super Bowl, and winning the Yahoo Superstar Award for coverage of the Olympics.