Colts vs. Steelers Best NFL Prop Bets and Anytime Touchdown Scorer Picks for NFL Week 9

Iain MacMillan | Nov 1, 2025

Bet on Jonathan Taylor to go over his rushing yards total against the Steelers in Week 9. / Robert Goddin-Imagn Images

The Indianapolis Colts have been the hottest team to start the NFL season, and they'll look to keep their momentum going in Week 9 action when they face the Pittsburgh Steelers in an AFC showdown.

You can find out my best overall bet for this game in this week's edition of the Road to 272 Bets. If you want my top three player props for this Sunday afternoon showdown, you'll find them below.

Colts vs. Steelers Best NFL Prop Bets

• Jonathan Taylor OVER 93.5 Rush Yards (-114) via FanDuel
• DK Metcalf Longest Reception OVER 25.5 Yards (-110) via BetMGM
• Daniel Jones Anytime Touchdown (+340) via FanDuel

Jonathan Taylor OVER 93.5 Rush Yards (-114)

Jonathan Taylor is having a career year so far this NFL season. He's already racked up 850 yards on the ground, which is good for 5.9 yards per carry and 106.3 yards per game. He's poised to have another strong game against a Steelers defense that has been average at best at stopping the run this season, ranking 17th in opponent yards per carry (4.3).

DK Metcalf Longest Reception OVER 25.5 Yards (-110)

As good as the Colts have been this season, they've allowed opposing teams to complete some deep passes against them. They've given up 28 passing plays of 20+ yards, which is tied for the second most amongst all teams. If that continues in Week 9, DK Metcalf will be in a good position to create at least one explosive play. He has a reception of 26+ yards in three games already this season.

Daniel Jones Anytime Touchdown (+340)

I'm surprised we're able to get Daniel Jones at +340 odds to score a touchdown, considering the Colts' quarterback has already scored with his legs four times this season. As a whole, he's run 30 times this season for 86 yards, so don't be surprised he tries to get it in himself if/when the Colts get close to the goalline.

---

With the latest FanDuel promo code new-user offer, you can place a $5 wager and win $300 in bonus bets. Create your new FanDuel account today to lock in this impressive welcome offer from one of the top sportsbooks in the nation.

Odds refresh periodically and are subject to change.

If you or someone you know has a gambling problem and wants help, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

You can check out all of Iain's bets here!