Three Strikes: Bumgarner takes his place in World Series lore

Madison Bumgarner becomes a World Series legend, Ned Yost shows a new side, and more notes from a thrilling Game 7 of the World Series.

Tom Verducci | Oct 30, 2014

Three Strikes: Bumgarner takes his place in World Series lore /

KANSAS CITY, Mo. — Just when Madison Bumgarner seemed as good as back home on his North Carolina farm feeding his horses and cows, San Francisco centerfielder Gregor Blanco played matador to Alex Gordon's bull of a single, and suddenly, the Royals had the tying run at third base with two out in the bottom of the ninth inning in Game 2,462 of 2014, otherwise known as World Series Game 7, on Wednesday night. The Giants' closer, Santiago Casilla, warmed in the bullpen, essentially for his next Cactus League appearance for all the chance he had of displacing Bumgarner. Fittingly for a series that went the distance but was parsimonious with memorable moments, we finally got Hitchcock's definition of drama: life with the dull parts left out.

What happened next was the last thrilling chapter of one of the greatest pitching stories ever told, right up there with Mathewson, Koufax, Morris and the Big Unit. Pitching on two days' rest in his 40th game and 270th inning of the season, Bumgarner threw one more high fastball to Salvador Perez in a hailstorm of high fastballs, and Perez popped it up.

For a brief moment as the ball rose, exhausted its climb and then fell like the first leaf of fall, the entire sport was thrown back a hundred years or more, back when men with long antiquated names such as Mordecai and Orval and Deacon and Cy and the lot of them knew nothing about pitch counts, innings limits or short rest. When the ball landed in the glove of San Francisco third baseman Pablo Sandoval, Bumgarner officially joined the company of the game's greatest World Series legends, no matter how long dead some of them may be.

Bumgarner threw 68 pitches and five shutout innings on two days of rest after throwing 117 pitches and nine shutout innings in Sunday's Game 5. His age and his career World Series ERA are now the same: 25, though for official record-keeping purposes the ERA goes in the record book as 0.25.

Where Madison Bumgarner's stellar World Series ranks all-time

Pitchers just don't pitch like this any more. Not even close. This year began with a torrent of Tommy John surgeries, with some of the best young pitchers in the game blowing out their elbows from too much work, too little work, too much travel ball, too much velocity, too much training, too much … well, too much of whatever theory was in vogue that particular week. Pitchers break down. Even Bumgarner's former rotation mates, Matt Cain and Tim Lincecum, no longer started for the Giants by the time the postseason started.

But Bumgarner stepped out of the bullpen of manager Bruce Bochy in the fifth inning Wednesday night, like a gunslinger out of a lawless Dodge, and from that moment on, the game was going to be played on his terms, which is to say unlike the standard operating procedures in today's game. It was now a game without governors.

"At first I was concerned," said Dick Tidrow, the Giants' pitching guru and assistant to the general manager. "He didn't have that premium fastball at the top of the zone. The first hitter or two it was 91, 92, and I thought, 'Uh-oh.' But he quickly found it. And when he can throw that fastball upstairs at 93, then he's in business. When I saw that, I knew he was good.

"He has the kind of fastball that is made for October. Hitters want to be heroes this time of year. They want to get the hit. And when they see the fastball up they want to swing. But he gets it up enough and hard enough that they can't hit it. It plays well this time of year."

Pitchers just aren't trained to do what Bumgarner did, and managers, who have a patellar reflex to summon their closer "because that's the way we did it all year," aren't comfortable sticking with a starting pitcher in relief on two days' rest with the tying run at third. And yet you knew there was no other way — no way Bochy was pulling Bumgarner, and no way Bumgarner was giving in.

After Bumgarner threw the eighth inning, neither Bochy nor pitching coach Dave Righetti nor catcher Buster Posey bothered to ask him how he was feeling. This was Bumgarner's game. It was his game in the ninth, as much as it was his game in the eighth, as much as it will be his game in perpetuity.

One hundred five miles north from Kauffman Stadium, up Interstate 35, eternally rests the Father of Game 7, Babe Adams. On Oct. 19, 1909, in the first decisive World Series Game 7 ever played, Adams took the ball for Pittsburgh at Bennett Field in Detroit against the Tigers. He threw a six-hit shutout for his third complete game win of the series. A rookie at 27, Adams pitched that game on two days of rest.

Adams was buried in Mount Moriah, Mo., the town he grew up in starting as a teen. The locals from Mount Moriah (population from the most recent census: 87) renamed a portion of the local thoroughfare Babe Adams Highway.

Maybe someday they will name roads after Bumgarner or build statues in his honor. But no miles of asphalt or hunks of bronze or stone can match the honor he gained for himself in Game 7. Bumgarner is now a fixed part of the game's oral history. He is as much a part of the perpetual intrinsic drama of Game 7 as Mazeroski and Morris — or, for that matter, Babe Adams.

Scintillating Bumgarner proves the ultimate World Series difference

In 1962, Peanuts illustrator and Giants fan Charles Schulz sketched a classic daily comic. For three panels, Charlie Brown and Linus are seated on a curb with their chin in their hands, deep in apparent sorrow. In the fourth panel, Charlie Brown finally speaks, and when he does he is yelling at the heavens: "Why couldn't McCovey have hit the ball three feet higher!"

Game 7 stays with you like that. The 1962 World Series ended with the tying run at third base: San Francisco slugger Willie McCovey lining out to Yankees second baseman Bobby Richardson. It is one of only three World Series Games 7 to end with the tying run on third. This was the third one, and the first win for the Giants in five tries in a World Series that went the distance. It was the antithesis of 1962. Instead of McCovey lining out, it was Bumgarner carrying the Giants to victory. It will live on forever.

• SI.com's game-by-game postseason recaps and analysis

2. A surprising October hero

The World Series offered fans several breakout names to learn about, such as San Francisco second baseman Joe Panik, Kansas City outfielder Lorenzo Cain and Kansas City manager Ned Yost.

Wait. Yost? The same guy the Brewers fired with two weeks left in the 2008 pennant race? Yes, that Yost, who made one of the more startling transformations ever known to the managerial business. The gruff man who caused his Brewers teams and first two Royals teams to play tight deserves credit for establishing one the most confident, loose group of players to be found anywhere in the big leagues.

"I don't think you could ever pan [a camera] in the dugout and not see our guys laughing and smiling," said Yost, who took over in Kansas City in 2010. "They enjoy playing the game. They play the game like they did when they were 12 years old. I think people appreciate that."

Despite his detractors, Ned Yost takes Royals to unexpected heights

Yost's confidence inspired his team where his persnickety ways once dragged it down. Each day with our FOX broadcast crew, Yost gave us a glimpse into his easygoing manner by telling charming and touching stories, especially how he once served on the pit crew of friend Dale Earnhardt, Sr. in the final eight races of the season.

"Rehydration engineer," was how Yost described his title for the late NASCAR legend. Translation: water boy. It was his job to extend a cup of electrolyte fluid to Earnhardt when the driver pulled into the pits.

"I thought I knew how to compete," Yost said. "I learned more about what it means to compete from that man that I knew in my entire life. We spent so much time just talking. The crew would be working on the car and we would just sit and chat. I once asked him who his friends were on the racing circuit. He said, 'No one.' I said, 'Come on. All these hours at the track and around these guys, and no one?' He told me, 'Nope. And here's why: When they see me in their mirror coming up behind them, I never want them to think that's a friend behind them.'"

Yost is only the latest of many examples why a manager on his second job is a better bet than a manager on his first. He brought Kansas City to the playoffs, something none of its 11 managers over the previous 29 years could do. He projected confidence and calmness, which never was more apparent than after his team's Game 5 loss on Sunday, when he said he could not be disappointed because deep inside, as a fan, he was rooting for a Game 7.

Yost's game management wasn't an issue in the World Series, at least to anyone who wasn't a micro-managing second guesser. (Don't blame him for the curious Alcides Escobar bunt in the fifth inning Wednesday night with a runner at first; Escobar bunted on his own.) On the contrary, the Royals proved to be a worthy opponent to the more experienced Giants. They were fun to watch, what with their speed, defense and enthusiasm — and even their new-look manager.

3. News and notes

• The Giants somehow won the World Series despite their starting pitchers lasting a total of 16 1/3 innings in the five games not started by Bumgarner. Ryan Vogelsong was out before the third inning ended in Game 4, and both Jake Peavy, who has the worst postseason ERA in history, and Tim Hudson, who won just two of his last 22 starts, failed to survive the second inning in Games 6 and 7, respectively. All three were at least four games worse than .500 in the regular season. No other World Series team ever started more than one such pitcher.

Royals fall short in World Series but still manage to make history

• Here's a Giants scout on Lorenzo Cain: "That guy has only scratched the surface. There's something in his swing that makes him a little long in the back, but if he catches the ball out front better — just makes a slight adjustment — he's going to be a 30-home run guy. And I didn't know he was this good on defense."

• Here's another Giants scout on the Royals: "They were the better team. But it's like Tim Hudson said before we played Washington: It's not the better team on paper that counts, it's the [guts] of the guys doing the playing."

• Some numbers to ponder about Bochy's 2010-14 Giants, who have now won three world championships in five seasons: They went 34-14 overall in the postseason, won 10 straight postseason matchups and went 13-2 in one-run games, 34-7 when not allowing any unearned runs, 13-2 in games decided by their bullpen and 29-4 when scoring more than two runs. But no, it's not a dynasty. You can't take two of five years off and be a dynasty. But so what? They are the first NL team in seven decades to win three titles in five years. That's impressive enough; you don't need to force the label "dynasty" on them.

• What another masterful job of game management by Bochy. You just are not supposed to win a World Series game when your starting pitcher gets only five outs. Until Game 7, teams played .250 baseball in those dire straits (16-48, including 0-7 since 1984).

• Giants hitting coach Hensley Meulens thanked catcher Buster Posey for grinding through a postseason in which Posey never managed an extra-base hit. Posey broke the record of David Eckstein of the 2002 Angels for the most at-bats in one postseason with no extra-base hits (69). "He was dead tired," Meulens said. "The same thing happened to [Royals catcher Salvador] Perez. These guys are just worn down. For that last out, I still felt good. Perez was worn down just like our guy. I told Buster, ‘You helped make us world champions. That matters most.'"

SI's Best Photos From Game 7 of the 2014 World Series

Madison Bumgarner and Buster Posey celebrate after the final out. Bumgarner made his much-anticipated appearance out of the bullpen, throwing five innings on two days' rest to preserve a one-run lead, as the San Francisco Giants beat the Royals 3-2 in Kansas City.

With the tying run on third, Pablo Sandoval caught a fly ball in foul territory to end the game and set off a San Francisco celebration.

The Giants are the first team to win Game 7 of the World Series on the road since Pittsburgh in 1979. Their feat broke a streak of nine straight Game 7 wins by the home team.

The Giants were dubbed a "Band of Misfits" in 2010 when they defeated Texas to win the franchise's first title since 1954 in New York. Two years later, they swept Detroit for another championship. And now they're the first team to win three in a five-year span since the Yankees won four rings from 1996 to 2000. (Text credit: AP)

A San Francisco contingent with seats behind the Giants' dugout relished the victory.

Hunter Pence and teammates have this routine down to a science now.

Michael Morse takes a champagne shower.

Free-agent third baseman Pablo Sandoval celebrates what could be his last playoff win with the Giants.

The Giants have even more celebrations awaiting them in California.

Two days after throwing 117 pitches in a complete-game shutout, Madison Bumgarner came out of the pen and hurled five more scoreless innings on 68 pitches to keep Kansas City at bay.

Bumgarner dropped his record-low career World Series ERA to 0.25.

Joe Panik make a superb defensive play with the game tied at 2-2 in the third inning, flipping the ball out of his glove to start a double play.

Joe Panik and Brandon Crawford turned two double plays in Game 7.

Michael Morse reacts after hitting a run-scoring single in the fourth inning to give the Giants their 3-2 lead.

Royals catcher Sandoval Perez falls down in pain after being hit above the knee in the second inning.

The Royals weren't immediately sure if their veteran catcher would be able to stay in the game.

Perez gets escorted toward first base. He shook off the pain and remained in the game but was held hitless on the night.

Hunter Pence slides into third safely after a fly ball to left.

The heads-up play in the second inning helped Kansas City erase a 2-0 deficit.

Pablo Sandoval was late with the tag on Gordon.

Pablo Sandoval was hit by a pitch and had three hits on the night.

Pablo Sandoval set a new postseason record by getting 26 hits during the Giants' playoff run.

In addition to his three hits in Game 7, Pablo Sandoval scored twice, including the winning run after taking third on a fly out to left by Brandon Belt.

Sandoval's success in the World Series can only help him in free agency.

After Omar Infante greeted Madison Bumgarner with a leadoff single to start off the fifth, Alcides Escobar laid down this sacrifice bunt.

Royals second baseman Omar Infante barehanded this ball in an attempt to throw out Pablo Sandoval at first.

Unfortunately for Infante, he lost his balance and didn't get enough on the throw.

Alex Gordon broke out of his hitting slump and went 2-for-3 with an RBI and a run scored.

Gordon's run tied the game at 2 in the bottom of the second.

Alcides Escobar is forced out at second by Brandon Crawford.

Alex Gordon was hit by a Jeremy Affeldt pitch in the fourth inning.

Hunter Pence scores in the top of the second to give San Francisco a 2-0 lead.

Buster Posey's bat splintered during one of his at-bats.

Omar Infante struggles to get to a ball.

Billy Butler scored on an Alex Gordon double to give the Royals their first run.

His run got most of the crowd of 40,535 pumped up as they rooted for a win by the hometown team.

Even though he was safe on the slide, Butler made doubly sure by touching home plate with his hand.

Mike Moustakas and the Royals reached the first all-wild card World Series by bouncing back from being two games under .500 in mid-July.

Lorenzo Cain tries to break up a double-play throw by Brandon Crawford.

Joe Panik made his major league debut in May and five months later is a World Series champion.

Madison Bumgarner works his magic.

Mike Moustakas breaks his bat while facing Bumgarner in the seventh inning. The Royals got only two hits against him in Game 7.

Kelvin Herrera struck out four Giants in 2 2/3 innings after relieving starter Jeremy Guthrie.

The officials await a replay ruling from the command center in New York on a close play at first. The call was reversed, resulting in an out.

Tim Hudson, at 39 the oldest Game 7 starter, allowed two runs in 1 2-3 innings. (Text credit: AP)

The 35-year-old Guthrie took the loss, giving up three runs in 3 1-3 innings. (Text credit: AP)

Former Royal Bret Saberhagen threw out the ceremonial first pitch.

Lorenzo Cain jokes around while getting a haircut before the start of the game.

Published Oct 30, 2014

TOM VERDUCCI

Tom Verducci is a senior writer for Sports Illustrated who has covered Major League Baseball since 1981. He also serves as an analyst for FOX Sports and the MLB Network; is a New York Times best-selling author; and cohosts The Book of Joe podcast with Joe Maddon. A five-time Emmy Award winner across three categories (studio analyst, reporter, short form writing) and nominated in a fourth (game analyst), he is a three-time National Sportswriter of the Year winner, two-time National Magazine Award finalist, and a Penn State Distinguished Alumnus Award recipient. Verducci is a member of the National Sports Media Hall of Fame, Baseball Writers Association of America (including past New York chapter chairman) and a Baseball Hall of Fame voter since 1993. He also is the only writer to be a game analyst for World Series telecasts. He lives in New Jersey with his wife, with whom he has two children.