Alex Rodriguez's Most Embarrassing Moments

Alex Rodriguez is retiring from baseball in mid-August 2016, whereupon he will become a special advisor/instructor for the New York Yankees. He will leave as one of the most statistically prolific players in major league history, but also one of the most controversial. Here are some of his worst moments.

SI Staff | Aug 6, 2016

Alex Rodriguez's Most Embarrassing Moments /

Alex Rodriguez's Most Embarrassing Moments

Mitt in the Face

Damian Strohmeyer for Sports Illustrated

Jason Varitek may have cemented his place in Red Sox lore when he challenged Alex Rodriguez during a July game at Fenway Park in 2004. Varitek shoved Rodriguez in the face with his glove after A-Rod objected to being hit with a Bronson Arroyo pitch, and following the subsequent brawl (in which both Varitek and Rodriguez were ejected), the Red Sox rallied to a dramatic 11-10 victory. The image can be found hanging in many a sports bar throughout New England.

The Slap

During Game 6 of the 2004 ALCS against the Red Sox, Rodriguez hit a slow roller between first base and the pitcher's mound. As Bronson Arroyo fielded the ball and tried to apply the tag, A-Rod slapped the ball from his glove. Derek Jeter, who was on first base, came around to score while Rodriguez advanced to second. The umpires huddled and ruled that A-Rod's slap was interference, forcing Jeter to return to second and nullifying the run. Boston went onto win the game and the series.

Tabloid Magnet

It's a challenge for any New York athlete to stay out of the press, something A-Rod knows all too well. In 2006, he was photographed sunbathing shirtless in Central Park. A year later, he was spotted leaving a Toronto strip club with a "mystery blonde." Days later, an exotic dancer was quoted in the New York Daily News about A-Rod's preference for the "she-male, muscular type." A year later, Cynthia Rodriguez filed for divorce, citing "extra marital affairs and other marital misconduct."

The Demotion

The Alex Rodriguez-Joe Torre relationship reached its low point during Game 4 of the 2006 ALDS against the Tigers. Stuck in a 1-for-11 slump with no RBIs, the struggling Rodriguez was moved down to eighth in the batting order by Torre. It was the lowest A-Rod had batted since May 1996, when he was a 20-year-old rookie with the Mariners. The move made little impact as Rodriguez finished the game hitless in three at-bats and Detroit knocked the Yankees out of the playoffs.

The Pop-Up

During an early-season matchup with the Blue Jays in 2007, Rodriguez got into some hot water north of the border. With two out in the ninth and the Yankees leading 10-5, Jorge Posada hit an infield pop-up. As third baseman Howie Clark settled under the ball, Rodriguez ran past him on the base path. Video replays clearly showed Rodriguez yelling something that was described by Jays on the field as "Mine!" or "I got it!" The ball dropped, a run scored and shortstop John McDonald had to be restrained from attacking Rodriguez, who insisted he only yelled, "Ha."

Stray Rod

Probably not a good idea to be spotted leaving a Toronto strip club with a busty blonde right before heading to Boston for a three-game series. Needless to say, Red Sox fans were relentless.

World Series Announcement

Rodriguez's future in New York was a hot topic throughout 2007. Agent Scott Boras had negotiated an opt-out clause after the seventh year of Rodriguez's record 10-year, $250 million deal signed in 2000. Though A-Rod had 10 days after the conclusion of the World Series to make his decision, his choice became public during the eighth inning of the deciding game between the Red Sox and the Rockies. While Boston won the game and the championship, it was overshadowed by Rodriguez and the curious timing of his announcement.

Madonna's Main Squeeze

In 2008, rumors spread about a relationship between the recently divorced Rodriguez and pop singer Madonna. The two were spotted around town together and the Yankees third baseman reportedly joined her at several Kabbalah services in New York City. But Madonna had eyes for another man and was soon dating 21-year-old Jesus Lutz. Gossip outlets soon reported that A-Rod was "embarrassed" because he was dumped for a younger guy, and fans had a field day teasing the love-struck third baseman.

Trashed by Torre

Rodriguez had a complex relationship with Yankees manager Joe Torre during their four years together, but Torre's true feelings came out with the release of his book, "The Yankee Years," in 2009. In it, the manager reveals how A-Rod monopolized all the attention in the Yankees clubhouse, and when the third baseman was at the plate in pressure situations, he was too often unable to "concern himself with getting the job done" and instead became distracted with "how it looks."

Caught Cheating

While many fans looked at Rodriguez's impressive statistics and felt they had to be attained with the help of performance-enhancing drugs, it took two SI reporters to prove it. Selena Roberts's and David Epstein's February 2009 cover story revealed that A-Rod had tested positive for two anabolic steroids -- testosterone and Primobolan -- during his 2003 season while playing for Texas. In an interview with ESPN days later, the third baseman admitted the report was true and he used banned substances from 2001 to 2003, a charge he flatly denied to Katie Couric in an interview two years later. He was not punished by Commissioner Bud Selig because the test was supposed to be anonymous and there was no mechanism in place at the time for disciplinary action.

The Centaur

Walter Iooss Jr. for Sports Illustrated; Colin Anderson/Brand X/Getty Images; Composite by Dave Kaye

In one of the more embarrassing revelations about Rodriguez, a former A-Rod fling told US Weekly in 2009 that the player had two painted portraits of himself as a centaur hanging above his bed. "He was so vain," the ex told the magazine. "He had not one, but two painted portraits of himself as a centaur. You know, the half man, half horse figure? It was ridiculous."

In Love With His Mirrror

A-Rod's image took another hit in 2009, when he was featured in a Details magazine photo spread kissing a mirror and stretching shirtless on a bare mattress.

The Secret of His Success

By the 2009 postseason, Rodriguez had developed a reputation as a hitter unable to deliver in the clutch. But in 15 glorious games, A-Rod played like a superstar, batting .335 with six home runs in leading the Yankees to a World Series title. Credit for the turnaround was not attributed to the extra work A-Rod put in or his increasing maturity as a player. Instead it was given to girlfriend Kate Hudson, who was seen as a human good luck charm for Yankee fans. The good luck ran out a couple months after the Series, however, as the third baseman reportedly dumped the actress.

Walking Across the Mound

Michael Zagaris/SI; Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

Rodriguez angered A's pitcher Dallas Braden when he broke the unwritten rule of not walking across an opposing team's pitcher's mound. The incident occurred in the sixth inning of an early-season game in 2010. A-Rod went from first to third on a foul ball by Robinson Cano. On his trip back to first base, Rodriguez walked over the mound. After a double play ended the inning, Braden started yelling at A-Rod, who later said he'd never heard of the rule. When asked about it after the game, Braden suggested Rodriguez "take a note from his captain" and not do it again.

The Popcorn Show

Rodriguez attended Super Bowl XLV with Hollywood girlfriend Cameron Diaz in 2011. As cameras panned to the happy couple, Diaz was shown feeding popcorn to the Yankees third baseman. The video soon went viral and A-Rod reportedly went ballistic, saying the Fox cameras were out to embarrass him.

Have a Baseball....For Your Number

2012-Alex-Rodriguez-op60-295-Kate-Quinn-Kyna-Treacy-inset.jpg — Al Tielemans for Sports Illustrated

He may have been benched late in the ALCS opener, but A-Rod found something to do while sitting out of the game: Flirting with a woman in the stands near the dugout, later identified as Kyna Treacy (inset right), an Australian bikini model. According to The New York Post, A-Rod reportedly asked a ball boy to give a baseball to Treacy and her Aussie friend, Kate Quinn (inset left), with a note asking for Treacy's phone number.

Suspended

On Aug. 5, 2013, the day of A-Rod's return from injury to baseball, Major League Baseball announced its suspension of Rodriguez through the end of the 2014 season for violating the Joint Drug Agreement. A-Rod's suspension is the longest non-lifetime ban in baseball history and by far the longest ever handed down under the JDA. Rodriguez appealed the suspension and played for the Yankees through Sept. 25. He would miss the entire 2014 season.

Ratter Up

Within two weeks of A-Rod's suspension, "60 Minutes" reported that his inner circle obtained and leaked documents implicating Ryan Braun and Yankees teammate Francisco Cervelli in the Biogenesis scandal just days after the Miami New Times detailed Rodriguez's use of performance enhancing drugs.

Published Aug 6, 2016

SI STAFF