The MMQB's 2017 NFL Awards

Our panel of 15 MMQB and Sports Illustrated staffers cast ballots to decide every NFL award, from MVP to Rookies of the Year to Executive of the Year to the season's Biggest Disappointment
Author:
Publish date:

With the regular season in the books, our panel of 15 writers and editors cast their ballots for the 2017 NFL awards—some traditional, some MMQB originals. Unlike AP voting, out voters cast ranked ballots, rather than just one name, for every award. Point totals are based on a 10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1 scale for MVP, and either 5-4-3-2-1 or 3-2-1 for the rest of the honors.

Image placeholder title

MOST VALUABLE PLAYER

tom-brady-mvp.jpg

The actual vote might be closer, but Tom Brady won our vote by a comfortable margin. His closest competitor, Todd Gurley, did not garner a single first-place vote. Only Brady and Carson Wentz appeared on all 15 ballots.

mvp.jpg
mvp-votes.jpg
Image placeholder title

OFFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR

todd-gurley-opoy.jpg

For our vote, we limited OPOY to non-quarterbacks only.

off-player.jpg
off-player-VOTE.jpg
Image placeholder title

DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR

calais-campbell-jaguars.jpg

Aaron Donald had the most first-place votes, but it was Calais Campbell taking the award.

def-player.jpg
def-player-VOTE.jpg
Image placeholder title

OFFENSIVE ROOKIE OF THE YEAR

alvin-kamara-oroy.jpg

Alvin Kamara appeared first or second on every ballot, enough to hold off rushing champion Kareem Hunt.

off-rookie.jpg
off-rookie-VOTE.jpg
Image placeholder title

DEFENSIVE ROOKIE OF THE YEAR

marshon-lattimore-defensive-rookie.jpg

Marshon Lattimore won by a comfortable margin, though Bills CB Tre'Davious White was the only defensive rookie to appear on all 15 ballots.

def-rookie.jpg
def-rookie-VOTE.jpg
Image placeholder title

COACH OF THE YEAR

sean-mcvay-coach-of-the-year.jpg

Sean McVay won the voting by a wide margin, though five different coaches received first-place votes.

coach.jpg
coach-VOTE.jpg
Image placeholder title

ASSISTANT COACH OF THE YEAR

pat-shurmur-vikings.jpg

For unleashing Case Keenum's potential, Vikings offensive coordinator (and current head-coaching candidate) Pat Shurmur takes the honors.

assistant-coach.jpg
assistant-coach-VOTE.jpg
Image placeholder title

EXECUTIVE OF THE YEAR

howie-roseman-executive.jpg

It took Howie Roseman just two offseasons to build the Eagles into a powerhouse, needing only 15 games to clinch the NFC's top seed.

executive.jpg
executive-VOTE.jpg
Image placeholder title

SPECIAL TEAMS PLAYER OF THE YEAR

greg-zuerlein.jpg

The Rams dominate the voting, taking each of the top three spots.

special-teams.jpg
special-teams-VOTE.jpg
Image placeholder title

MOST IMPROVED PLAYER

jared-goff-most-improved.jpg

Another win for the Rams, as Goff wins by a comfortable margin, with a couple of quarterbacks trailing in the second and third spots.

improved.jpg

improved-VOTE.jpg

Image placeholder title

MOST DISAPPOINTING PLAYER

derek-carr-disappointing.jpg

A landslide "victory" for Carr, who slid back significantly in what was supposed to be an MVP-type campaign. Teammate Amari Cooper wasn't far behind, in a receiver-heavy vote.

disappointment.jpg

disappointment-VOTE.jpg

Image placeholder title

The voters:

Ben Baskin, NFL Reporter
Andy Benoit, Analyst and Staff Writer
Greg Bishop, Senior Writer
Andrew Brandt, Business of Football Columnist
Albert Breer, Senior Reporter
John DePetro, NFL Video Producer
Jacob Feldman, NFL Reporter
Gary Gramling, Senior Editor
Jonathan Jones, Staff Writer
Kalyn Kahler, Editorial Assistant
Peter King, Editor-In-Chief
Robert Klemko, NFL Writer
Conor Orr, Staff Writer
Tim Rohan, NFL Writer
Jenny Vrentas, Senior Writer

• Question or comment? Email us at talkback@themmqb.com.