NFL Fans's Dubious Reaction to Dan Quinn's One-Yard Catch Challenge Didn't Age Well

A game of inches.

Dan Quinn made an interesting challenge against the Bears on 'Monday Night Football' / Paul Rutherford-Imagn Images

Challenging a one-yard completion on first down isn't advised, but Commanders coach Dan Quinn did just that in the second quarter of Washington's Monday Night Football game against the Bears.

The challenge was successful, nullifying a one-yard catch by running back D'Andre Swift to turn a second-and-9 play into second-and-10. Sounds silly, right? Well, the move turned out to prove consequential, as the Commanders forced fourth-and-1 two plays later and got a big fourth-down stop to hold Chicago scoreless on the drive.

NFL fans quickly questioned Quinn's challenge, but it turned into a funny moment shortly thereafter when the single yard actually mattered:

Dan Quinn bringing the world together one action at a time pic.twitter.com/llrNqGXzAS

— Andrew Hall (@AndrewHallFF) October 14, 2025

how dan quinn feels after challenging a catch that went for 1 yard pic.twitter.com/WxZTV6kpto

— ruby (@rubythevalley) October 14, 2025

Dan Quinn challenging a one yard difference pic.twitter.com/q71D7yNXZY

— JD5/Lile FC #RaiseHail (@CommandersMuse) October 14, 2025

Dan Quinn 0-2 on challenges this year just needed to see one go through the hoop we've all been there

— Ian Hartitz (@Ihartitz) October 14, 2025

dan quinn playing against deandre swift in a ppr league

— nick ercolano (@nickercolano) October 14, 2025

Maybe Dan Quinn was a genius after all for using that challenge 🧠

— brandon (@JayDanielsMVP) October 14, 2025

Maybe Dan Quinn's decision to challenge for one yard wasn't so outlandish after all...

— Alex Shapiro (@AlexShapiro____) October 14, 2025

Quinn was pretty fired up after his team got the stop, which made the funky challenge pay off:

Dan Quinn was hype after that 4th down stop pic.twitter.com/yXLnudtSLD

— COMMANDERS FOOTBALL (@HogsHaven) October 14, 2025

Unfortunately for the Commanders, they weren't able to score after the turnover on downs, driving down to Chicago's 32-yard line before Matt Gay's 50-yard field goal attempt clanked off the left upright. Quinn's move still mattered, though, as it helped keep more points off the board for the Bears, who opened the game with 13 straight points before the Commanders scored a touchdown to cut the lead to 13-7 at the half.

---

More NFL on Sports Illustrated

feed