Does Winning the Community Shield Lead to Premier League Success?

Sunday August 6th, 2017

Since the Premier League's inception in 1992, 25 Community Shield matches have been played in what is ultimately a glorified friendly, not a season defining game as history proves. Of the winners, only seven teams went on to win the league, and of the winners, only two clubs, Chelsea [2] and Manchester United [5] have achieved this feat. 

The most recent team was, in fact, Sir Alex Ferguson's final title winning team of 2013, which saw off Wigan Athletic 2-0 for the season's curtain opener. With this previous stat in mind, do Chelsea or Arsenal have what it takes to buck the trend and go on to win the league?

Shaun Botterill/GettyImages

Chelsea will be looking for a more successful title defense this time around, after Jose Mourinho's title winning team of 2014/15 famously collapsed the next season, finishing 10th. With Antonio Conte at the helm, this is unlikely of repeating, already stirring things up amongst the squad to keep players on their toes. While maintaining the quality within the squad, Conte has added Antonio Rüdiger and Tiémoué Bakayoko to the fold for added competition.

 

Even more importantly, Chelsea have kept hold of two of the best players in the league, which will clearly aid a title defense. Eden Hazard, who was sensational last season, was given more freedom to attack in Conte's 3-4-3. Of course, N'Golo Kante is worth mentioning, who adapted his passing game superbly after his move from Champions Leicester City and was everywhere defensively as usual. 

Conte was prepared to exile his first choice striker Diego Costa without second thought, and now with Alvaro Morata acquired, the loss of his 20 goals in the Premier League last season seems less bitter. The manager's attempt to both cleanse and evolve the squad should ensure that determination is kept within the camp to defend this title. Furthermore, that he is able to maintain his reputation and his relationship with the dressing room, something Mourinho lost. 

 

Michy Batshuayi has been especially impressive in pre-season, and after being sidelined last season could finally be given a chance in blue, with the addition of Champions League football. Netting twice against Arsenal in a 3-0 pre-season win, the 23-year-old looked sharp in front of goal with powerful but precise finishing. You could certainly make the argument that Chelsea will be even better equipped up front this season. 

OLLY GREENWOOD/GettyImages

It's certainly the same case for Arsenal, who broke their record transfer fee to bring Alexandre Lacazette to the Emirates for £52.7m. The added firepower that the Frenchman brings could just be that missing piece that will return the Premier League to Arsenal's clutches. Having not won a league title since the "Invincibles" of 2003/04, Lacazette will look to emulate Arsenal legend Thierry Henry's 30 goal season. 

 

Amidst the turmoil of last season, Arsene Wenger's two-year contract extension following the FA Cup win disgruntled some fans but the added security and knowledge of the club's direction should steady the ship. Wenger has added well to his squad, plugging the obvious gaps within, especially at left back with Sead Kolasinac.

Arsenal are preparing to mimic Chelsea's three at the back triumphs; the formation deployed by Wenger at the tail end of last season ultimately saved his job. The formation has proved somewhat successful in pre-season, a controversial Emirates Cup win saw Arsenal win the tournament on goals scored. Having beat Benfica 5-2, the loss to Sevilla was made redundant, unfortunately for Arsenal, the Community Shield isn't won solely on goals scored.  

 

A repeat fixture of what we saw in the FA Cup Final last term will certainly be an exciting one that's for sure. During pre-season, Chelsea dispatched of Arsenal in a less competitive 3-0 win, but with Wembley watching and the world anticipating the outcome of the new season. There's a lot more on the line than you might expect.

SI Apps
We've Got Apps Too
Get expert analysis, unrivaled access, and the award-winning storytelling only SI can provide—from Peter King, Tom Verducci, Lee Jenkins, Andy Staples, Grant Wahl, and more—delivered straight to you, along with up-to-the-minute news and live scores.