Fantasy Tennis: Building the Ideal Player for 2011

The exercise of constructing the perfect tennis organism by cherry-picking assets from history's greatest players has been done for so long that most veteran fans can skip the thinking and rattle it off by heart: Sampras for serve, Agassi for return game, McEnroe for net play, etc.

But what if you were trying to build the best player for 2011, based on today's players and current form?

We asked's tennis experts to design a player for the unique challenges of today's game. The one ground rule: you could only pick one attribute from a given player. The process was a series of difficult choices -- Serena for mental toughness or forehand? Where to play the Federer card? -- but the result presents a revealing look at the state of tennis entering the 2011 season.

First, their picks for the men's tour:

Serve: Ivo Karlovic Basic geometry: There's no substituting a delivery from FAA-jurisdiction.

Return game: Andy Murray Compact strokes and uncanny anticipation.

Forehand: Juan Martin del Potro (Wrist willing.) Nothing flashy, not a lot of spin. Just pure power.

Backhand: Novak Djokovic For sheer precision; over Stan Wawrinka for aesthetics; Tomas Berdych for power and Marat Safin for old times sake.

Net Play: Bob Bryan Yes, in part because we're saving Federer for later. But still ...

Fitness: David Ferrer He's been to cool down after runs by ... jogging.

Footwork: Roger Federer We'll play our Federer card here. So smooth and efficient.

Mental Toughness: Rafael Nadal Not even close. One stat among many: His record in slam finals? 9-2.

Serve: Andy Roddick Andy's predictable but overpowering.

Return game: Andy Murray The counterpuncher's main punch, without it he wouldn't be in the top five.

Forehand: Juan Martin del Potro When he's on, no one can handle Delpo's sledgehammer.

Backhand: Richard Gasquet Richard is the one-stroke wonder of the men's game.

Net Play: Mardy Fish The game's dying art, so Fish wins by default.

Fitness: Roger Federer The foundation of all of Fed's wonderful play.

Footwork: Novak Djokovic Would put Fed here, too, but at his best Djokovic floats like a dancer.

Mental Toughness: Rafael Nadal Without it, he wouldn't be half the player he is.

Serve: Andy Roddick He has the reputation, and consistently delivers in the clutch.

Return game: Andy Murray Magical hands; if only he attacked the way he defends.

Forehand: Robin Soderling Rides this shot straight up to the penthouse.

Backhand: Rafael Nadal His two-hander on the run, or the retreat, is one of the most amazing sights in sports.

Net Play: Michael Llodra One of the few serve-and-volleyers left, and he's coldly efficient up there.

Fitness: Nikolay Davydenko Can't stand watching him, but the man can run all day.

Footwork: Roger Federer The man is a living textbook.

Mental Toughness: John Isner From the NCAA championships to the Wimbledon marathon against Mahut, he thrives on will power.

Serve: John Isner Big John gets free points at will. If only all the Slams were on hardcourts.

Return game: Andy Murray Great hand-eye coordination and a gutsy returner.

Forehand: Fernando Gonzalez Since we've picked Federer and Nadal elsewhere, we go Gonzo here.

Backhand: Novak Djokovic The backhand is the Joker's biggest weapon.

Net Play: Bob Bryan The doubles specialist's quick hands is why he's famous worldwide.

Fitness: Nikolay Davydenko Would be happy to play every tournament.

Footwork: Roger Federer The most efficient mover in men's history.

Mental Toughness: Rafael Nadal Legendary steel when it matters most.

Serve: Ivo Karlovic Even at 31, I'll give Dr. Ivo's 6-foot-10 frame the edge over the younger Isner.

Return game: Andy Murray Peerless anticipation. No one combines offense, defense and accuracy on the return better.

Forehand: Roger Federer David Foster Wallace famously called Federer's forehand "a great liquid whip."

Backhand: Novak Djokovic The two-fisted backhand is Nole's signature stroke -- and with good reason.

Net Play: Mardy Fish We saw just how effective Fish's volleying could be in 2010, when he finally was fit enough to get into position for them consistently.

Fitness: Nikolay Davydenko Not exactly a crowd-pleaser, but no one questions his endurance. "He plays like PlayStation: he runs to everywhere," Del Potro remarked in 2009.

Footwork: David Ferrer Arguably the best in the business on clay and top flight on anything else.

Mental Toughness: Rafael Nadal Always confident and never beats himself. Ingenious control of match pace.

Serve: Rafael Nadal Would you like a side of speed to go with that topspin? No? Too bad -- no point for you!

Return game: Novak Djokovic Talk about hitting against the wall; dude can retrieve anything from just about any position.

Forehand: Robin Soderling Listen close, and you'll hear a sonic boom about 10 seconds after contact.

Backhand: Richard Gasquet It's as if he's saying "ta-da!" after every stroke; the only thing it's missing is jazz hands.

Net Play: Michael Llodra Not only kisses his volleys, but hugs ballgirls when he crashes into them.

Fitness: Roger Federer That wet patch you see on his shirtfront isn't sweat. It's condensation.

Footwork: Andy Murray Few are as graceful on the move. The trick is getting him to do it.

Mental Toughness: Andy Roddick When his mind is vaulted, he's a tough opponent to crack.

Next,'s experts craft their ideal women's player.

Serve: Venus Williams Still clocking, especially when it matters.

Return game: Vera Zvonareva A key to her late-career surge.

Forehand: Ana Ivanovic When she's getting it in the court -- which fortunately has occurred lately -- it's as good as any this side of Serena (whom we're saving).

Backhand: Justine Henin We're still suckers for beauty.

Net Play: Samantha Stosur Such an agile athlete. Just wish she'd get there more often.

Fitness: Francesca Schiavone Even at her age, she'll win matches simply by being in superior shape.

Footwork: Kim Clijsters Always a terrific mover -- and childbirth did nothing to impede her locomotion.

Mental Toughness: Serena Williams Not even close.

Serve: Serena Williams Serena's accurate and overpowering.

Return game: Caroline Wozniacki The counterpuncher's main punch, without it she wouldn't be in the top five.

Forehand: Samantha Stosur Samantha's stinger gets the job done.

Backhand: Venus Williams Henin's would be here normally, but her head is her best weapon.

Net Play: Francesca Schiavone Francesca's is a marvel of skill, whimsy and imagination.

Fitness: Kim Clijsters Clijsters, still, looks like she can run forever.

Footwork: Jelena Jankovic At her best Jankovic floats like a dancer.

Mental Toughness: Justine Henin Without it, she wouldn't be half the player she is.

Serve: Serena Williams Stronger, more accurate and more intimidating than anyone else's on tour.

Return game: Venus Williams Still one of the tour's best athletes, and it shows here.

Forehand: Samantha Stosur Gets the max out of that chiseled right arm.

Backhand: Justine Henin Her lingering elbow injury is disturbing, but nobody disputes that form.

Net Play: Francesca Schiavone So elegant and creative, so far removed from baseline tedium.

Fitness: Caroline Wozniacki There's a reason she played more often, at the elite level, than anyone else on tour.

Footwork: Kim Clijsters Always set to deliver a bullet, from either side.

Mental Toughness: Maria Sharapova Big-time fighter in a field of sheep.

Serve: Venus Williams Sister Serena has one of the best serves of all time but Venus can still crank it up when healthy.

Return game: Victoria Azarenka Belrussian has great instincts and keeps getting better.

Forehand: Kim Clijsters Momma's forehand is one of the most powerful in history.

Backhand: Justine Henin Her one-hander is the Kandinsky of the sport.

Net Play: Francesca Schiavone Flamboyant Italian has McEnroe-like skills at net.

Fitness: Samantha Stosur Get ready for the gun show: This Aussie is chiseled.

Footwork: Caroline Wozniacki The Dane is beautiful to watch on the run.

Mental Toughness: Serena Williams The toughest player in tennis, male of female.

Serve: Venus Williams Serena has grown more consistent, but Vee still has fastest serve in history.

Return game: Victoria Azarenka Ability to retreive every ball seems immunte to mental frailties that crop up in other facets.

Forehand: Samantha Stosur Which way to the gun show? Credit coach David Taylor for harnessing the latent talent in Sam's pythons.

Backhand: Kim Clijsters Henin's is sublime, but I worry about her elbow; Clijsters' two-handed version is a hammer.

Net Play: Francesca Schiavone Her charmed 2010 season was a triumph for tennis aesthetes; creative, stylish net play that belongs in the Uffizi.

Fitness: Caroline Wozniacki No one played more matches on tour in 2009 and '10. That's not an accident.

Footwork: Justine Henin Superlative balance, court coverage, tactics and ability to shift from defense to offense seamlessly.

Mental Toughness: Serena Williams The Everest of the women's tour.

Serve: Serena Williams It isn't just the WTA's most powerful and accurate, but it's also the most consistent.

Return game: Jelena Jankovic Good luck passing this 5-foot-9 condor -- especially when she's doing splits.

Forehand: Venus Williams Even more incredible than her Plasticman range is her Hulk-like force.

Backhand: Francesca Schiavone As Italian gesticulations go, this is my favorite.

Net Play: Cara Black If her touch with Liesel Huber were as soft as it is inside the service line, maybe they'd still be partners?

Fitness: Justine Henin Now that Dementieva's gone, she takes the pound-for-pound crown.

Footwork: Maria Sharapova It ain't the prettiest, but it rarely fails to get her in position to lash that massive forehand.

Mental Toughness: Kim Clijsters For as much as Mommy Dearest seems to have on her mind, it never impedes her game.

SI Apps
We've Got Apps Too
Get expert analysis, unrivaled access, and the award-winning storytelling only SI can provide - from Peter King, Tom Verducci, Lee Jenkins, Seth Davis, and more - delivered straight to you, along with up-to-the-minute news and live scores.