David Price cannot overcome his postseason struggles as the Blue Jays drop Game 2 of the ALCS to the Kansas City Royals

By Phil Taylor
October 17, 2015

KANSAS CITY — The postseason is the land of small sample sizes, where lasting judgments are often made with minimal data. A bad outing for a pitcher that would be filed and forgotten in June is taken as a possible sign of folding under pressure in October. If a hitter goes through a bad stretch in the regular season he’s just in a slump, but if he does it in the playoffs, the whispers start: Could it be that he can’t handle the big stage?

Most of this is nonsense, of course, because baseball is a game that should be assessed in big gulps, not small bites. Occasionally someone reminds us of that, as when Dodgers pitcher Clayton Kershaw, who hadn’t had nearly the postseason success that one would expect of a pitcher with three Cy Young Awards, shut down the Mets for seven innings in their playoff series last week in an elimination game for the Dodgers. Suddenly it seemed so silly, this idea that players who perform at a high level for six months suddenly get the yips in the cauldron of October.

For six innings on Saturday, it appeared that Blue Jays starter David Price, another Cy Young winner with a similarly poor postseason history, was going to duplicate Kershaw’s accomplishment, if not exceed it. Price was nearly flawless against the Kansas City Royals in Game 2 of their American League Championship Series, allowing a leadoff hit to Alcides Escobar before retiring the next 18 consecutive batters.


“He had it going on,” said Jays shortstop Troy Tulowitzki. “I mean, he was sailing.”

But in the seventh, whatever postseason gremlins have dogged Price in the past got to him again.

Royals come from behind to defeat Blue Jays in Game 2 of ALCS

Also, the Royals are very good. Trailing 3–0, they pieced together a five-run seventh that began with a botched pop-up in rightfield, on their way to a 6–3 victory that gave them a 2–0 series lead and left the Jays, particularly Price, once again shaking their heads. Afterwards, Price was asked if it was frustrating to pitch so well, then suddenly struggle.

“I don’t think I struggled,” he said evenly. “It’s frustrating, but I didn’t struggle.”

Struggle or not, the outing ended up being another in a series of postseason disappointments for Price. He has now been the losing pitcher in all seven of his career postseason starts and owns a 5.24 ERA. After pitching splendidly for Toronto after he was acquired from Detroit at the trade deadline, he has a 6.75 ERA in two starts and a three-inning relief appearance for the Jays in the playoffs.

2015 MLB postseason schedule: Start times, TV listings, recaps

“I don’t know that there’s really an explanation for it other than, ‘That’s baseball,’” said rightfielder Jose Bautista, whose miscommunication with second baseman Ryan Goins allowed Ben Zobrist’s very catchable pop-fly drop to lead off the Royals’ seventh. “Everybody knows the caliber of pitcher he is, but a bad break here or there can change everything in a ball game, no matter what time of year it is.”

As for the blown pop-up between himself and Goins? “I think there’s video,” Bautista said. “You can watch it.”

Volquez, man with a plan, surprises everyone with Game 1 dominance

​Goins was more forthcoming. In a show of accountability, he made himself immediately available as soon as the media was allowed into the Blue Jays’ clubhouse. “It’s on me,” he said, going on to explain that he called for the ball as it floated toward the foul line in short rightfield but at the last moment he thought he heard Bautista coming and he pulled up. But Price didn’t hold either of his teammates responsible.

“It didn’t change anything for me, mentally,” Price said. “Ryan’s made a lot of big plays for us. It was my job to pitch through it, and I didn’t do a very good job of that.”

The normally gregarious Price wasn’t much interested in trying to explain his postseason problems, though.

“It happens,” he said. “I was staying in the moment. I wasn’t thinking about getting the win, I was thinking about getting the next guy out. I stay in the present. I don’t worry about what happened in the past or look forward. It just didn’t work out.”

Matt Slocum/AP

It worked out perfectly for the Royals, who, in case it wasn’t clear by now, are a resilient team, awfully good at taking a small crack and turning it into a gaping hole. They did it in the seventh inning of the deciding game of the division series against Houston, when Astros shortstop Carlos Correa’s error opened the door to their decisive five-run inning. They did it again after the gaffe between Bautista and Goins.

“I felt we needed to catch a break and Zobrist’s ball got things going,” said leftfielder Alex Gordon, whose double eventually drove in the lead run. “You’ve obviously seen it before, once this lineup gets going it’s one guy after another keeping the line moving and that’s what happened.”

NLCS preview: Mets, Cubs meet in unlikely battle for NL pennant

Singles by Lorenzo Cain, Eric Hosmer and Mike Moustakas produced three runs, and Gordon drove a Price fastball in the gap in right center—“the one pitch I’d like to have back,” Price said—to give the Royals the lead for good.

“It was unfortunate,” said Jays manager John Gibbons. “You really can’t pitch a better game, to that point, anyway. Sometimes there’s that one little crack, when you’re on the road, that can open up the floodgates. He deserved better, that’s for sure.”

Or maybe it’s just that the Royals got what they deserved. Kansas City’s offense is opportunistic and loaded.

“Gordon was hitting eighth, and he’s not an eighth-place type of hitter, by any means,” Price said. “If you give them an opening, they have the kind of hitters that can take advantage.”

The story of the comeback may have been more about the Royals’ strengths than Price’s failings, but that won’t change the narrative about Price being a different pitcher in the postseason. Stories don’t matter much more than sample sizes.

If he wondered how things might have been different if that pop fly had been caught, Price wasn’t admitting it. But he did gaze blankly into the outfield after it happened.

“I know good things are coming,” he had said a day earlier, when asked about his postseason problems. As the series heads to Toronto, Price has to be wondering, “When?

Eagle (-2)
Birdie (-1)
Bogey (+1)
Double Bogey (+2)