Rating summer transfers: Di Maria, Vidal and Europe's other major moves

Big names with new home addresses: Ben Lyttleton rates 10 of the summer's most noteworthy transfers across Europe.

Author:
Ben Lyttleton
Publish date:
Aug 4, 2015

It often happens that one year before a major tournament players are more risk-averse when it comes to changing clubs, but that has not been the case this summer despite Euro 2016 looming at the end of the upcoming campaign.

Some of the biggest stars in Europe have been on the move, while certain clubs, among them Manchester United, AC Milan and Fenerbahce, have been spending big to catch up with their title rivals in hopes of securing a return to the pinnacle of their respective leagues.

Here are 10 of the biggest transfers so far this summer and how the big names fit in at their new homes:

Bastian Schweinsteiger

Bayern Munich to Manchester United, £10 million

Some deals just work for all parties and this is one of them. Bayern gets a decent fee for a 31-year-old with one year left on his deal, while Pep Guardiola has one less selection headache without the pressure of having to pick the player because he was club captain, even if he didn't have his full confidence.

Schweinsteiger's transfer could be win-win for Bayern, Man United

United gets a player looking for a new lease of life, with extra motivation for the challenge of signing for his brother Tobias’s favorite team, and keen to prove that his injury-hit seasons of the last two years were anomalies. United has been here before: it took a risk in signing injury-prone Robin van Persie, whose impact in season one earned United the title but provided some counterweight to the two curtailed campaigns since.

Schweinsteiger also provides something United has lacked in recent seasons; leadership on and off the pitch and that been-there-done-that mentality that only World Cup winners possess. Schweinsteiger may not have the on-field impact that Van Persie did, but off the pitch, there will be no doubting his value.

LYTTLETON: Memphis Depay steps into spotlight at Manchester United

Angel Di Maria

Manchester United to Paris Saint-Germain, £45 million

Manchester United broke its transfer record to sign Di Maria, off the back of his man-of-the-match performance in the Champions League final and starring in Argentina’s run to the World Cup final and yet cuts him loose at a loss of almost £15 million one year later.

Differences in player valuation: How teams operate in transfer market

The reasons given for Di Maria’s failure at Old Trafford–and failure is putting it kindly–range from his wife’s unhappiness in Manchester (not helped by a frightening burglary in their house) to Di Maria playing out of position, struggling to learn English and not adapting to the coach’s demands. Yet perhaps the biggest surprise is that this deal has been shrugged off as one of those things, as if a £60 million signing that flops is like losing some lose change down the back of the sofa.

If there is an internal inquiry into Di Maria’s short-lived spell at Manchester, lessons need to be learned. PSG, which would have signed Di Maria last summer were it not for FFP& regulations, will be the beneficiary, and the Argentine genuinely wants to move to the French capital. There is a South American enclave of players there, it can go deep in the Champions League and it’s unlikely that he will be left to sink or swim on his own.

Christian Benteke

Aston Villa to Liverpool, £32.5 million

The figure that Liverpool spent on Benteke puts him in the top 25 most expensive transfers of all time, and there are fears in Belgium that the price tag will inevitably increase the pressure on the personable forward. The concern at Liverpool is a different one: how can Brendan Rodgers tally his ‘beautiful football’ philosophy and start with a player whose obvious strength is winning headers from crosses?

EPL Season Preview: 10 storylines to follow as a new season begins

Benteke is far more accomplished than Andy Carroll, a traditional ‘target-man’ Rodgers bombed out of Anfield as soon as he could, but it remains to be seen whether Benteke will play on his own ahead of an attacking three–maybe Coutinho, Roberto Firmino and one of Adam Lallana, Jordon Ibe and Lazar Markovic–or as part of a two-man strike-force alongside Daniel Sturridge or Danny Ings (or Divock Origi) ahead of a midfield diamond.

“He is a big guy but he has got the attributes that I like in terms of pace and movement and he gets all type of goals,” said Rodgers. “He will fit our tactical idea of the game.”

He has to hope so. Rodgers cannot afford a poor start to the season: owners FSG thought about replacing him last year and his future seems inextricably tied to Benteke’s form. No pressure, then.

MORE: USA's Johannsson signs four-year deal with Werder Bremen

Arturo Vidal

Juventus to Bayern Munich, £28 million

Arturo Vidal brings ferocity to Bayern Munich in fascinating transfer

Champions League finalist Juventus was expected to sell one of its dynamic midfielders this summer but many thought it would be Paul Pogba, not Vidal. That Bayern paid such an amount for a 28-year-old whose style of play is surely not sustainable as age catches up with him is credit once again to sporting director Beppe Marotta, who continues to prove himself one of the smartest operators in the market today.

Vidal may have won the Copa America with Chile over the summer but his personal standing took a hit when he was arrested for drunken driving mid-tournament. With Andrea Pirlo now in New York, Juve has replenished its midfield with Sami Khedira (free, although he's injured to start the season) from Real Madrid and, as seems likely, Julian Draxler for £20 million from Schalke. Now if Pogba can just stay for one more season, then Juventus’s summer business would be complete.

Raheem Sterling

Liverpool to Manchester City, £49 million

Regardless of how Sterling pans out, his transfer saga was a disaster

Never has a transfer saga been so transparent, as both Liverpool and Sterling’s agent Aidy Ward kept the press regularly updated towards this ugly deal’s inevitable conclusion. Liverpool’s negotiating stance eked out a massive sum for a player who is far from the finished product; the onus is now on City and coach Manuel Pellegrini to improve Sterling and push him to fulfill his potential. Question marks remain over his finishing – but, crucially, not his temperament.

“He’s a strong boy mentally,” said Rodgers, when the row with Ward was at its peak.

Added newly minted Liverpool captain Jordan Henderson, after Sterling was booed during England's summer friendly against Ireland: “He’s strong-minded and doesn’t let things bother him.”

Being the most expensive English footballer of all time adds an extra pressure, but so far Sterling looks like he can handle it. City could do with his pace, fearlessness and youth. He could even play as a false nine for City if Sergio Aguero is unavailable. For that price, he should be able to play anywhere.

Geoffrey Kondogbia

Monaco to Inter Milan, £20 million

The Milan derby should be interesting this season. Last month, Milan CEO Adriano Galliani was so convinced that his club was about to sign Jackson Martinez and Kondogbia that he announced the deals as all but done. Martinez ended up at Atletico Madrid and Kondogbia at Inter.

Yaya Toure reaffirms commitment to Manchester City, desire to stay put

“Milan offered me more money, but [Inter coach] Roberto Mancini called me and that was decisive,” said Kondogbia, rubbishing Galliani’s claims that he had signed the more lucrative deal.

Mancini had originally wanted Yaya Toure to run his midfield but Kondogbia is a younger, and cheaper, option.

“He’s our Yaya,” said Inter owner Erick Thohir unhelpfully.

Inter has had a busy, and successful, summer, bringing in defenders Miranda (from Atletico Madrid), Jeison Murillo (Granada), Davide Santon (Newcastle) and Martin Montoya (loan from Barcelona); also striker Stevan Jovetic from Manchester City and keeping Mauro Icardi on the books. It may not be enough to overtake Juve at the top, but Mancini now can at least challenge for the title.

Gianelli Imbula

Marseille to Porto, £16 million

Imbula thought he would be the Inter midfielder that Mancini turned to after rejection from Yaya Toure, but it did not quite turn out like that. Reports in Spain have suggested that Doyen Sports managed the deal–despite FIFA’s outlawing of third-party ownership from last May–and that he will be parked in Porto for a year before joining AC Milan next summer.

Imbula is Porto’s most expensive signing: more than Hulk (€19 million, who moved to Zenit for €60 million) and Danilo (€13 million, who joined Real Madrid for €31 million).

Unlike Xavi, Iker Casillas endures strange, unceremonious club farewell

Porto’s summer spending was labeled ‘madness’ by Jose Mourinho, as it has also signed Iker Casillas on a free transfer (but on big wages), Maxi Pereira from Benfica, Danilo Pereira from Maritimo and Alberto Bueno from Rayo Vallecano. Despite the outlay–offset by the sale of Martinez to Atletico–it’s another excellent window for Porto president Pinto da Costa and his sporting director Angelo Henrique. And keep an eye out on where Imbula might end up next summer.

Arda Turan

Atletico Madrid to Barcelona, £24 million

The Turkish winger will have to wait until Barcelona’s transfer embargo is finished in January before he can make his debut, but at least he is still at the club; because he was officially signed during presidential election period, his contract had a two-week window in which the new president could sell him back to Atletico at a 10% loss.

Barcelona's Champions League title caps season, adds to dominant era

As it happened, (surprise, surprise after winning the treble), the new president was the old president Josep Bartomeu, so the move went through.

Nevertheless it will be a frustrating six months for Turan, and then he will need time to fit in among his new teammates; the same happened to Luis Suarez last season (his debut was in October) and that at least kept him fresh toward the home stretch.

Where Turan fits in is also worth watching: possibly as cover for any of the front three rather than the midfield. While the Neymar-Suarez-Messi trident was sensational last season, perhaps just as impressive was the fact that none were injured. Barcelona will hope for a repeat, but has a contingency plan just in case.

Abou Diaby

Arsenal to Marseille, free

Has there been an unluckier footballer than Diaby? Injury upon injury, and those who know him say he works as hard as ever and remains positive, even if the evidence–three full games in the last two seasons–is stacked against him. What works in his favor is his talent: when fit, which is rarely, he is as good as any midfielder around.

Watch: Zlatan plays word association: Messi, Ronaldo, Guardiola, more

Marseille is taking a low-cost chance on the Frenchman, after the player had a long chat with club doctor Christophe Baudot. His contract is on a play-as-you-play basis, unsurprisingly, although there are some concerns that coach Marcelo Bielsa’s intense pressing game, not to mention his training methods, could burn Diaby out before he gets going. Club sources have suggested that if Diaby gets 20 games next season, it will have been a success.

Given that's more than his combined total in the last four years (16 appearances), the Marseille medical team would deserve medals.

Petr Cech

Chelsea to Arsenal, £11 million

There were some poignant moments after Arsenal beat Chelsea to win the Community Shield on Sunday. That was billed more as Arsene Wenger beating Mourinho, his first time in 14 attempts, and Cech walked a tricky line between respect for his former club and celebrating his current success very well.

EPL season preview: Relegation fight, bottom-half outlook for 2015-16

He spoke to Thibaut Courtois after the final whistle, made a point of shaking hands with every member of the Blues backroom staff, including a special grin for his former goalkeeping coach Christophe Lollichon, and then he embraced Mourinho.

That Wenger finally ended this hex was not all down to Cech–Eden Hazard had the best chance for Chelsea and he skied it, while a save from Oscar’s free-kick was routine–but Per Mertesacker afterwards spoke of his arrival as “a huge boost.”

It finally looks as if Arsenal has a goalkeeper that has the personality and winning mentality of Jens Lehmann, who has never been properly replaced. It may not be enough for Arsenal to win the title, but it makes the team a whole lot stronger.

GALLERY: Tifos around the world

Best soccer tifos from around the world

Emrah Yorulmaz/Anadolu Agency/Getty Images

Galatasaray fans display a sensational "Rocky" tifo ahead of their clash against rival Fenerbahce. It didn't inspire a victory, though. The Turkish rivals played to a 0-0 draw.

Borussia Dortmund fans channel their 1963 cup triumph over Benfica ahead of the teams' second leg in the Champions League round of 16 at Signal Iduna Park.

Hapoel Be'er Sheva fans turn to Moses for tifo inspiration, with his splitting the Red Sea illustrating how "impossible is nothing" in their Europa League series against Besiktas.

Fans of Tunisia's Club Africain display this pointed tifo at a friendly against PSG, whose Qatari owners have pumped millions and millions into the club.

U.S. fans in Columbus, Ohio, make a "One Nation, One Team" statement ahead of the USMNT's World Cup qualifying match against Mexico on November 11, 2016.

Germany fans display their heart for the team colors ahead of a World Cup qualifier against Czech Republic in October 2016.

Italy fans spell out their support for the Azzurri ahead of a massive World Cup qualifier vs. Spain in October 2018.

Iceland fans keep up their world-famous passion for the national team during a World Cup qualifier against Turkey in October 2016.

Fans in the United Arab Emirates set their sights on reaching the 2018 World Cup in Russia during a qualifying match vs. Australia in September 2016.

Colombia fans send a massive jersey around the stadium during a World Cup qualifier vs. Venezuela in September 2016.

Seattle Sounders fans turn to Game Of Thrones for inspiration in a game against the Cascadia rival Vancouver Whitecaps in September 2016.

Djurgardens fans go all out in Sweden for a match against AIK in September 2016.

Zulte Waregem fans prepare Kortrijk for the absolute worst in this Belgian top-flight match in September 2016.

Seattle Sounders fans turn their pop culture reference to Poltergeist in March 2016 ahead of the season home opener against Sporting Kansas City.

The Timbers Army doubles down on their Eastbound and Down theme, adding another wrinkle during the club's MLS Western Conference final first leg vs. FC Dallas on November 22, 2015 at Providence Park.

Fans make a French flag tifo at Wembley Stadium during the singing of Le Marseillaise ahead of England's friendly vs. France, which took place days after the terrorist attacks in Paris.

The Timbers Army referenced Eastbound & Down's Kenny Powers with their "Cup Bound and Down" tifo for the Portland Timbers' MLS playoff elimination game against Sporting Kansas City on October 29, 2015.

Lars Ronbog/FrontZoneSport via Getty Images

Brondby IF fans display a gladiator holding up a lion's head during the team's Danish Alka Superliga match against FC Copenhagen, whose logo is a lion's head, on September 27, 2015.

New England Revolution fans equate Jermaine Jones to Indiana Jones on their quest to capture the 2015 MLS Cup on September 26, 2015.

New England Revolution fans display a Lion King theme in honor of Orlando City FC's first visit to Gillette Stadium on September 5, 2015.

Red Bulls fans take a shot at NYCFC's two summer arrivals, 37-year-old Frank Lampard and 36-year-old Andrea Pirlo, ahead of their third MLS meeting of 2015.

Alexander Hassenstein/Bongarts/Getty Images

Germany fans in Cologne salute their World Cup champions ahead of a friendly against the United States in June, 2015.

Real Madrid fans went all out prior to the second leg of the 2014-15 Champions League semifinal vs. Juventus.

Lazio fans display a stunning eagle tifo ahead of the Rome derby against AS Roma in their penultimate Serie A match of the 2014-15 season.

Barcelona fans bid farewell to veteran midfielder Xavi with this banner at his last league game at Camp Nou before he departs for Qatari club Al Sadd.

Fans at Anfield pay tribute to Steven Gerrard in his final home match as a Liverpool player in May 2015.

Juventus fans state their case to beat Real Madrid in the 2014-15 Champions League semifinals and reach the final in Berlin.

Fans at Benfica's Estadio da Luz remind rival Porto who the Primeira Liga reigning champion is during an April 2015 match in Portugal.

New York Red Bulls fans send a pointed message to their NYCFC counterparts prior to the teams' first MLS meeting in May, 2015.

Inter Milan's Curva Nord announces its presence ahead of the April 2015 Derby della Madonnina–the annual clashes between city rivals Inter and AC Milan.

Bayern Munich fans implore their club to (translated) "Never give up" in the Champions League quarterfinal second leg vs. Porto. Bayern then turned a 3-1 first-leg deficit into a 7-4 aggregate win and a place in the semifinals.

dortmund-tifo-juventus — Patrik Stollarz/AFP/Getty Images

Dortmund fans commemorate their 1997 Champions League trophy in the club's clash vs. Juventus–the opponent on the wrong side of that title bout.

Portland Timbers fans speak out against homophobia with this tifo in a 2013 match against Chivas USA

Atletico's supporters display a banner reading "Atleti crushes" before the Spanish league match between Atletico Madrid and FC Barcelona at the Vicente Calderon stadium in Madrid,

Borussia Dortmund fans put on a remarkable display ahead of a UEFA Champions League quarterfinal second leg match.

Brondby IF fans unveil a tifo ahead of a match in Denmark against Randers FC.

FC Barcelona fans display a huge banner in memory of former head coach Tito Vilanova.

Burak Akbulut/Anadolu Agency/Getty Images

Galatasaray fans support their team during the UEFA Champions League Group D match between Borussia Dortmund and Galatasaray at the Turk Telekom Arena in Istanbul.

The American Outlaws unveil a huge tifo ahead of a 2014 World Cup send-off match between the USA and Turkey at Red Bull Arena in Harrison, N.J.

Marseille's supporters use paper sheets to create an "OM" (Olympique de Marseille) tifo at the beginning of the French L1 football match between Marseille and Genoble.

Seattle Sounders fans display their tifo that shows coach Sigi Schmid playing cards and holding a Royal Flush before a match against the Portland Timbers.

Panathinaikos Athens fans display a banner during the UEFA Europa League match against Dynamo Moscow.

Fans of the Saudi Al-Hilal team celebrate after the scoring of a goal against Uzbekistan's Bunyodkor.

Seattle Sounders fans unveil a tifo inspired from the “Build a Bonfire” chant, featuring Sounder players holding torches on horseback ahead of a game against the Portland Timbers.

Jan-Philipp Burmann/City-Press via Getty images

Fans of Hertha BSC before the Bundesliga match between Hertha BSC and Werder Bremen in Berlin.

Sporting-KC-tifo-rsl — Andy Mead/YCJ/Icon SMI

Sporting Kansas City fans channel their inner Mario ahead of the 2013 MLS Cup final vs. Real Salt Lake.

Brondby IF fans.

barcelona-tifo — Manuel Blondeau/AOP Press/DPPI/Icon Sportswire

Thousands of Barcelona fans hold up cards to spell out "Barca! Orgull," which translates to "Barcelona pride" ahead of a Champions League clash with Bayern Munich at Camp Nou.

Fans raise a tifo celebrating “Community, Club and Country” ahead of a CONCACAF Gold Cup match between the USA and Belize in Portland, Oregon.

Vitesse fans unfurl a massive Eagle banner at the Dutch Eredivisie match against Ajax at the GelreDome.

valencia-tifo — Manuel Queimadelos Alonso/Getty Images

Valencia fans drape a banner featuring a king for a Copa del Rey ("The King's Cup) match against Atletico Madrid.

juventus-tifo — Jonathan Moscrop/LaPresse/Icon Sportswire

Juventus fans make a statement in Turin in a match vs. Inter Milan.

dortmund-tifo — Matthias Hangst/Getty Images

Dortmund fans put on another strong display at a Bundesliga match against Mainz 05.

germany-tifo — John MacDougall/AFP/Getty Images

German fans boast the newest star earned by the national team, symbolizing its 2014 World Cup triumph, at a Euro 2016 qualifying match in Dortmund.

real-madrid-tifo — Pedro Castillo/Real Madrid/Getty Images

Real Madrid fans make a point to display the club's 10 European championships ahead of the October 2014 clash against rival Barcelona at the Bernabeu.

san-jose-earthquakes-tifo — John Hefti/Icon SMI

San Jose Earthquakes fans unleash a massive tifo to mark the opening of Avaya Stadium, MLS's newest soccer-specific venue, in March 2015.

barcelona-fans-tifo — Anadolu Agency/Getty Images

Barcelona fans show all who the real 12th man is ahead of the March 2015 Clásico vs. Real Madrid.

Ivan Villa/STR/LatinContent/Getty Images

Ahead of a clash with Mexican foe Monterrey, Tigres players are treated by this message by its fervent supporters.

Steven-Defour-Tifo — Yorick Jansens/AFP/Getty Images

Standard Liege fans have a pointed message for Steven Defour, who departed the club for Belgian rival Anderlecht.

orlando-city-tifo — Alex Menendez/Getty Images

Orlando City fans mark their club's inaugural MLS game vs. fellow expansion side New York City FC with a statement that the Lions' "reign begins now."