Eric Mack
Monday May 2nd, 2011

We are through one full month of the season, so now it seems like a good time to reassess the preseason rankings and the current points leaders among hitters, by position. This has been an interesting beginning to the year, because so many of the elite stars are off to slow starts, namely Albert Pujols and Hanley Ramirez.

The top two in the draft averages aren't even in the top five of their positions through four weeks. They should be considered potential buy-low candidates, though, if anyone is selling. Hitters hit and the numbers are going to level out.

Let's see where we're at:

First base

Preseason top five:

1. Albert Pujols, STL 2. Miguel Cabrera, DET 3. Joey Votto, CIN 4. Mark Teixeira, NYY} 5. Adrian Gonzalez BOS

Current top five:

1. Votto, CIN 2. Cabrera, DET 3. Lance Berkman, STL 4. Prince Fielder, MIL 5. Alex Gordon, KC

A-Gone has just one homer coming off shoulder surgery, but he has remained productive otherwise. Berkman has been a fantasy MVP and 27-year olds Fielder and Gordon are making good on potential career years.

Second base

Preseason top five:

1. Robinson Cano, NYY 2. Dustin Pedroia, BOS 3. Ian Kinsler, TEX 4. Dan Uggla, ATL 5. Chase Utley, PHI

Current top five:

1. Ben Zobrist, TB 2. Cano, NYY 3. Howard Kendrick, LAA 4. Kinsler, TEX 5. Brandon Phillips, CIN

Utley still hasn't even started playing live games yet, proving he was far overrated amid his knee issues. Pedroia and Uggla aren't performing up to potential either. They are all buy-low candidates. Zobrist could be a sell high, we suppose, but he is capable of a career year here. Kendick is another 27-year old off to an impressive, career-year-like start.

Third base

Preseason top five:

1. Evan Longoria, TB 2. Alex Rodriguez, NYY 3. David Wright, NYM 4. Ryan Zimmerman, WAS 5. Jose Bautista, TOR

Current top five:

1. Bautista, TOR 2. Placido Polanco, PHI 3. Wright, NYM 4. Adrian Beltre, TEX 5. Michael Young, TEX

This position was the mess we said it would be in the bold predictions -- mostly due to the surprise injuries of Longo and Zimmerman. Bautista hasn't let down after his career year, while Polanco and Young are proving capable of hanging on. A-Rod is a decent buy low, while Bautista is a decent sell high. He just can't produce another 50-plus homer season, right?


Preseason top five:

1. Ryan Braun, MIL 2. Carlos Gonzalez, COL 3. Josh Hamilton, TEX 4. Carl Crawford, BOS 5. Matt Holliday, STL

Current top five:

1. Bautista, TOR 2. Braun, MIL 3. Matt Kemp, LAD 4. Berkman, STL 5. Zobrist, TB

As repeated often in spring training, outfield is the deep, level position that rotates its top players more than any other. Kemp, Berkman and Zobrist are back after down seasons. They are not necessarily sell-highs, though, because they can be just as good as anyone over the long haul. Braun is having a strong age-27 season, while Gonzalez and Crawford are a lot better than they have shown. Hamilton was the injury bust he was probably destined to be.


Preseason top five:

1. Joe Mauer, MIN 2. Victor Martinez, DET 3. Buster Posey, SF 4. Brian McCann, ATL 5. Mike Napoli, TEX

Current top five:

1. Russell Martin, NYY 2. Miguel Montero, ARI 3. Posey, SF 4. Carlos Santana, CLE 5. Alex Avila, DET

Mauer and Martinez were injury-hit, but Posey has proven to be rock-steady in his sophomore season. McCann and Napoli are fine and should rise in the current points standings. Martin, Montero, Santana and Avila have proven to be great sleepers in mixed leagues and each can be considered viable top-12 options at the position now. Mauer and V-Mart are buy-low candidates at a position with no current sell-high options.

Now on to the rest of our weekly look at fantasy trends:

Ten RBI in a week is a productive one for any position in fantasy. Zobrist almost did it in one game, driving in eight in Game 1 of a doubleheader and coming back in the nightcap with a two-run homer. Ten RBI in one day is just ridiculous. It is still too early for full-season paces, but Zobrist is on pace for 42 homers and 150 RBI. He is back to being a must-start in all leagues, especially with his second-base eligibility.

Past players of the week: 3. SP James Shields, TB; 2. SP Dan Haren, LAA; 1. SP Jered Weaver, LAA.

This could help you deal with injuries or forecast the returns of your stars:

3B Longoria, Rays (oblique) -- He looks like a safe play with a return from the DL and a rehab assignment Tuesday. When he isn't on the DL, he is a must start.

C Martinez, Tigers (groin) -- The catcher position is thin enough to use V-Mart in a brief week. He is hoping to be activated from the DL and a rehab assignment Wednesday.

3B Zimmerman, Nationals (stomach) -- The news got worse with Zimmerman, who will be out until June after surgery. Jerry Hairston will get the bulk of the at-bats. He is merely an NL-only Rotisserie option, though. You need to look to the waiver wire for the hot hand at third base on a weekly basis. Ryan Roberts and Jack Hannahan are the popular ones right now on the stats sheets.

SP Zack Greinke, Brewers (rib) -- He isn't quite at full speed yet, having tossed just five innings in his past rehab start, but he is an ace worth trusting in any format right away -- even as a one-starter. He should be a must-start, two-start pitcher next week, too.

RP Neftali Feliz, Rangers (shoulder) -- He is expected to start a rehab assignment early this week and could be ready to return Friday when first eligible. A healthy week will make him a must-start in all leagues next period. Darren Oliver and Arthur Rhodes will not be circumstantial options for saves at that point.

3B Pablo Sandoval, Giants (wrist) -- Kung Fu Panda owners were enjoying a renaissance, but now they will be without him until at least June. The Giants are considering moving Miguel Tejada to third for the time being and giving more at-bats to Mike Fontenot, who is a merely an NL-only fantasy option.

SP Johnny Cueto, Reds (shoulder) -- The Reds might bring him off the DL this weekend. A healthy return will make him a solid option for any league next week and beyond. Pick him up in the 20-plus perfect of fantasy leagues he is currently available.

3B David Freese, Cardinals (hand) -- He was finally healthy and scorching, but a broken hand will send him back to the DL and back in fantasy owners' doghouses. Daniel Descalso will likely get more starts at third base initially. Allen Craig (groin) could be a candidate to come off the DL and a rehab assignment to get more time at third base, too. He isn't a great glove at that position, though.

The most-added players:

1. 3B Roberts, ARI 2. SP Bartolo Colon, NYY 3. 3B Hannahan, CLE 4. 2B Darwin Barney, CHC 5. SP Mike Leake, CIN

Journeymen Roberts and Hannahan are taking advantage of their surprising opportunities and are on hot streaks that won't last. They are producing on an elite level, but it will eventually come crashing down for these players best suited to be big-league reserves and deeper NL- and AL-only fill-ins. Barney is in the same boat. Colon and Leake are a bit underrated and could be on this most-added list for a few more weeks.

The most-dropped players:

1. SP Chris Narveson, MIL 2. C Carlos Ruiz, PHI 3. SP Matt Harrison, TEX 4. OF Travis Snider, TOR 5. SP Travis Wood, CIN

Narveson, Harrison and Wood have hit the skids after decent starts out of the gate. They won't be completely useless in mixed leagues, but they can be dropped until they prove effective again. Then only use them when the matchups are right. Snider is back in the minors and shouldn't be lost sight of. He is still young enough to be considered a prospect; he was just rushed to the major leagues. Ruiz hasn't been hitting and is now out with an injury that won't send him to the DL but will keep him out of fantasy lineups this week.

The most-scouted players:

1. 3B Roberts, ARI 2. 2B Mike Aviles, KC 3. OF Matt Joyce, TB 4. 3B Hannahan, CLE 5. 3B Kevin Youkilis, BOS 6. OF Michael Brantley, CLE 7. 1B Matt LaPorta, CLE 8. OF Carlos Lee, HOU 9. RP Fernando Salas, STL 10. SP Bud Norris, HOU

A trio of Indians got healthy off Tigers pitching over the weekend. LaPorta is the most interesting of them, because of the hype that once surrounded him. Youkilis and Lee are banged up and question marks. Youk is the much safer play of the two right now. And, how about Norris? He is making good on his promising talent and is a must-own in all leagues at this point. He could be on the verge of a 15-win, 200-plus strikeout breakthrough, even for the Astros. He has ace-like stuff.

Eric Mack rounds up the fantasy baseball movers and shakers every Monday of the season at You can mock him, rip him and (doubtful) praise him before asking him for fantasy advice on Twitter @EricMackFantasy. Hit him up. He honestly has nothing better to do with his free time.

SI Apps
We've Got Apps Too
Get expert analysis, unrivaled access, and the award-winning storytelling only SI can provide - from Peter King, Tom Verducci, Lee Jenkins, Seth Davis, and more - delivered straight to you, along with up-to-the-minute news and live scores.