NEW YORK — The shame was in the ending—not its manner but the fact of it, that it came after just the regular 40 minutes and maybe at all. Saturday’s Big East tournament final between Seton Hall and Villanova was such an eyes-wide-open, Saturday-night-at-the-Garden classic that it seemed unfair that it would end just as its build reached fever pitch. That there would be no more dueling between the Pirates’ Isaiah Whitehead and the Wildcats’ Kris Jenkins. That there would be no more and-ones. That there would be no more decibel-raising, game-tying threes, no more Ryan Arcidiacono flying over press row into the stands chasing a loose ball, no more tourney shoo-ins from a major conference playing like two small schools locked in an auto-bid do-or-die. That after Whitehead’s soaring, rattle-around-the-rim layup while being fouled and his ensuing go-ahead free throw with 18.5 seconds left, that after Jenkins missed a long three and Josh Hart missed a put-back amidst a flurry of physicality, that after one last Arcidiacono prayer fell short, the game was over: Seton Hall 69, Villanova 67.
And only in the ending could there be the reward, the just deserts for a Pirates team that spent last season in a tailspin, February on the bubble, and this week knocking off the Big East’s biggest seeds to win the program’s first conference championship in all but one of its players’ lifetimes.
“When the clock hit zero?” said senior Seton Hall guard Derrick Gordon, a smile breaking across his face as his head tilted toward the ceiling. “The feeling that went through my body, it was just—it’s a blessing. It was a feeling that I’ve never felt, ever.”
Twenty-three years had passed since any Pirates player had that feeling, and this was not supposed to be the season that it returned. Last season’s team had followed a 12–2 start with a 4–13 finish then saw its leading scorer and would-be lone returning senior, Sterling Gibbs, siphoned off via transfer to UConn. The Big East’s preseason poll picked the Pirates seventh out of 10 teams. (“I was actually excited,” coach Kevin Willard said Saturday. “I thought we were going to be eighth or ninth.”) But their defense tightened and upped its peskiness, Gordon transferred in from UMass to provide a veteran leader and defender, and a somewhat disappointing batch of last year's freshmen—guards Whitehead and Khadeen Carrington, and forwards Desi Rodriguez, Angel Delgado, and Ismael Sanogo—grew into the core of a contender.
By the time they arrived in New York for the conference tournament, confidence was so high that Delgado began telling teammates he could already feel a championship ring on his finger. He repeated the message as the Pirates left the team hotel before the title game, amended with a promise about the Wildcats who had edged them twice in January. “They,” Delgado said, “are not beating us three times in a row.”
For much of Saturday’s first half it seemed there would be no drama in his prediction’s fulfillment. Seton Hall came out blazing from beyond the arc, making five of its first six three-point attempts, and scoring easily around the rim while Villanova big man Daniel Ochefu hobbled in and out of the game on his sprained right ankle. But an 11-point halftime lead was wiped in large part by Jenkins’s 16 second-half points, highlighted by a banked three from the left wing to tie the game with 9:21 left.
Eight fist-tight minutes later came a final 60-second showdown between the game’s two stars. A trey by Jenkins to put Villanova up three. One of two free throws by Whitehead to cut it to two. And then, after a trap by Carrington, Gordon and Sanogo forced a Josh Hart turnover, the go-ahead bucket, when Whitehead blew past Ochefu along the right of the key and collided with Jenkins on the right block. “I saw Kris Jenkins coming over,” Whitehead explained, “and I knew that he wouldn’t be able to get in position fast enough for me to draw a charge. I just tried to lay it in on him.” For nearly two seconds the ball skipped around above the net before dropping through to tie the game and give Whitehead the chance to take the lead at the line. From his seat along the baseline, next to the Seton Hall cheerleaders, Whitehead looked up and flexed both biceps.
It is a play that will live on in Big East tournament highlight reels and certainly in Seton Hall lore. After Jenkins’s miss on the other end, Hart appeared to be fouled on an attempted put-back amid a trio of Pirates defenders. But he did not blame the swallowed whistle for the outcome.
“Honestly, I’m going to say yeah,” he said when asked if he was fouled. “There’s so many more things that we did that could have changed the outcome. As a junior leader, I turned the ball over with 20-something seconds left. Up two, with a time out ... That’s why you don’t put the game in anyone else’s hands.”
In the chaos of the postgame celebration, as the P.A. blared Jersey deity Bruce Springsteen's “Born to Run” and the Pirates’ mascot, The Pirate, mugged for photos with players, the game’s prize—the Big East tournament trophy—was in Gordon’s hands, clung to his chest like a newborn. He has made the NCAA tournament twice before, with Western Kentucky and UMass, and still he was overwhelmed by his latest triumph. “It’s priceless,” he said. “It’s something that I’m honestly gonna remember the rest of my life. We plan to make a deep run in the NCAA tournament but right now I’m just celebrating with my teammates. This doesn’t happen everyday.”
Isn’t that a shame.
Here are three takeaways from Seton Hall’s triumph at the Garden:
Isaiah Whitehead is ready for primetime
If any Pirate is suited for sudden March stardom, it is Whitehead, the 6'4" sophomore point guard who leads Seton Hall with 18.2 points and 5.1 assists per game. He came to South Orange carrying the burden of being not only a Brooklyn-bred, five-star prodigy but also the Pirates’ first McDonald’s All-American in 14 years. Playing mostly shooting guard, he missed 10 games as a freshman with a stress fracture in his foot, then disappeared in several games during the team’s disastrous second half. But as a sophomore he has fulfilled his promise as a team-carrying star, highlighted by an ongoing streak of seven consecutive games with 20 points or more. (He had nine such performances in Seton Hall’s first 26 games.)
And he has combined a knack for fearless drives and pretty floaters with a flair for the theatric. After hearing that Steve Lavin, the former St. John’s coach who works as a Big East analyst for Fox Sports 1, had predicted the Pirates would lose their quarterfinal game to Creighton due to a lack of maturity, Whitehead crowed about it in the postgame: “Hey, we proved him wrong I guess.” (Lavin, to his credit, enjoyed making light of it during a postgame interview with Whitehead the next night.) During a replay review with three minutes left of Seton Hall’s semifinal win over Xavier, Whitehead turned to TV broadcaster Gus Johnson and said, “We want Villanova.” Then there was the flex after the game-tying bucket against Villanova, and the exaggerated, leg-kicking “BOOM!” exclamation after a first-half three.
When a reporter began asking Gordon about Whitehead on the court after Saturday’s win, Gordon cut him off at the mention of his teammate’s name. “Man,” Gordon said, then let out a series of stupefied sighs. “He’s on another level.”
Forget history: Ochefu’s ankle is Villanova’s top concern
The talk around the Wildcats this time of year is predictably centered on whether this will be the season that they finally advance to the NCAA tournament’s second weekend for the first time since 2009. In that span they have lost five times as the higher seed, including second-round losses as a No. 2 in 2014 (to eventual champion UConn) and as a No. 1 last season (to North Carolina State). The concerns typically center on the team’s lacking makeup, undersized lineup, or reliance on threes.
But the primary worry for Villanova right now is the right ankle of Ochefu, the versatile 6'11" center around whom so much of its offense (via not only scoring but also screens and hand-offs) and defense (via shot-blocking and switches) revolve. Ochefu averaged just over 15.7 minutes over three Big East tourney games, averaging 4.3 points and 2.7 rebounds, but more importantly limping while running and looking unlike himself for long stretches of time. Against Seton Hall he was blocked from behind by Whitehead on one shot attempt, then later clanked a turnaround layup attempt hard off the backboard. When he was matched up on Whitehead for the game-deciding drive, he appeared to stand no chance of staying with him.
Still, after the game Ochefu blew off talk of the injury’s impact. “It was cool. I was out there,” he said. “No excuse for anything. My ankle wasn’t limiting me. I could have played better.” Coach Jay Wright seemed less optimistic. “I really don’t know,” Wright said. “It’s a nagging injury that he’s had for, I don’t know, man. He hasn’t dunked a basketball in three or four games. It’s something that every time he gets out there he tweaks it again.”
Don’t sleep on the Pirates
In mid-January, after the Pirates had been handled by Creighton for a second straight loss, Gordon called a team meeting. He had not been part last season’s disastrous finish, he said, but he had heard about the rifts within the team as the losses piled up. “I didn’t want it to go that way,” Gordon said.
It has gone decisively the other way. After two more losses soon after the meeting—to Villanova by one and at Xavier—Seton Hall has won 11 of its last 13 to go from the bubble to a possible top-5 seed. In one 24-hour span, it knocked off two teams currently ranked in the top five in the polls. “When we watched films of other teams when we were preparing for Seton Hall,” Wright said, “we kept saying these guys are getting better and better and better and better ... They got the right guy the ball and made the right plays, they defend, they got rebounds. That’s a very good basketball team. A well-coached basketball team.”
The peak is well-timed. Seton Hall has not been to the Big Dance in 10 years; it has not reached the second weekend in 16; it has made the Final Four only once, when P.J. Carlesimo coached the national runners-up in 1989. Their finish has the Pirates thinking of doing one better. “The sky’s the limit,” Gordon said. “It’s open. It’s open for anybody. If we have the same mindset that we had out here, I mean, we control where we go.”