Kyrie Irving and the Most Famous Trade Requests in Sports History

0:55 | NBA
Cavs Ship Kyrie Irving to Celtics for Package Including Isaiah Thomas
Wednesday August 23rd, 2017

Kyrie Irving shocked the sports world when he asked the Cavaliers to trade him in July. After all, it seemed Irving had the perfect situation: His team had reached three consecutive finals, he played alongside the best player in the league who is known for his unselfishness, and Irving did not have to defer to LeBron during crunch time. James would often defer to Irving when the Cavs needed a bucket, most famously when Irving hit the game-winning three-pointer in the 2016 NBA finals. 

Despite what looked ideal on paper, Irving yearned to be the man on his own team, and his wish was granted when the Cavs traded him to the Celtics for a package centered around Isaiah Thomas. 

What motivates athletes to demand trades varies across each situation. Sometimes, as in Irving's case, it's a desire to escape another player's shadow. In other instances, perhaps a player doesn't believe his team's management is committed or capable enough to build a championship-ready roster. But one thing is for certain—whatever the cause, anytime an athlete wants to leave a team, it's going to evoke strong feelings, and strong feelings are memorable.

Here are the some of the most memorable trade requests in sports history, in no particular order. 

Eli Manning

Getty Images

Manning was the clear-cut No. 1 player in the 2004 draft and the team with the top pick, San Diego, thought it had found its franchise quarterback. But then Manning’s agent broadsided San Diego just days before the draft by saying Archie Manning had made it clear he didn’t want his son playing for the floundering Chargers. Archie wanted Eli in New York. 

In the end, it worked out swimmingly for both sides. The Chargers took Manning, the Giants took Phillip Rivers—who the Chargers liked more than Ben Roethlisberger—and the teams worked out a trade. San Diego got the Giants’ third-round pick that year and selected Nate Kaeding, who went on to become the most accurate kicker in franchise history. The Bolts also received the Giants' 2005 first-round pick, which they used on Shawne Merriman. 

John Elway

Getty Images

Elway’s situation was nearly identical to Manning’s. The Colts picked Elway No. 1, despite Elway’s father having told the team months earlier that his son would never play for Baltimore. But Elway had something Manning didn’t: a baseball career to fall back on (or use as leverage). The Yankees had taken him in the second round of the 1981 draft and Elway threatened to leave football behind. The Colts caved eventually, though, and dealt Elway to the Broncos. 

Kareem Abdul-Jabbar

Getty Images

Kareem will forever be remembered for his tenure with the Lakers, but he blossomed into the NBA's best player as a member of the Milwaukee Bucks. The Bucks selected Adul-Jabbar—then known as Lew Alcindor—first overall in 1969, and he averaged better than 30 per game and made the All-Star team in each of his six seasons in Milwaukee. Kareem even won his first NBA title with the Bucks in 1971, but Abdul-Jabbar was not satisfied; he saw Los Angeles as a place where he could grow his brand, live in a bigger city and, above all, win more. His wish was granted in 1975, and Kareem would go on to win five more rings in L.A. en route to becoming the NBA's all-time leading scorer. 

Chris Paul

Getty Images

In an alternate universe, the Knicks could have been a superteam. On the eve of the lockout-shortened 2011–12 NBA season, Chris Paul told the Hornets he wasn’t going to sign a contract extension and asked to be traded... to the Knicks. But the Carmelo-Amare-CP3 trio never came to be. The CP3-Kobe pairing never happened, either, after commissioner David Stern controversially squashed a three-way deal between the Hornets, Lakers and Rockets. Paul did end up in Los Angeles eventually, with the Clippers. 

Joe Montana 

Getty Images

As far as quarterback controversies go, it doesn't get much better than the pickle the 49ers found themselves in in 1992. Montana had led the team to four Super Bowls and was the undoubted face of the franchise, but he missed all of the 1991 and most of the 1992 season with an elbow injury. In his absence, Steve Young emerged as one of the best quarterbacks in the league and took home NFC MVP honors in 1992. When Montana was finally healthy and ready to play prior to the 1993 season, he made it clear that he would not backup Young and demanded a trade to the Kansas City Chiefs. 

Interestingly enough, the 49ers actually offered to reinstate Montana as the starter, but the locker room damage was beyond repair. Montana was traded to the Chiefs in April 1993 and led Kansas City to two playoff appearances before retiring after the 1994 season. Young, for what it's worth, won another MVP in 1994 and led the 49ers to a Super Bowl XXIX. 

Carmelo Anthony

Getty Images

Melo’s departure from Denver wasn’t exactly a trade demand. Instead, he simply refused to entertain the idea of signing a new contract with the Nuggets and the team set out to trade him rather than lose him in free agency and get nothing in return. Anthony indicated he wanted to go to a big market like New York or Chicago and after months and months of negotiations he ended up with the Knicks. 

Carmelo Anthony (again)

Getty Images

Melo’s tenure in New York began well enough, but then Phil Jackson came along. Phil spent his last few months as Knicks president publicly lobbying for Anthony to waive his no-trade clause. He had already turned down a deal to the Clippers and didn’t seem eager to leave his life in New York. But at some point he just said, Screw it, maybe Phil was right, and told the Knicks he wants to join Chris Paul in Houston

NBA
The 10 most embarrassing moments from Phil Jackson’s time with the Knicks

Hakeem Olajuwon

Getty Images

The Dream went to the University of Houston, where he was a member of the Phi Slamma Jamma team that lost consecutive NCAA title games,  so his roots in Houston ran deep. It seemed that the Olajuwon-Houston love affair was coming to and end in 1992; Olajuwon was dissatisfied with his contract, the direction of his franchise and, most significantly, he was angry at the organization for accusing him of faking a hamstring injury. But the Rockets held firm and refused to trade Olajuwon, and that turned out to be the right call—Olajuwon led the franchise to back-to-back NBA championships in 1994 and 1995. 

Kyrie Irving

Getty Images

Kyrie’s request to leave the Eastern Conference favorite caught everyone by surprise. Just as surprising was the news that he’d been traded to the Celtics, a move that hadn’t even really been rumored. 

Neymar

Getty Images

There are countless soccer transfers that could have made this list, because virtually every soccer transfer is the result of a player being unhappy with his club situation and requesting a move.

The Neymar situation makes the list because its recent and resembles Irving's request in many ways. Neymar was regarded as the second-best player on a world-class team, playing alongside the best player in the game. Eager to set out on his own and prove himself as a top player, Neymar accepted a record move to Paris-St. Germain. 

Dwight Howard

Getty Images

It’s easy to forget that Dwight Howard was once one of the most valuable players in the NBA, so teams were knocking down the Magic’s door when he asked to leave before the 2011–12 season. ESPN’s Brian Windhorst reported that Howard was upset the organization did take his advice on personnel moves. He ended up getting traded to Lakers before the next season, which was an unmitigated disaster

Wilt Chamberlain

Getty Images

There is a theme here: big men seem to be drawn to the Los Angeles Lakers. Chamberlain was 31 and coming off three-consecutive MVP seasons for the 76ers when he made his desire to move out west known. He knew that he needed more championships to pair his individual accomplishments and, like Abdul-Jabbar and Howard, felt like the Lakers gave him a great chance to win. While Chamberlain's production declined in Los Angeles, he was named Finals MVP when the Lakers won it all in 1972.

Kobe Bryant

Getty Images

Kobe’s request was the rare one that wasn’t mediated through an anonymous source. In 2007, Bryant told Stephen A. Smith on the radio “I would like to be traded, yeah.” Kobe was upset that someone within the Lakers organization leaked—falsely, Bryant claimed—that he was the reason Shaq left Los Angeles. The demand almost led to a Kobe-for-LeBron trade, which would have stopped the rotation of the Earth. 

SI Apps
We've Got Apps Too
Get expert analysis, unrivaled access, and the award-winning storytelling only SI can provide — from Peter King, Tom Verducci, Lee Jenkins, Grant Wahl, Andy Staples and more — delivered straight to you, along with up-to-the-minute news and live scores.