Major Scrapped Cody Rhodes WrestleMania Creative Pitch Revealed On WWE: Unreal

The road to WWE WrestleMania 41 took many twists and turns, but it almost drove off a cliff in regards to then-WWE Champion Cody Rhodes.

Rhodes lost the Undisputed WWE Championship to John Cena in the main event of the Premium Live Event, aided by Travis Scott. But there was nearly a major detour to the moment, according to one of WWE's top creative contributors.

The new "WWE: Unreal" series gives a look at the build to WrestleMania, and in one of the episodes, Dwayne Johnson's right-hand man (and former WWE creative head) Brian Gewirtz revealed a shocking title change could have taken place ahead of the "Show of Shows."

“The prospect of babyface John [Cena] and babyface Cody [Rhodes] felt a little dry to us. But just looking at it from the outside, let’s throw some controlled chaos into this. So, myself and Rock, we got together and we pitched something that was two-fold," he said.

"I had the idea of Cody needing to be Rock’s champion. We had that as the hook. We proposed, at Elimination Chamber, Cody turning down The Final Boss, and that was gonna lead to Final Boss making an impromptu title match right then and there, that resulted in Kevin Owens who had been in a storyline with Cody during that time, leaving with the championship."

MORE: WWE: Unreal Reveals Crazy Pitch For Chelsea Green To Win The 2025 Royal Rumble

Owens hasn't held a world title in WWE since 2017, and had been locked in a blood feud with Rhodes at the time of the Royal Rumble. But instead of facing Rhodes at the Elimination Chamber show, he defeated Sami Zayn in an unsanctioned match, while Rhodes instead declined The Rock's offer of success in exchange for his soul.

This would lead to Cena turning heel in a controversial storyline pivot.

Gewirtz expanded, noting that the grand plans weren't ultimately for Owens, but rather, a major story beat for Rhodes.

"Kevin Owens winning the title wasn’t the end goal," he said. "The takeaway was, whatever it is we do, needs to be seismic. That’s the big question. What is Cody gonna say?”

Owens was scheduled for a significant WrestleMania blowoff match with Randy Orton instead. That would not come to fruition, though, as he would require neck surgery and miss the show altogether.

H/T Fightful for partial transcription assistance.

The Latest on WWE, AEW, & More

Becky Lynch Reveals Massive Back Bruise After WWE Raw

WWE Announces Details For Return To Japan Later This Year

WWE Unreal Reveals Vastly Different Proposed WrestleMania 41 Card, Including Stone Cold Return

WWE NXT Preview (7/29/25): Start Time, Match Card, How to Watch & Live Stream