Lawrence Butler Rips MLB Umpires Over Lack of Accountability: 'I'm Fed Up'

Karl Rasmussen | Aug 18, 2025

Athletics outfielder Lawrence Butler shared his honest assessment of MLB umpires. / Daniel Kucin Jr.-Imagn Images

Athletics outfielder Lawrence Butler voiced his displeasure with the umpires in MLB, expressing that he feels there's a lack of accountability among big league umpires that doesn't exist at the Triple-A level.

Butler said Monday that he's "fed up" with MLB's umpires and said that minor league umpires displayed more caution in regards to the strike zone due to the existence of the automated ball-strike system that's in place, a system which MLB tested use of during the All-Star Game.

Because teams are able to challenge the call from umpires, Butler feels that umpires in the minors are more careful when calling balls and strikes.

"ABS. I'm fed up with the umpires. I've had enough with the umpires. They miss too many calls both ways," said Butler when asked what he would change if he were commissioner of MLB for a day.

"I want the challenge system. Three [challenges per game], just like they do in Triple-A. If you look at Triple-A, the umpires are a little bit more cautious about what pitches they call, because they know a pitcher or hitter might challenge it and it might embarrass them. So they might be a little bit more cautious to pull that trigger. I feel like up here, they don't five a f––."

"I'm fed up with the umpires... I feel like up here they don't give a fuck."

A's outfielder Lawrence Butler says umpires were more cautions in Triple-A because the automated ball-strike system held them accountable pic.twitter.com/rjdmt5x5U0

— Jomboy Media (@JomboyMedia) August 18, 2025

Butler didn't hold back with his assessment of officiating in MLB, and he made clear he'd welcome the implementation of ABS.

---

More MLB on Sports Illustrated

feed