Reuben Foster’s Situation Shows How the NFL Commissioner’s Exempt List Is Being Misused

Shortly after Foster was claimed by Washington on Tuesday, the NFL placed him on the Commissioner’s Exempt List—a list that should be utilized for players with special circumstances, but has lately become a haven for guys facing domestic violence charges. A possible fix? Count players on the list toward the 53-man roster.

Author:
Jonathan Jones
Publish date:
Nov 29, 2018

Before the 2014 NFL season, the commissioner’s exempt list was a seldom-used tool in the league for players facing unusual circumstances. It was a list where the NFL could find a temporary spot for a player while not counting him against a team’s active 53-man roster.

Michael Vick finished his suspension while on the list in 2009 before joining the Eagles in the regular season. Jonathan Vilma was on it in 2012 after finishing his Bountygate sentence. Jeff Demps, the former Bucs running back, was on the list the following year while he was pursuing his track dreams.

But in the past four years, a disturbing pattern has developed—and that pattern continued this week when newly claimed Washington linebacker Reuben Foster was added to the list. Though it has always been within its rules, the list has become a stowaway for guys who have abused those close to them, and it comes with no penalty to the teams who wish to keep the players.

Adrian Peterson appeared on the list in 2014 when the then-Vikings running back was indicted on child abuse charges. That was followed shortly after by then-Panthers defensive end Greg Hardy, who was convicted of assaulting a woman that summer and then appealed (the appeal triggered a jury trial, for which the accuser did not appear in court and the charges were eventually expunged). Two years later, Giants kicker Josh Brown was placed on the list when more documents emerged about his alleged domestic violence. And on Tuesday, shortly after Washington claimed Foster off waivers following domestic violence charges, the NFL placed him on the exempt list.

As my colleague Robert Klemko noted, Washington claiming Foster shows the organization values winning over people. I’m a believer in second chances, and I’m also a believer in due process. But this list provides a safe haven for both the player and team that should be cut out.

While on the list, a player is considered to be on paid leave and does not count against the 53-man roster; the team is without his services until Roger Goodell removes him from the list, and the player misses only practices and games during that time. The fix here is an easy one: make the commissioner’s exempt list one truly used only for unusual circumstances. If a player is charged with a crime, don’t give the club an out. If the team wishes to keep a player on the roster (or in Washington’s case, take one on), let that player count against the 53-man roster. You want him? He’s yours.

But this solution will never pass in the next round of CBA negotiating. The players still get paid so the union won’t argue for it. The teams get an out, so the owners won’t argue for it. And the list will continue to be the Land for Badly Behaving Boys.

Not getting this newsletter in your inbox yet?Sign up for The MMQB’s Morning Huddle.

HOT READS

NOW ON THE MMQB: The Jaguars’ misery at quarterback is of their own making. … In a first-person piece, Matt Ryan explains why The March of Dimes and Northside Hospital Miracle Babies, the two organizations which he is supporting through the NFL’s My Cause My Cleats platform, are so important to him. ... Andy Benoit looks at more teams’ draft needs. ... Conor Orr ranked the top head coaching openings, should they…you know…become open. … and more.

WHAT YOU MAY HAVE MISSED: Jenny Vrentas updates us on what players and teams are doing in their communities for social-justice work. … Read Greg Bishop’s masterful cover story on Drew Brees. … Come and get your power rankings here! … Episode 6 of “Fall of a Titan” is out now. … and more.

PRESS COVERAGE

1. Aaron Rodgers says the Packers might as well “let it all hang out” down the stretch. Well... yeah.

2. The Detroit Free Press looks back at the Lions’ decision to pass on Aaron Donald in the 2014 draft.

3. Cowboys WR Amari Cooper told Yahoo! Sports that he’s finally happy in Dallas after a miserable half-season in Oakland.

4. Tonight’s game could feature two teams without their left tackles. Saints LT Terron Armstead (pec) is out and Cowboys LT Tyron Smith (neck) is questionable.

5. NFL Network’s Gil Brandt says at least two NFL teams have already offered jobs to former Texas Tech coach Kliff Kingsbury. As the league’s faces an offensive explosion, Kingsbury should have a blank check.