A Simple Rule Tweak Would Fix the Home Run Derby’s Split-Screen View Everyone Hated

In Tuesday’s Hot Clicks: the real problem with the derby, the Lightning’s Stanley Cup celebration and more.
Author:
Publish date:

Don’t blame ESPN

Monday’s Home Run Derby was supposed to be the best in the event’s history. The lineup was stacked, the balls were juiced and the air was thin. It had all the ingredients to be legendary. And while it was a fun time, the broadcast made it hard to follow what was going on.

A lot of viewers thought that the issue was the split-screen view ESPN employed. Indeed, the constant action on both sides of the screen made it difficult to decide where your eyes should be focused. It was helpful to see each swing, but sometimes a hitter would appear to make less-than-stellar contact and, because they were at Coors Field, it would turn out to be a homer. That meant that you couldn’t ignore the majority of batted balls and had to keep darting your eyes back and forth from the batter to the flight of the ball.

The split screen isn’t new, though. ESPN has been using it since the 2017 derby, and for the first few years, it added to the viewing experience. Compare the '18 final round between Kyle Schwarber and Bryce Harper to the '16 final that pitted Todd Frazier against Giancarlo Stanton.

It’s far more satisfying to see every swing the batter takes, which the split screen allows. And you’re still able to follow the flight of the ball. The issue with Monday’s derby wasn’t with the split screen; it was with MLB's ignoring the rule applied in previous derbies that required the pitcher to wait for the previous ball to land before they could deliver another pitch. As a result, there would often be two balls in flight at once. The first one would land and ESPN’s cameras would cut to the second one so late in its flight that it was impossible to tell where it was going. That’s why the broadcast was lousy, not because the screen was split in half.

I understand why MLB would relax the application of that rule. If Pete Alonso had to wait for each one of his monster shots to come back to Earth before he could swing again, there’s no way he would have been able to hit 35 home runs in the time allotted to him in the first round. In a derby that had been hyped for weeks, it was in MLB’s best interest to tweak the conditions to allow the most homers possible.

But going forward, the umpires should be more strict about enforcing the rule. Not only would it make the derby easier to follow for the fans, it would also benefit the hitters. Shohei Ohtani, the presumptive derby favorite, looked absolutely gassed in his first-round loss to Juan Soto. If he had another fraction of a second to take a breath while waiting for the ball to land, he might not have been so winded. Just add a little more time to each round to compensate for the time lost waiting for the ball to land and hitters will still be able to put up big numbers. The other benefit of waiting for the ball to land is that it allows ESPN to put up a graphic saying how far the last home run went, which is the piece of information fans want to know the most.

MLB saved the derby by ending the outdated format based on “outs” that led to too many taken pitches, but there is still certainly room to improve. Making the derby a more viewer-friendly experience would go a long way toward solving the marketability problem that is discussed so much. 

The best of SI

The cover of SI’s Olympics issue is a profile of Simone Biles by Stephanie Apstein. ... Ohtani’s two-way exploits baffle even his All-Star peers. ... Which teams at Euro 2020 lived up to expectations?

Around the sports world

Stephen A. Smith issued two apologies after criticizing Ohtani for needing to use an interpreter. ... Smith also landed in hot water for comments on the same episode of First Take belittling the Nigerian men’s basketball team and its players’ names. ... The U.S. men‘s basketball team was handed its second straight exhibition loss, this time to Australia. ... The Washington Football Team’s new name won’t be “Warriors” or anything else evocative of Native Americans. ... Mark Sanchez is reportedly joining Fox as an NFL game analyst. ... An elite kayaker explains the hidden costs of trying to qualify for the Olympics.

The poor guy below took quite a kick

Juan Soto set a record with the longest dinger of the night

The Lightning put a hell of a dent in the Stanley Cup

Pete Alonso’s pitcher was flawless

He’s 6' 7", 360 pounds—and of course he plays for Alabama

“Festival de Cuadrangulares” is such a better name

HBO’s new docuseries on Garrett McNamara and Nazaré’s enormous waves debuts on Sunday

Not sports

Gyms in Seoul are not allowed to play upbeat songs in order to limit sweating and the spread of COVID-19. ... A woman in China allegedly ran 49 red lights in her ex-boyfriend’s car to rack up fines. ... British drug dealers are scamming customers by offering bogus “ethically sourced cocaine.”

He bounced off like Derrick Henry

Everybody wants to see the tiny cow

A good song

Email dan.gartland@si.com with any feedback or follow me on Twitter for approximately one half-decent baseball joke per week. Bookmark this page to see previous editions of Hot Clicks and find the newest edition every day. By popular request I’ve made a Spotify playlist of the music featured here. Visit our Extra Mustard page throughout each day for more offbeat sports stories.