NFL Fans Couldn’t Believe ESPN Showed Replay of Tyreek Hill’s Horrific Injury

Hill was carted off the field and quickly transported to a local hospital following the knee injury.

Tyreek Hill suffered an awful knee injury during Miami's game against the Jets on 'Monday Night Football' / Sam Navarro-Imagn Images

Dolphins star receiver Tyreek Hill suffered a gruesome-looking leg injury near the start of the second half of Miami's Monday Night Football game against the Jets.

He was carted off the field and the team quickly reported he was ruled out with a knee injury and was being transported to a local hospital for imaging, evaluation and observation. It was a horrific injury for the 10-year veteran who has never played less than 12 games in a season over his NFL career. He has played in 15 or more contests each year aside from 2019 where he appeared in 12 games for the Chiefs due to a shoulder injury.

Monday night's injury is one of those you immediately regret watching and you definitely want to avoid if you're squeamish. The ESPN broadcast decided to show a replay of the moment, which left some viewers less than thrilled.

The decision of whether or not to show a replay is a difficult one for broadcasts to weigh—in this case, many appeared to wish ESPN had passed.

WHY DID THEY JUST SHOW THAT TYREEK HILL INJURY AGAIN?!?! JESUS CHRIST

— Robert Griffin III (@RGIII) September 30, 2025

I can’t believe they showed a replay of that leg injury. What is ESPN thinking

— Conor McCormick-Cavanagh (@ConorMichael28) September 30, 2025

Trying to avoid watching an injury, just for ESPN to give you an up close replay <<<

— Diante Lee (@DianteLeeFB) September 30, 2025

Dawg why did ESPN show the Tyreek injury? They didn’t have to do that

— Lamin (@itsLamin) September 30, 2025

They did not need to show that Tyreek injury 🤮

— Dylan (@TallDPD) September 30, 2025

Tyreek Hill #dolphins

Will not be posting the video of it. Horrible looking injury. Knee dislocated likely numerous ligaments that need repair. Immediate concern for any vascular injury. Hope for the best

— Tom Christ, PT, DPT, OCS, FAAOMPT (@FantasyInjuryT) September 30, 2025

If the Tyreek injury is gruesome then don't show the replay

— Dave (@sportsinfive) September 30, 2025

Can I sue ESPN for showing the Tyreek Hill injury in slow motion? I can’t unsee it

— Tony Phonebooths (@tony_vols) September 30, 2025

What possesses ESPN to show the replay of Tyreek Hill’s leg exploding after the commercial??

— Nathan (formerly Nate) (@NateLovesGallo) September 30, 2025

Surprisingly, Hill seemed to be in good spirits as he was carted off the field, clapping and smiling as he acknowledged the fans, although he was understandably disappointed. Patrick Mahomes and others across the NFL world quickly took to social media to send their thoughts to the star receiver.

---

More NFL on Sports Illustrated

feed