Man Busted for Impersonating Extremely Mediocre Former MLB Pitcher

In Friday’s Hot Clicks: Missouri police arrest a man pretending to be someone very much not famous, baseball fans get all conspiratorial and more.
Publish date:

That’s who you picked to impersonate?

Pop quiz: What is the proper value of an autograph from Omar Olivares? If you answered, “Who the hell is Omar Olivares?” then congratulations, you’re correct. 

Olivares pitched 12 years in the majors (1990–2001) for eight different teams, compiling a career ERA of 4.67. He was worth 13.2 WAR, or just over one win per season. He is the definition of a “guy”—someone who was around for a while but you haven’t thought about in 15 years and who the majority of baseball fans didn’t even know existed. 

And yet, Olivares is the baseball player a Missouri man apparently chose to impersonate to scam people with fake autographs. 

Former MLB pitcher Omar Olivares on the mound in an Anaheim Angels uniform

Police in the St. Louis suburb of Manchester, Mo., announced Wednesday that they arrested a man who had been posing as Olivares and using his identity to sell fake memorabilia. (Olivares spent five years in St. Louis with the Cardinals, the only team for which he played more than two seasons.) 

“Investigation revealed that this subject had stolen Mr. Olivares’ identity and was using this ruse to sell ‘autographed’ baseballs and other memorabilia to unsuspecting fans,” the cops wrote on Facebook. “He also used this scam to trick victims into ‘loaning’ him money that was never paid back.”

Details on the scam are scant because the suspect has yet to be formally charged. (He faces charges of identity theft, stealing and forgery.) I for one can’t wait for the details to emerge. How much was he charging for autographs of such an obscure player? How did he convince people he was the real deal? Did the guy look anything like Olivares, or was he like It’s Always Sunny’s Donovan McNabb impersonator?

The real Olivares stayed in Pennsylvania after playing his final MLB season with the Pirates in 2001. Back in St. Louis, police are still looking for more victims. 

Conspiracy time!

Who would have thought when the Mets fired Carlos Beltrán over his role in the Astros’ sign-stealing scandal that it wouldn’t be the biggest baseball story of the day?

But then a Twitter account claiming to belong to Beltrán’s niece fired off a pair of tweets even more explosive. The tweets claimed that José Altuve and Alex Bregman wore some kind of devices under their jerseys that buzzed, allowing signals to be transmitted silently and without the use of a trash can—and that they were used in the 2019 season. (Altuve issued an unequivocal denial.)

The Beltrán family denied to ESPN’s Marly Rivera that the account belong to any relative. But there was enough reason to believe the person behind the account has at least some connection to Beltrán that fans ran wild with the accusations. The account tweeted days before Beltrán was hired that he would be the new manager of the Mets and the day before he was ousted by the Mets that he would be “stepping down” (this is the phrasing that was used in initial reports about Beltrán’s fate earlier Thursday, presumably from Beltrán’s camp). 

The anonymous Twitter account isn’t the only one talking about buzzers, either. Reds pitcher and noted Astros hater Trevor Bauer and Jimmy “Jomboy” O’Brien, who has been all over the sign-stealing story, say they’ve also heard about buzzers. 

Once you begin to entertain the possibility of vibrating devices on players’ skin, everything from the Astros’ season seems suspicious, like this video of Altuve telling his teammates not to tear his jersey off. 

Or this screencap of a Josh Reddick interview. 

Or this bump on Altuve’s shoulder, that even got Padres outfielder Tommy Pham put on his tinfoil hat.

Is Altuve just being modest? Is Reddick just wearing a bandaid? Maybe! But now baseball fans have something to keep them occupied through the rest of the winter.

The best of SI

Albert Haynesworth doesn’t need your love. Just your kidney. ... Jürgen Klopp might be the best coach in any sport right now. ... MLB doesn’t just have a problem, it has an ethical crisis. ... Odell Beckham Jr. needs to chill out. ... All the absurd things to happen this week in baseball, ranked.

Around the sports world

The director of the Australian Open says the tournament will go on despite horrendous air quality caused by the massive wildfires. ... The Giants have hired Alyssa Nakken as MLB’s first female coach. ... Joe Burrow’s dad says his son would have no problem going to Cincinnati.

49 for Brandon Ingram!

Galaxy brain

LaMelo Ball has a racehorse?

Bad week for Brad Marchand

On a dime

Avalanche jerseys for their upcoming outdoor game

Not sports

NBC announced details for its upcoming “Peacock” streaming service. ... A Massachusetts family chased a kidnapper’s car after seeing an Amber Alert. ... Netflix is spending $17.3 billion on content this year.

Whales are cool

The directors of Uncut Gems made a short film starring Adam Sandler as a Times Square performer

A good song

Email with any feedback or follow me on Twitter for approximately one half-decent baseball joke per week. Bookmark this page to see previous editions of Hot Clicks and find the newest edition every day. By popular request I’ve made a Spotify playlist of the music featured here. Visit our Extra Mustard page throughout each day for more offbeat sports stories.