Skip to main content

Eli Manning Says Two Super Bowl Wins Over Patriots Still Bother Tom Brady

In Wednesday’s Hot Clicks: how Tom Brady feels about losing two Super Bowls to Eli Manning, rare footage of Kobe Bryant and more.
  • Author:
  • Updated:

Rub that in his face, Eli!

Only one quarterback has won two Super Bowls against Tom Brady: Eli Manning. The Giants’ two upset victories over the Patriots are the highlights of Manning’s otherwise slightly-above-average career and constitute the entirety of his Hall of Fame case.

But when Manning finds himself in a room with the undisputed greatest football player of all time, he doesn’t rub the two rings in Tom’s face. But that doesn’t mean that the topic doesn’t come up.

“It’s one of those things, it’s not something I ever say or ever think a lot about,’’ Manning told the New York Post when asked about his 2–0 record against the G.O.A.T. on the game’s biggest stage. “I’ve been around Tom numerous times, and I’ve never brought up a Super Bowl or our games versus them. He actually brings it up. It still bothers him a little bit, especially the ’07 one when they had the chance to go down as the greatest team of all time.

“But I don’t have any bragging rights with Tom. This is his 10th Super Bowl, and I’m so impressed with his whole career.’’

Really, Eli? Your Houdini-like escape and subsequent throw to David Tyree for the helmet catch is one of the most iconic plays in Super Bowl history. It was a miracle that denied a team a perfect 19–0 record. You deserve to hold that over the head of the guy you beat. As a little brother, you should know to seize any opportunity to brag.

It’s not surprising that Brady’s Super Bowl losses still sting. According to Google Trends data, people didn’t start anointing Brady as the greatest quarterback ever until he led the Patriots back from a 28–3 deficit against the Falcons in Super Bowl LI to win his fifth ring, surpassing Joe Montana’s record. Imagine how much sooner Brady would have been recognized as the best to ever do it if he hadn’t lost back-to-back Super Bowls to a guy who led the league in interceptions three times. 

The best of SI

Here’s Tom Verducci’s Hall of Fame ballot. ... The 20 most fascinating people to watch in Super Bowl LV. ... Our first look at who should be in and out of the NCAA tournament’s field of 68

Around the sports world

80% of Japanese residents surveyed say they want this summer’s Olympics in Tokyo postponed or canceled. ... The mass detected on Caris LeVert’s kidney after he got traded to the Pacers turned out to be cancer, but he’s expected to make a full recovery after surgery. ... Here’s who’s eligible for the Baseball Hall of Fame next year. ... Stephen A. Smith wants to eventually host a late-night show. ... Panthers coach Matt Rhule says he took a draft prospect off his board last year after riding in an elevator with him at the combine

And then he scored a grand total of zero points in the second half as the Knicks blew a 13-point lead

The Los Angeles Times unearthed footage of Kobe’s pre-draft workout with the Clippers

This guy loves refusing to accept the results of elections

Fireworks in the Milan Derby

A Russian cross-country skier smacked his Finnish rival with ski pole and then bowled him over after the finish line

Look for the announcement a little later that they’re being moved to Zoom

Not sports

A South Carolina mayor consulted a local Chick-fil-A manager to figure out how to reduce wait times at a drive-though vaccination site. ...  A four-word tweet from Elon Musk set Etsy stock skyrocketing. ... Twitter is buying an email newsletter platform. ... A barge carrying toxic sludge dredged from New York’s Gowanus Canal sank right back to the bottom

Enormous avalanche near Mount Everest

Next week on Gatsby: Will we beat on, boats against the current? Tune in to find out.

A good song

Email with any feedback or follow me on Twitter for approximately one half-decent baseball joke per week. Bookmark this page to see previous editions of Hot Clicks and find the newest edition every day. By popular request I’ve made a Spotify playlist of the music featured here. Visit our Extra Mustard page throughout each day for more offbeat sports stories.