SI

Cleveland Browns select Justin Gilbert No. 8 overall in the 2014 NFL draft

Justin Gilbert, Oklahoma State (J.P. Wilson/Icon SMI) The Browns have been as active as any team could be in this draft, moving back from the fourth overall
Cleveland Browns select Justin Gilbert No. 8 overall in the 2014 NFL draft
Cleveland Browns select Justin Gilbert No. 8 overall in the 2014 NFL draft

Justin Gilbert, Oklahoma State (J.P. Wilson/Icon SMI)

The Browns have been as active as any team could be in this draft, moving back from the fourth overall pick so that the Bills could take Sammy Watkins, and then moving from the ninth pick to the eighth to take Oklahoma State cornerback Justin Gilbert. Gilbert really turned heads at the combine when he ran a 4.37 40-yard dash and blew up the positional drills. Pairing Gilbert with Joe Haden gives the Browns perhaps the best cornerback duo in the AFC North.

Strengths: Gilbert’s raw speed allows him to cover a ton of ground, plus helps him recover from any mistakes he may make. As he stated at the combine, with the ball in his hands he’s a constant threat to go the distance, be it off an interception or on a kick return. Receivers almost never blow past him on straight-line routes, further evidence that he’s as fast as the 40 time made him look.

Height and leaping ability make Gilbert a menace in the air — the pick-six he pulled off versus Texas came after he planted, then leaped toward the sideline in front of a receiver. Takes advantage of his size when playing in press coverage (though, not always effectively, as we’ll touch on shortly). Tough to beat over the middle because because how well he can get his foot into the ground, then transfer to top speed.

His ability to step in as a return man will earn him extra points. Barring an injury, the worst-case scenario for Gilbert heading into camp is that he competes for a No. 2 or No. 3 cornerback job while contributing heavily on special teams. He is very smooth with the ball in his hands, and made catches on interceptions that some receivers might have struggled to make.

Weaknesses: As with another projected Round 1 cornerback, Darqueze Dennard, Gilbert almost invites officials to flag him with his contact in coverage. Dennard can get himself into trouble attempting to maintain a jam; Gilbert has more issues downfield, where he’ll lunge and put himself in tough positions on deep balls. Some of that could be rectified if Gilbert continues to improve reading plays — right now, he can hang himself out to dry on well-run routes because he’s constantly hunting for an interception.

Effective as a tackler, but not overly eager to get involved, especially in the run game. Considering how physical he can be in man-coverage, it would be nice to see him translate that edge over to tracking ballcarriers. As with a quarterback who tries to overcompensate for poor reads with a strong arm, Gilbert puts almost too much faith in his speed, which may not fly quite as comfortably in the NFL.

Grade: B.

The Browns and new head coach Mike Pettine pick up a major asset in Gilbert, making their defense that much more formidable. They'll just have to hope that the much-needed quarterback they desire is there later in the first round.

[si_video id="video_FFCBF50B-89FF-F707-13D3-D89901797668" height="475"]


Published
Doug Farrar
DOUG FARRAR

SI.com contributing NFL writer and Seattle resident Doug Farrar started writing about football locally in 2002, and became Football Outsiders' West Coast NFL guy in 2006. He was fascinated by FO's idea to combine Bill James with Dr. Z, and wrote for the site for six years. He wrote a game-tape column called "Cover-2" for a number of years, and contributed to six editions of "Pro Football Prospectus" and the "Football Outsiders Almanac." In 2009,  Doug was invited to join Yahoo Sports' NFL team, and covered Senior Bowls, scouting combines, Super Bowls, and all sorts of other things for Yahoo Sports and the Shutdown Corner blog through June, 2013. Doug received the proverbial offer he couldn't refuse from SI.com in 2013, and that was that. Doug has also written for the Seattle Times, the Washington Post, the New York Sun, FOX Sports, ESPN.com, and ESPN The Magazine.  He also makes regular appearances on several local and national radio shows, and has hosted several podcasts over the years. He counts Dan Jenkins, Thomas Boswell, Frank Deford, Ralph Wiley, Peter King, and Bill Simmons as the writers who made him want to do this for a living. In his rare off-time, Doug can be found reading, hiking, working out, searching for new Hendrix, Who, and MC5 bootlegs, and wondering if the Mariners will ever be good again.