Inside The Padres

Padres Sale Accelerates as Seidler Lawsuit Ends and Buyers Emerge

The removal of a legal family dispute has opened the door for a bidding war over one of MLB’s most valuable teams.
Mar 28, 2024; San Diego, California, USA; A detailed view of the shoes worn by San Diego Padres right fielder Fernando Tatis Jr. (23) in honor of former Padres chairman Peter Seidler during the fifth inning against the San Francisco Giants at Petco Park.
Mar 28, 2024; San Diego, California, USA; A detailed view of the shoes worn by San Diego Padres right fielder Fernando Tatis Jr. (23) in honor of former Padres chairman Peter Seidler during the fifth inning against the San Francisco Giants at Petco Park. | Orlando Ramirez-Imagn Images

In this story:


It has been a whirlwind 24 hours for the San Diego Padres, as the sale of the team has taken a step forward on multiple fronts. As a refresher, the decision to sell the franchise was announced in November and stems from the passing of former owner Peter Seidler in 2023.

Since then, Seidler’s brothers have assumed control of the team while also dealing with a serious lawsuit filed by Seidler’s wife, Sheel Seidler. She initially accused brothers Matt and Bob Seidler of breaching their fiduciary duty by failing to distribute trust assets to her and failing to disclose their actions as trustees. 

While the lawsuit did not explicitly mention the Padres, it was widely understood that Sheel would be the sole beneficiary of the Padres trust - something that ultimately did not happen.

However, most of the claims against the brothers have now been dismissed, as Matt, Bob and Sheel have agreed to resolve the matter outside of court. Sheel’s decision to withdraw the lawsuit filed in Texas last month does not signal a family reconciliation, but rather a rapidly advancing sale of the franchise.

Despite the aggressive internal dispute over control of the Padres, the team is moving toward a sale, rendering the court case an unnecessary obstacle that would complicate the process. With that legal issue removed, the sale can proceed smoothly as the Seidler family determines how to distribute the assets and proceeds. While their dispute has not been fully resolved, eliminating the legal uncertainty helps protect the franchise’s value and paves the way for a cleaner ownership transition.

On the sales front, bids are officially coming in as some of the wealthiest owners in sports vie for one of the most valuable franchises in Major League Baseball. The Padres are currently valued at $2.31 billion by Sportico, though the Seidler family is expected to seek a price well above that figure.

Steve Cohen’s $2.42 billion purchase of the New York Mets in 2020 remains the record for an MLB franchise, but the Padres could surpass - and potentially shatter - that mark.

With no legal barriers remaining and general manager A.J. Preller exercising restraint in avoiding expensive long-term contracts this offseason, the Padres are positioned to maximize their sale price. A new ownership group is guaranteed to bring significant financial resources, continuing the late Seidler’s commitment to aggressive spending.

The bidding war is being led by a pair of European soccer owners - an ownership demographic known for its willingness to invest heavily. Dan Friedkin, owner of Everton and AS Roma, is reportedly looking to expand into baseball, while Chelsea owner José Feliciano is also believed to be in the mix.

Both would be welcomed additions given their global resources, though Friedkin is especially intriguing. His estimated net worth of $10 billion far exceeds Feliciano’s reported $3.9 billion, which would make Friedkin the third-richest owner in MLB behind Cohen and the Blue Jays’ ownership group.

With legal conflicts being resolved behind the scenes and serious bidders emerging, momentum is building quickly in San Diego. A new owner may not be in place by Opening Day, but the sooner the sale is finalized, the better - especially after what has been the Padres’ most difficult offseason since 2018.


Published
Gregory Spicer
GREGORY SPICER

Greg Spicer resides in San Diego, California, after growing up in Chicago where baseball was a constant presence throughout his life. He attends San Diego State University, gaining experience working for MLB teams in both Chicago and San Diego through stadium and game-day operations, while also covering athletics at SDSU. A White Sox fan who has since embraced Padres fandom, Greg has covered football, collegiate sports, MLB and the NBA for multiple outlets, including Fox 5/KUSI, before starting at On SI.

Share on XFollow Greg_Spicer_