SI

NFL Power Rankings, Week 9

Last year, rookie head coaches in the NFL were all the rage, as three of the four first-time hires took over last-place programs and immediately turned them

Last year, rookie head coaches in the NFL were all the rage, as three of the four first-time hires took over last-place programs and immediately turned them into playoff teams. The Dolphins, Ravens and Falcons were a combined 10-38 in 2007, but all three went 11-5 and made the postseason last year, thanks in large part to the work of Tony Sparano, John Harbaugh and Mike Smith.

But where are the Sparano-, Harbaugh- and Smith-like turnarounds this year? Nowhere in sight. Of the whopping 11 new head coaches, only two have teams with winning records: Jim Caldwell's Colts are 7-0, and Josh McDaniels' Broncos are 6-1. Nice work, but not exactly a worst-to-first story given that Indianapolis was 12-4 and a playoff team last season and Denver was 8-8, blowing a three-game lead in the AFC West with three weeks to go.

Here's the rest of the new coaches' report card after Week 8, and it's not pretty: Rex Ryan's Jets are 4-4 after going 9-7 last season; Mike Singletary's 49ers 3-4 after a 7-9 finish in 2008; Jim Mora's Seahawks 2-5 after last year's 4-12; Tom Cable's Raiders 2-6 after 5-11 last season; Eric Mangini's Browns 1-7 coming off a 4-12 mark; Todd Haley's Chiefs 1-6 after their 2-14 finish; Steve Spagnuolo's Rams 1-7 after going 2-14 in '08; Jim Schwartz's Lions 1-6 on the heels of their historic 0-16 last year; and Raheem Morris's 0-7 Bucs already have matched their 2008 loss total.

That's a paltry .346 combined winning percentage (28-53) for the 11 new head coaches, and a dismal .224 clip (15-52) for the nine not coaching the Colts and Broncos. No big turnarounds here. Last year, those 11 teams won at a slightly higher .352 rate (62-114), which dropped to .292 (42-102) when you subtracted Indy and Denver (20-12, .625).

Bottom line? Makes you appreciate all the more what Sparano, Harbaugh and Smith accomplished a year ago. On to the rankings... (Send comments to siwriters@simail.com)

NFL Power Rankings

1 - 10

11 - 20

21 - 32


Published | Modified
Don Banks
DON BANKS

Senior NFL writer Don Banks joined SI in 2000 after 10 years on the beat covering the Vikings and Buccaneers. His Snap Judgments cap off every Sunday of every NFL season.