By Joe Posnanski
November 05, 2009

NEW YORK -- The Yankees clubhouse reeked of champagne, it smelled the way you might imagine DonHo's living room used to smell. Well, this is what you get when you win a World Series. Here Mariano Rivera stood in the doorway waiting for family. There Mark Teixeira wore goggles and talked about how God led him to the right team. Over there two Yankees players prepared to double-team Johnny Damon with a champagne attack. The sound was laughter and happy souts and the popping of champagne corks.

And there's really only one question left worth asking: Why THIS Yankees team?

In one way, it's an easy question to answer: These Yankees were the best team in baseball in 2009. There really wasn't much doubt about that. They won 103 games, the most in baseball. They scored the most runs, they hit the most home runs, closed out the most saves. They were the best team, and in a World Series that offered just enough drama to keep the tabloids interesting (but no more), they closed out the Phillies in six games. They clinched their 27th World Series championship with a dry and bloodless 7-3 strangling Wednesday night in the new Yankee Stadium.

Still, in the larger sense, the question remains: Why THIS Yankees team? New York had not won a World Series since 2000, and while eight years hardly seems to be a dry spell, it is a major dry spell when you are spending a lot more money to get players than any other team. And the Yankees spent a lot more money every year. Well, in 2001, they spent only about $3 million more than the team with the second-highest payroll. But they lost the World Series in seven games (to the EXPANSION Arizona Diamondbacks, for crying out loud), and it was time for some serious New York overkill.

2002: Yankees spent $17 million more on payroll than any other team.

2003: Yankees spend $35 million more.

2004: Yankees spend $57 million more.

2005: Yankees spend $85 million more.

2006: Yankees spend $74 million more.

2007: Yankees spend $40 million more.

2008: Yankees spend $72 million more.

Now, look, when you are spending that much more money than any other team -- and remember this is more than ANY team -- you should win. You better win. You have no excuses when you don't win. The Yankees won plenty of games -- averaged 97 victories a year -- and they won some playoff series. But they didn't win it all.

And you heard it everywhere: Something was missing. The Yankees got shut out by a young Josh Beckett. The Yankees blew a 3-0 lead against Boston. The Yankees got taken out by teams from Cleveland and Detroit and Anaheim. Something was missing. Character? Focus? Hunger? Everyone had theories. The Yankees didn't have enough pitching. They didn't have the cohesiveness of their great teams. They hired too many mercenaries who did not know what it meant to play for the New York Yankees.

Or simply: Blame it on A-Rod.

So what made this Yankees team different? Well, they spent a lot of money to bring in two big-money starting pitchers (CC Sabathia and A.J. Burnett). That helped. They spent a lot of money to bring in the biggest free-agent hitter on the market (Teixeira). That helped, too. There were stories about the Yankees players refocusing -- Derek Jeter worked out with a new trainer, and Alex Rodriguez searched for inner peace after a dreadful and painful spring training, and Mariano Rivera had a little surgery to clean out his shoulder and so on.

And the Yankees had another great season and made the playoffs again. They swept an overmatched and generous Twins team in the first round. They beat a surprisingly jittery Angels team in the ALCS. They reached the World Series for the first time since 2003, and they talked about how this team was different from the last eight years.

But the World Series is a whole different thing. It's different because it's volatile. There's no definitive formula for winning the World Series -- the best teams famously do not always win. A seven-game series is simply too short. Baseball has too many variables. Sometimes experience plays a big role in victory, sometimes it's youthful exuberance that is decisive. Sometimes luck plays. Sometimes destiny takes a hand.

Sometimes, a good starting pitcher does just enough to win, or someone makes a great play that changes the landscape or a shut-down bullpen makes the difference or a hot hitter can make the series his own.

The Yankees got all that -- and they got all that from familiar players. Andy Pettitte was the gutsy pitcher who, without great stuff, kept the Phillies from having that big and decisive inning. He won two games.

Damon made the big play. In the pivotal Game 4, with the score tied in the ninth, he paddled through a ferocious battle against Phillies closer Brad Lidge, finally rapped a single, the stole second and third on the same play. Lidge seemed rattled. Lidge hit the next batter then gave up back-to-back hits to Rodriguez and Jorge Posada.

Mariano Rivera represented that shut-down bullpen. Neither team seemed capable of getting outs late in games ... except when The Great Rivera was on the mound. He pitched in four games, and he did not give up a run.

Finally, the Yankees had that hot hitter. There was definitely a creeping panic in New York before Wednesday's Game 6. The New York Daily News warned manager Joe Girardi "You Better Be Right." The New YorkPost's cover featured Pedro Martinez in a diaper and demaded that the team "Spank Him." There was this sense of desperation in the air. The Yankees had to wrap this thing up. The city couldn't take much more.

And the Yankees had any number of players who could have been the star. It could have been Derek Jeter, of course, the Yankee captain. It could have been A-Rod, one of the best to ever play the game. It could have been Johnny Damon, who had been a force behind the Red Sox's first championship. It could have been Mark Teixeira.

But in many ways Hideki Matsui was as likely a choice as any of them. Matsui has been a baseball star on two continents for 17 years. He won three championships in Japan, was a three-time MVP in Japan, when he signed with the Yankees they held a parade down the streets of Tokyo in his honor. They called him Godzilla. His first game at Yankee Stadium, he hit a grand slam.

And so, what was Game 6 of the World Series? Another big game. His first at-bat against Pedro Martinez he ripped three fouls, each seemingly hit harder than the last, until finally Pedro left a ball over the plate and Matsui kept the ball fair for a two-run homer. Next inning, he again ripped a foul ball against Pedro before cracking a two-run single on a line drive. Two innings later, this time against J.A. Happ, he hit a two-run double -- that gave him six RBIs. Only one player -- Bobby Richardson in 1960 -- ever drove in six runs in a single World Series game.

"He hit whatever we threw him," Philadelphia manager Charlie Manuel said, once more cutting right to the point.

So, you can say that there was something different about this Yankees team, something sturdier. The chemistry was better. They had a sense of purpose. And so on. And maybe all of that's true. It's hard to say. Matsui was a part of the last few Yankees teams that did not win. So were Jeter and Damon and Pettitte and A-Rod and those other thirty-somethings who sprayed champagne on each other in the clubhouse. The Yankees have long had Rivera to finish off games, and they have long had expensive starting pitchers with glitzy resumes, and they have been built around Jeter for a long time, and they have always had the New York fans who play their role.

So: Why THIS Yankees team? Well, the Yankees were once again a terrific team. And as for the rest -- it probably comes down to that most unsatisfying of clichés: It was just their year.

You May Like

Eagle (-2)
Birdie (-1)
Bogey (+1)
Double Bogey (+2)