- Better than Ezekiel Elliott? Evaluators around the NFL think so. The Penn State running back is emerging as a generational talent and is being viewed as a true franchise player as the league goes back to the future with power-running offenses
The Titans, built sturdy and tough up front, rushed for 195 yards on the vaunted Seahawks defense on Sunday. The Ravens spent the last two offseason getting younger and quicker on defense, and that group kept the Bengals and Browns out of the end zone in Weeks 1 and 2. Then in London, a Jaguars offense reworked this offseason with size in mind ran for 166 yards on them.
This is how the NFL works. Teams spent the last decade building around quarterbacks and receivers, and defenses are now stocked with 220-pound linebackers and 250-pound pass rushers. And now we’re getting the zig to that zag—personnel czars like Jacksonville’s Tom Coughlin and Tennessee’s Jon Robinson capitalized by building jackhammer offenses to run at those defenses, while creating better environments for their young QBs.
“That’s been going on since the 1970s,” said one NFC personnel exec. “It’s not a new trend, it’s the same cycle. New people rise in the football world, history repeats itself.”
Enter Saquon Barkley. In the four drafts between 2011 and ’14, only one running back, Alabama’s Trent Richardson, went in the top half of the first round. In the last three drafts, five tailbacks—Todd Gurley, Melvin Gordon, Ezekiel Elliott, Leonard Fournette and Christian McCaffrey—have gone within the top 16 picks. And Barkley might be better than any of them.
Moreover, he’s coming along at the right time. Teams are considering retro looks offensively, which can prop up young quarterbacks, help the defense, and exploit opponents built to combat high-end passing attacks. So where the value of running backs may have recently declined, it seems now demand for a 230-pound, three-down, 21st-century style bellcow, a la Elliott or Joe Mixon, is on the rise.
“You can build an offense around him,” said one AFC exec of Barkley. “He’s so f---ing good. Zeke is solid in all areas. Fournette is a special athlete for the position. This kid? He’s way better than both of them . . . He’s a step above Zeke in all categories, and has much better hands and feet and vision than Fournette does. He’s special. I haven’t seen a better college football player.”
“When I first saw Zeke, it was his explosion from the line to the second level that was rare, and Saquon’s is probably a little better,” said another NFC personnel director. “There’s something different about this guy, he has rare things about him—his explosion, his balance, his vision, his ability to cut laterally. Someone hits him and he lands on his feet. And he’s tougher than s---. He steps up in pass protection.”
What we all saw on Saturday, in a game that Penn State seemed to be in the process of blowing at Iowa, was the virtual trailer to what Barkley could be at the next level. He ripped through the Hawkeyes defense for 211 yards and a touchdown on 28 carries, and caught 12 balls for 94 yards, and returned for three kicks for 53 yards. His fourth-quarter hurdle of Iowa corner Josh Jackson to convert a third-and-6 was a moment you’ll see replayed a ton in March and April. There wasn’t a moment when there was any doubt who the best player on the field was.
So there’s a better than good chance that there will an NFL offense built around the true junior at this time next year, the same way Elliott had an offense built around him as a rookie last year. That Barkley could be better than the league’s reigning rushing champion makes this one even more interesting. And how a retro-minded team might view him as a true centerpiece adds another layer.
“If you look you at it from our perspective, the ideal back today has to be able to do everything,” said an AFC college scouting director. “There’s not great value in the first- and second-down back anymore, or a guy who’s just a third-down scatback. You want a guy who does everything. And that’s Zeke, it’s Mixon, and it’s Saquon Barkley.”
The last time a running back went first overall was in 1995, and it was another Penn State Nittany Lion: Ki-Jana Carter. The quarterbacks will almost certainly prevent Barkley from breaking that drought. But after that? His wait won’t be long.
FIVE FROM SATURDAY
1. I’ve spent a lot of time over the last few months explaining the NFL’s offensive line crisis, but there are signs that help is on the way. Notre Dame guard Quenton Nelson and tackle Mike McGlinchey, Oklahoma tackle Orlando Brown, Clemson tackle Mitch Hyatt, Washington tackle Trey Adams and Ohio State center Billy Price are all showing potential ahead of 2018.
2. Michigan linebacker Devin Bush is a true sophomore, so he won’t be draft eligible until 2019. But the son of the former Falcons, Rams and Browns safety was all over the place, again, in the Wolverines’ win over Purdue.
3. Watching Washington crush Colorado to run its record to 4-0—after the mass exodus to the NFL they went through last spring—again makes me wonder if Huskies coach Chris Petersen would ever consider the NFL. Be it at Boise or in Seattle, he’s always gotten the most out of the talent on his roster, and he’s played giant killer at both schools.
4. Speaking of reloading—and this was not a surprise—but what a statement by Nick Saban and Alabama on Saturday, taking an upstart Vanderbilt team and effectively stuffing them in a locker. The Tide outgained Vandy 677-78 in total yardage and had a 38-3 edge in first downs in the 59-0 road rout over the previously perfect Commodores.
5. Florida benching Feleipe Franks and going back to Luke Del Rio creates a fun quarterback showdown for Saturday. The son of Raiders coach Jack Del Rio will lead the Gators into a home game against those rebound-minded Commodores and Kyle Shurmur, son of Vikings offensive coordinator Pat Shurmur. Their dads actually did go head-to-head as head coaches once: On November 20, 2011, Shurmur’s Browns beat Del Rio’s Jaguars 14-10.
1. Saquon Barkley, RB, Penn State
2. Sam Darnold, QB, USC
3. Minkah Fitzpatrick, DB, Alabama
4. Arden Key, EDGE, LSU
5. Derwin James, S, Florida State
6. Josh Rosen, QB, UCLA
7. Quenton Nelson, OG, Notre Dame
8. Christian Wilkins, DT, Clemson
9. Harold Landry, EDGE, Boston College
10. Josh Allen, QB, Wyoming
Three receivers that I considered that are on the periphery: SMU’s Courtland Sutton, Alabama’s Calvin Ridley and Texas A&M’s Christian Kirk . . . Three defensive players on the rise: Michigan DT Maurice Hurst, Virginia Tech LB Tremaine Edmunds, Ohio State CB Denzel Ward.
Top of the Class:
1. Sam Darnold, USC (15-29, 164 yards, 0 TD, INT vs. Washington State): It’ll take a little more than the Friday night stumble for Darnold to knock Darnold off his perch, but we’ve mentioned his problems protecting the ball before. Both his turnovers were avoidable.
2. Josh Rosen, UCLA (28-45, 372 yards, TD, INT vs. Colorado): Credit to Rosen for stopping the bleeding at home against the defending Pac-12 South champs. And for looking good doing it.
3. Josh Allen, Wyoming (14-24, 219 yards, 3 TDs, 0 INT): Allen’s starting to adjust to all the new personnel around him.
Helped Himself: Luke Falk, Washington State. Since we hit on Darnold earlier, it’s definitely worth checking in on the guy who outdueled him on Friday. And Washington State senior Luke Falk impressed those evaluating him with more than just his stat line (34-51, 340 yards, 2 TDs, INT). It was his ability to go through progression reads and make solid decisions against a team with more physical ability than his own. Falk will be an interesting one to watch going forward.
Hurt Himself: Riley Ferguson, Memphis. It was easy to like Riley Ferguson’s effort in Memphis’s upset of UCLA, and former Tennessee transfer certainly brings some physical ability to the table. But the senior can’t afford too many more afternoons like the one he had at UCF—Ferguson threw three picks and lost a fumble in a 40-13 loss at UCF. All four turnovers happened in the second and third quarters, and worked to blow a close game wide open.
Christian Kirk and Texans A&M vs. Alabama (Saturday, ESPN, 7:15 p.m.): Based on what we’ve seen so far, I’m not necessarily expecting this game to be close. But SEC players know that the first tape a scout is going to pop in to study them will be the Alabama tape, and so it should be good to see what the electric, do-everything Kirk puts on that tape. The junior receiver/return man is due for a big game.
• Question or comment? Email us at firstname.lastname@example.org.