Skip to main content

Overrated on an Underrated Team?

The NFC North has several overrated players according to publishers of the FanNation websites, and even the Bears have one as a team rated at the bottom of the league by many analysts.

It was in 2006  that Sports Illustrated conducted a poll asking a few NFL players on each team to anonimously name the most overrated players.

They voted for Terrell Owens as No. 1, with Brian Urlacher placing second. 

Urlacher that year led the fabled "They Are Who We Thought They Were" comeback win over Arizona with a super-human game, and helped the Bears go on to the Super Bowl. Of course, he made the Pro Football Hall of Fame on the first ballot. Owens is third in alltime receiving yards, eighth in receptions and made it to Canton—although he didn't make it there in person for the ceremony.

So much for overrated. It's all a matter of who is doing the rating.

There probably are overrated players in the league and on each team, even the Bears. This might seem strange because they aren't being rated very high by anyone, but it's true.

Here are the division's most overrated players by team according to FanNation publishers who cover those franchises. Each of these players can only hope they treat the tags in the same manner as Urlacher and Owens.

NFC North Most Overrated


The Eddie Jackson who has played the last two seasons is much different than the one who made Pro Bowls in 2018-19 or made 10 interceptions and scored five touchdowns in 2017-19. After signing his four-year, $58.4 million deal, Jackson's statistics fell off sharply. It occurred at the same time the rest of the Bears secondary declined, so laying it all on Jackson is unfair but the numbers reflect his part in it. As a former two-time Pro Bowl player, a higher level is expected. Sportradar credits Jackson with eight TD passes allowed the last two seasons and passer ratings against of 110.1 and 143.6 when targeted. This after he had spectacular ratings against of 40.5 and 57.6 in 2018-19. Jackson hasn't made an interception in 30 games, although he had a few overturned by defensive penalties.

Jackson has really not been the same since the Bears lost safety Adrian Amos to Green Bay in free agency. There is hope rookie Jaquan Brisker can be more of a force closer to the line of scrimmage as Amos had been. It could free Jackson up to do what he had done best and that was go for the football. Also, the new defensive scheme is one favoring players who read the quarterback and go after the ball, and that has always been a strength of Jackson's. Or, at least it was. It seems he must prove himself all over again after struggling for two years.

-Gene Chamberlain, BearDigest


Prior to landing with the Detroit Lions in 2021, Harris spent time with both the Miami Dolphins and Atlanta Falcons.

Harris, a former 2017 first-round NFL draft pick, was a player who benefited mightily from playing in defensive coordinator Aaron Glenn's defensive scheme, which took advantage of his strengths as a pass rusher.

In 2021, Harris recorded career highs in tackles (65), quarterback hits (16), tackles for loss (10) and pressures (34). Unfortunately, his performance was sporadic. He went six consecutive weeks without a sack after having a four-game sack streak from Weeks 2-5.

Among the question marks heading into the 2022 season is whether Harris' performance was simply an anomaly or a sign of things to come.

Even Harris acknowledged to reporters he left a lot of plays out on the field, something he is looking to correct this season.

"Mentality wise, I think I've been able to go back and watch a lot of film from last last year and see the plays that could have been made, but didn't get made," Harris said. "I think that's kind of where I am this year. If I added every play I could have made, numbers would be crazy."

Detroit now has added additional defensive linemen via this year's draft, which should bode well for a competitive training camp.

-John Maakaron, All Lions


It’s not that Jones isn’t a good player. Heck, he’s a very good player and will be a big factor most weeks as a runner and receiver. But, notably, the 2020 Pro Bowler wasn't quite as good last season. Running backs have a limited shelf life and perhaps the 27-year-old is getting close to the end of his prime time.

At this time last year, Jones ranked sixth in NFL history with a career mark of 5.17 yards per carry (minimum 600 carries). In three of his first four seasons, he averaged at least 5.47. Last year, however, his average slipped to 4.67.

After back-to-back seasons of 1,084 rushing yards in 2019 and 1,104 rushing yards in 2020, Jones slipped to 799 rushing yards last season. Compared to 2020, his yards after contact dropped from 3.54 per rush to 3.18, according to Pro Football Focus. Notably, for an explosive, shifty runner, his 10-yard runs plunged from an average of 24.3 the previous three seasons to only 16 last year.

Scroll to Continue

Read More

With a revamped receiver corps, Packers coach Matt LaFleur might have to rely more on the running game. Fortunately for him, he’s got Jones and AJ Dillon providing an excellent one-two punch. But the ascending Dillon could emerge as the lead back and Jones, whose cap number explodes to $20 million in 2023, could be entering his final season with the team.

-Bill Huber, Packer Central


Cousins is one of the most polarizing players in recent memory. Some people have a proper idea of who he is as a quarterback, and some probably even underrate him a bit. Still, it seems like the majority of people—including the Vikings' own front office and coaching staff—overrate his abilities.

With a career record of 59-59-2 as a starter, Cousins has made it abundantly clear that he is a .500 quarterback. No, wins aren't exclusively a QB stat, but at some point, your record is who you are. Cousins is paid like a top-five quarterback and viewed by many Vikings fans as a top-10 player at the position, despite the reality that he's somewhere in the 13-16 range.

Cousins' impressive accuracy is overshadowed by his conservative decision-making, inconsistent pocket presence, and struggles to create outside of structure. Adding to that, his refusal to get vaccinated against COVID-19 caused him to miss a must-win game for the Vikings' playoff hopes last year. After one postseason berth in four seasons, it's apparent that the Vikings made the wrong call when they signed Cousins to a huge deal in 2018.

And yet, the team's new brass decided to double down this offseason with another extension. Maybe Cousins escapes this label in 2022 under Kevin O'Connell, but it's difficult to feel particularly confident in that happening.

-Will Ragatz, Inside the Vikings

Twitter: BearDigest@BearsOnMaven