Skip to main content

Top Draft Prospect Compared to Former Cardinals QB

Michigan QB J.J. McCarthy resembles a certain former Arizona Cardinals QB.

ARIZONA -- Michigan Wolverines QB J.J. McCarthy has seen quite the rise in draft stock over the last few months, and ESPN sees a resemblance from a former Arizona Cardinals quarterback.

ESPN's Matt Miller picked Jake Plummer as McCarthy's pro comparison in terms of style and play:

"McCarthy enjoyed a breakout 2023 season with more freedom in the Michigan offense, and his draft stock improved immensely. The junior has good arm strength and can speed up his release for better velocity. He's also an accomplished runner who isn't afraid to put his shoulder down to take on linebackers at the goal line. McCarthy is just 21 years old and still developing, and it shows at times in his ball placement. But he's a fast learner when he does make mistakes on the field. He finished third in the nation in QBR (88.2) while completing 72.3% of his throws. I have McCarthy lower here than his likely draft range; recent buzz around the league says he's a potential top-six pick."

Both quarterbacks during their respective careers in college had the coveted "it" factor with success for their individual programs. McCarthy - like Plummer - wasn't quite viewed as an athletic freak of nature, though both as prospects were able to move around and make plays with their legs if needed.

Oddly enough, McCarthy could end up being picked with the No. 4 overall pick, a spot the Cardinals currently hold but are hefty candidates to trade out of.

Teams who are rumored to be interested in a move up for McCarthy are the Minnesota Vikings, Denver Broncos, Las Vegas Raiders and New York Giants.

The 2024 NFL Draft begins on April 25.