Hield and Valentine lead SI's 2016 All-America Team
7:58 | College Basketball
Hield and Valentine lead SI's 2016 All-America Team
Friday March 11th, 2016

NASHVILLE, Tenn. — The question was a fair one, but it still seemed to catch Damian Jones off guard. As Vanderbilt’s senior forward sat high atop a podium after his team’s opening game of the SEC tournament, he paused. An onlooker had posed a relatively black-and-white query to Jones: Do you feel like you’re still in?

Vanderbilt’s lanky forward shrugged. “Time will tell,” an emotionless Jones said. “We’ll see what happens.”

Jones, of course, was referring to Vanderbilt’s hopes of making the NCAA tournament, a feat once considered a foregone conclusion for such a talented roster. But the unforgiving reality of conference tournaments reared its head at the Commodores in Nashville’s Bridgestone Arena on Thursday. The result? An inexcusable, 67–65 second-round loss to 12th-seeded Tennessee, which ended Vanderbilt’s stint in the SEC tournament on the very day it began.

• Latest tournament bracket, bubble updates | Every NCAA tourney bid so far

College Basketball
Iowa exits Big Ten tournament early as stunning collapse continues

Now the Commodores, who looked the part of an SEC title contender in the preseason, find themselves sweating ahead of Selection Sunday. Vanderbilt simply needed to avoid an embarrassing exit in the SEC tournament to remove doubt about its postseason plans. Instead, coach Kevin Stallings’s program laid a black-and-gold egg at the worst possible time, a performance that might end up spoiling Vanderbilt’s shot at the Big Dance.

The Commodores had won six of their final eight regular-season games heading into Thursday, but they looked anything but hot in the early moments against Tennessee. The Vols forced Vanderbilt into 10 first-half turnovers and led by as many as 15 points. UT had lost the in-state matchup twice this season by a combined 31 points, but it headed to the locker room with a 34–22 advantage at halftime. “I thought Tennessee really was aggressive in the first half, and I thought we played a little tentative early,” Stallings said.

But Vanderbilt emerged from the locker room re-energized. Stallings and his staff threw a zone defense and a 2–1–2 press at Tennessee, which stalled the Vols’ offense. Meanwhile, the ‘Dores regained life, gradually chipping away at Tennessee’s lead. A three-pointer by Joe Toye with 4:19 to play gave Vanderbilt a 57–56 advantage, its first since leading 4–2 early in the first half. The Commodores were beginning to look the part of an SEC champion.

Tennessee bounced back and led 67–65 when guard Detrick Mostella stepped up for a one-and-one opportunity with five seconds to play. When Mostella clanked the first shot, Commodores forward Luke Kornet hauled in the rebound and quickly dished to teammate Wade Baldwin. The senior sliced through a sea of orange jerseys and banked in a layup at the buzzer. Just like that, Vanderbilt was heading to overtime tied 67–67 with Tennessee.

Andy Lyons/Getty Images

Vanderbilt’s sideline erupted as teammates swarmed Baldwin. “We thought the shot was good,” Jones said, “so we were just preparing and getting everything set just to keep going.” But an official review halted the Commodores’ sudden euphoria: Baldwin had failed to get the shot off in time. Somehow, the Vols had survived with a win. “We knew they had to make a run in the second half,” Tennessee coach Rick Barnes said, “and I was just really pleased with the way we kept our poise when they did that.”

But poise had no business residing on Tennessee’s bench. Vanderbilt’s roster was tailor-made for poise, a deep and talented group built to wipe the floor with a rebuilding Vols squad. An undersized Tennessee team didn’t start a player taller than 6'7"—Vanderbilt’s lineup included two seven-footers in Kornet and Jones—yet the Vols matched the Commodores’ 30 points in the paint. Meanwhile, Barnes used just seven players in his team’s limited rotation, with one Volunteer, guard Shembari Phillips, notching just nine minutes. The deck was stacked against Tennessee, but Stallings and company inexcusably folded on a big stage.

College Basketball
Seniors take centerstage on SI’s 2016 All-America teams

Now the Commodores have nothing left to do but wait, a feeling all too familiar to Vanderbilt fans. Since reaching the Sweet Sixteen under Stallings in 2007, the ‘Dores have turned several promising seasons into early March exits. Behind Jones, a potential NBA lottery pick, and big-time playmakers like Baldwin and Kornet, Vanderbilt entered this season expected to author another deep run into March. Instead the program often played down to its opponents, dropping games against non-tournament teams like Arkansas, Mississippi State and Ole Miss in SEC play. And unfortunately, it saved its worst SEC loss—to a sub-.500 Tennessee team—for last.

Stallings hinted that the burden of expectations weighed on his roster as it entered tournament play. His Commodores knew they shouldered a slim margin of error, and that hesitation manifested itself against Tennessee. “These guys are very intelligent,” he said. “They know that there’s a lot on the line, and there’s been a lot on the line for us for the last several weeks. I just thought maybe we played a little tight [against Tennessee].”

HAMILTON: House leading Texas A&M to long-awaited tournament bid

The Commodores’ NCAA hopes have not totally vanished, of course. They finished the regular season on a 7–3 run (upping their overall record to 19–13 and SEC record to 11–7), with wins over Kentucky and Texas A&M during that stretch. Their strength of schedule (27th) and RPI (51) will still work to their advantage. But can the Vanderbilt team that failed to show up against Tennessee (15–18, 6–12) convince the selection committee of its tournament worth?

Those questions—and the program’s future—will weigh on the Commodores for the rest of this week. “I guess we’ve just got to wait,” guard Matthew Fisher-Davis said, “and see what happens on Sunday.”

SI Apps
We've Got Apps Too
Get expert analysis, unrivaled access, and the award-winning storytelling only SI can provide - from Peter King, Tom Verducci, Lee Jenkins, Seth Davis, and more - delivered straight to you, along with up-to-the-minute news and live scores.