Closer Rankings: Chapman back and hurling fire, Shaw replaces Axford

Friday May 16th, 2014

Aroldis Chapman has already racked up five strikeouts and a save since returning from his injury.
Al Behrman/AP

The closer position is constantly changing, so we'll keep you up to date with who's in and who's not with our rankings below. This week, Aroldis Chapman leaps up to the No. 2 spot, returning to the game nearly two months after taking a line drive off the face. He picked up his first save of the season, striking out the side against Colorado on May 11. He gave up a home run to Padres' Chase Headley in his following outing, but don't let that take away from the fact that he's hurling 99 mph fastballs on a regular basis.

FANTASY BASEBALL WEEK 7: Power rankings | Pitching report | Hitting report | Waiver wire | Prospect watch | Twitter chat highlights | May 16 news -- Who'll be the next Mets' closer?

Rankings and information to date as of May 16. An asterisk next to a player's name indicates additional notes below.

Fantasy Baseball Closer Rankings


Craig Kimbrel

Craig Kimbrel

Atlanta Braves


Aroldis Chapman*

Cincinnati Reds


Kenley Jansen

Kenley Jansen

Los Angeles Dodgers


Greg Holland

Greg Holland

Kansas City Royals


Sergio Romo

San Francisco Giants


Koji Uehara

Boston Red Sox


Rafael Soriano*

Washington Nationals


Joe Nathan

Detroit Tigers


Francisco Rodriguez

Milwaukee Brewers


Glen Perkins

Minnesota Twins


Huston Street*

San Diego Padres


Steve Cishek

Miami Marlins


Joakim Soria*

Texas Rangers


David Robertson

New York Yankees


Jonathan Papelbon

Philadelphia Phillies


Casey Janssen*

Toronto Blue Jays


Trevor Rosenthal*

St. Louis Cardinals


Grant Balfour

Tampa Bay Rays


Fernando Rodney

Seattle Mariners


LaTroy Hawkins

Colorado Rockies


Matt Lindstrom*

Chicago White Sox


Mark Melancon

Pittsburgh Pirates


Addison Reed*

Arizona Diamondbacks


Ernesto Frieri

Los Angeles Angels


Hector Rondon

Chicago Cubs


Bryan Shaw*

Cleveland Indians


Sean Doolittle

Oakland A's


Jenrry Mejia*

New York Mets


Zach Britton*

Baltimore Orioles


Jeurys Familia*

New York Mets


Chad Qualls*

Houston Astros


Brad Ziegler*

Arizona Diamondbacks


Jesse Crain*

Houston Astros


Tommy Hunter

Baltimore Orioles


Darren O'Day

Baltimore Orioles


Jason Grilli*

Pittsburgh Pirates


Cody Allen

Cleveland Indians


Joe Smith

Los Angeles Angels


Joaquin Benoit

San Diego Padres


Jim Johnson

Oakland A's


Drew Storen

Washington Nationals


Luke Gregerson

Oakland A's


Daniel Webb

Chicago White Sox


Carlos Martinez

St. Louis Cardinals


Danny Farquhar

Seattle Mariners


Mike Adams

Philadelphia Phillies


Tyler Clippard

Washington Nationals


Carlos Torres

New York Mets


John Axford

Cleveland Indians


Junichi Tazawa

Boston Red Sox

Rankings updated as of May 16

2. Aroldis Chapman, Cincinnati Reds -- Chapman has been back for a week and already has the most pitches of at least 99 mph this season.

7. Rafael Soriano, Washington Nationals -- Soriano gave up his first runs of the season while blowing a save against the A's on May 10.

11. Huston Street, San Diego Padres -- It's hard to envision that Street will be in a San Diego uniform after the July 31 trade deadline, and that could be a risk for his current fantasy owners. It might not be a bad time to see what sort of price he can fetch on the market.

13. Joakim Soria, Texas Rangers -- Soria's FIP is 0.81, he has allowed eight baserunners in 14 innings, and he has 19 strikeouts against two walks. What a shrewd signing by Jon Daniels last year.

16. Casey Janssen, Toronto Blue Jays -- Janssen has allowed one hit and one walk in his three innings since coming off the DL. He has converted both of his save opportunities, as well.

17. Trevor Rosenthal, St. Louis Cardinals -- Rosenthal has not been the lockdown closer the Cardinals envisioned after he dominated out of the bullpen last year, posting a 4.74 ERA and 1.42 WHIP in 19 innings.

21. Matt Lindstrom, Chicago White Sox -- After a shaky start to the season, Lindstrom has corrected course and taken a firm grip of the ninth-inning duties for the White Sox. He has surrenderred two runs in his last seven innings, and those came with the White Sox trailing by nine runs.

23. Addison Reed, Arizona Diamondbacks -- Reed recently received a vote of confidence from Kirk Gibson, but he still could be in danger of losing his job. He has a 5.03 ERA and 5.49 FIP in 19 2/3 innings.

26. Bryan Shaw, Cleveland Indians -- Shaw got the first save for the Indians A.A. (After Axford), so consider him the favorite in the bullpen for now.

28. Jenrry Mejia, New York Mets -- Terry Collins said the Mets will go with a committee approach for the time being, but there's no doubt that Mejia has shutdown-closer stuff. He could really take this job and run with it.

29. Zach Britton, Baltimore Orioles -- Britton picked up the save for the Orioles on May 15, the first pitcher other than the struggling Tommy Hunter to notch a save for Baltimore this season. If Hunter is indeed on the outs, Britton would be the favorite to hold down the job.

30. Jeurys Familia, New York Mets -- Familia should factor into the Mets' closer committee, but he's running second to Jenrry Mejia for now.

31. Chad Qualls, Houston Astros -- Qualls has a save and a win in his last two outings, and he earned that win after pitching the top of the ninth in a tie game, typically a spot for the closer. He looks to be the man in Houston for now, which doesn't actually say a whole lot.

32. Brad Ziegler, Arizona Diamondbacks -- Ziegler has been the most effective reliever in Arizona's bullpen, putting up a 2.53 ERA, 2.91 FIP and 1.03 WHIP in 21 1/3 innings. If Kirk Gibson decides to demote Addison Reed, Ziegler would likely ascend to the closer's chair.

33. Jesse Crain, Houston Astros -- Crain is still expected back sometime in late May or early June. He'll likely get right into the closing mix in Houston when he's off the DL.

36. Jason Grilli, Pittsburgh Pirates -- Grilli threw a two-inning simulated game on May 14, and will shortly head out on a rehab assignment before joining the Pirates. The team could, however, ease him back into the closer's role, espeically with Mark Melancon pitching so well.

SI Apps
We've Got Apps Too
Get expert analysis, unrivaled access, and the award-winning storytelling only SI can provide - from Peter King, Tom Verducci, Lee Jenkins, Seth Davis, and more - delivered straight to you, along with up-to-the-minute news and live scores.