Walsh Jesuit Takes Down Toledo Central Catholic in Ohio Football Showdown

Toledo Central Catholic visited Walsh Jesuit in a battle of Ohio high school football powerhouses on Friday. In the end, the Warriors took advantage for a majority of the contest for the 38-25 victory.
Junior Dominic Courtad led the rushing attack for Walsh Jesuit as he finished with two rushing touchdowns. One offensive highlight for the Warriors was when senior quarterback David Ternosky threw a backwards pass to Cayden Levert, who then connected with Sam Barrett for a 24-yard trick play touchdown.
Meanwhile, senior Jeremiah Fuller scored both of Central Catholic's touchdowns in the first half, with the first being on a 97-yard kickoff returned for a score, and then on a short TD run.
Trailing 38-13 early in the fourth quarter, the Irish attempted to rally with Fuller finding the end zone for the third time, followed by quarterback Kasyn Ditmeyer scoring on a seven-yard keeper. However, the comeback attempt was too little, too late.
Refresh This Page for the Latest Live Updates
FINAL
Walsh Jesuit 38, Cental Catholic 25
Courtad keeps pounding the rock for a couple first downs. The Warriors then take a knee to run out the clock for the victory.
Central Catholic attempts another onside kick but it goes out of bounds. Walsh Jesuit's next possession begins at the Irish 45.
TOUCHDOWN! On 1st and goal at the 7, Ditmeyer keeps it himself and takes it in for the seven-yard score. Two-point conversion no good, as Central Catholic cuts it to 38-25.
On 2nd and 10 at their own 40, Ditmeyer scrambles and hits a wide open Amari Eliano, a Syracuse commit, as he races down the right sideline for a big gain inside the Warriors 10.
Central Catholic's next possession begins at their own 20. On 3rd and 2, Ditmeyer connects with Peyton Barringer across the middle for a big gain and the first down.
Walsh Jesuit's offense begins at their own 47. They are unable to move the ball and are forced to punt.
Central Catholic then attempts a surprise onside kick, but the ball is recovered by Walsh Jesuit's Emmett Tobin, who takes a big hit.
TOUCHDOWN! On 3rd and goal at the 1, Fuller goes up the middle and scores. However, the extra point is no good, as Central Catholic cuts it to 38-19 with 6:42 left in the game.
On 1st and 10 at midfield, Ditmeyer connects with Yarbrough across the Warriors 30 for a big gain and the first down. Then, Fuller gets the carry, breaks a tackle and picks up a chunk of yardage and goes out at the 9.
Central Catholic beigns at their own 20. On 3rd and 8, Ditmeyer scrambles with the ball and picks up enough yards for the first down, but gets leveled at the end of the play. Then on 3rd and 6, Ditmeyer keeps it himself again and picks up another first down.
FIELD GOAL! Walsh Jesuit converts on a 21-yard field goal by Oliver Nonno to make it 38-13 early in the fourth.
END OF 3RD QUARTER
Walsh Jesuit 35, Central Catholic 13
On 1st and 10 at the Irish 45, Ternosky fires a deep pass down the right sideline and connects with Cameron Brunson inside the 10, resulting in a 1st and goal. Time runs out in the quarter.
Central Catholic begins at their own 20. On 3rd and short, Ditmeyer gets sacked by Buckner again for a big loss, resulting in a punt.
TOUCHDOWN! On 1st and goal at the 9, Ternosky dumps the ball off to Wollschleger, who takes it in for the nine-yard score. Walsh Jesuit leads 35-13 with 2:47 left in the third.
On 3rd and 3 at the 30, Courtad breaks out a huge run up the middle into the red zone and goes down at the 10 for another first down.
After a fair catch, Walsh Jesuit begins at the Irish 48. Courtad picks up a first down on a short carry on 3rd and 3.
Central Catholic's next possession starts at their own 20. Walsh Jesuit's Caleb Buckner comes through with a tackle and a sack behind the line of scrimmage on back-to-back plays. Ditmeyer then keeps it himself for a big gain but is short of the first down, resulting in a punt.
TOUCHDOWN! After a seven-yard carry, Kourtad takes it in from one yard out. Walsh Jesuit leads 28-13 in the third quarter.
On 2nd and 9, Ternosky connects with Barrett near the sideline at the 25 for another first down. Kourtad then breaks more tackles down the left sideline for a big gain and a 1st and goal at the 8.
On 2nd and 11, snap is low as Ternosky rolls to his right and finds Cameron Brunson over the middle as he goes down at the Irish 38 for the first down.
On the opening kickoff to the second half, Caden Levert races across midfield for a big return to the Irish 35. However, a personal foul after the play moves Walsh Jesuit back to their own 49.
HALFTIME
Walsh Jesuit 21, Central Catholic 13
Walsh Jesuit begins at their own 10. They run a couple plays as the clock runs out on the first half.
On the ensuing kickoff, John Wollschleger gets a big return down the right sideline across midfield, but an illegal blindside block moves Walsh Jesuit back. A random helmet came off during the return as well.
TOUCHDOWN! On 1st and goal at the 3, Fuller takes the handoff, breaks some tackles, and gets in the end zone from three yards out. Central Catholic cuts the deficit to 21-13 with a minute left in the half.
On the next play, Ditmeyer fires deep again to Yarbrough who catches the ball inside the 5 to set up 1st and goal.
Central Catholic now begins at their own 20. On 3rd and 1 at their own 30, Ditmeyer throws a deep pass to Hughes across midfield for a big gain and the first down at the Irish 43.
TOUCHDOWN! On 3rd and 4 from the 24, the Warriors run a trick play as Ternosky throws a lateral pass to Cayden Levert, who throws his own pass to Barrett for the 24-yard score. Walsh Jesuit leads 21-6 with 3:32 left in the half.
Walsh Jesuit takes over at their own 20. On 2nd and 10 from their own 34, Courtad runs right and then cuts inside to the left and scampers down the sideline and goes out of bounds at the Irish 30.
On 4th down in the red zone, Central Catholic attempts a 32-yard field goal, but the holder Beckham Vargas drops the snap, tries running with the ball and gets tackled behind the line of scrimmage, resuling in a turnover on downs.
On 1st and 10 from their own 45, Ditmeyer fires deep to David Yarbrough who picks up the first down around the Irish 12.
Central Catholic's next possession starts at their own 20. They pound the rock with Fuller for a couple first downs.
TOUCHDOWN! On 2nd and goal, Kourtad takes the direct snap and scores from two yards out. Walsh Jesuit leads 14-6 with 10:42 left in the half.
On 3rd and short, Central Catholic jumps offsides and gives Walsh Jesuit an automatic first down. On 1st and 10 at their own 44, Ternosky fires a deep pass to Barrett down the left sideline as he gets tackled inside the 10 for a 1st and goal.
END OF 1ST QUARTER
Walsh Jesuit 7, Central Catholic 6
Walsh Jesuit's next possession begins at their own 20. On 2nd and 7, Ternosky fakes the handoff, rolls left, and connects with Barrett for a 12-yard gain and the first down. Time eventually runs out in the quarter.
TOUCHDOWN! On the ensuing kickoff, Fuller races down the sideline and gets past multiple defenders for a 97-yard score. However, the extra point is blocked as Central Catholic trails 7-6.
Ben Biel comes in as a Wildcat QB and punches in a TD from two yards out for Walsh Jesuit. Jeremiah Fuller answers with a 97-yd kick return for Toledo CC. Walsh up 7-6 w/ 1:15 left in the first after blocking the PAT. pic.twitter.com/jwMNjhNjpR
— Jonathan Simmons (@Jonathanx1867) September 4, 2026
TOUCHDOWN! On 3rd and goal at the 2, Walsh Jesuit runs a Wildcat play as Ben Biel takes the direct snap and scores from two yards out. Walsh Jesuit leads 7-0 with 1:33 left in the first quarter.
On 3rd and 3 at the 11, Courtad runs to his left and picks up six yards to set up 1st and goal at the 5.
On 1st and 10 at the 18, Domanic Courtad takes the handoff, runs to his right and scores on an 18-yard touchdown run. However, the score is called back due to offensive holding.
Walsh Jesuit takes over at their own 25. On the first play of the drive, Mason Rodgers takes the handoff and races across midfield and gets tackled at around the Irish 30.
However, on the very next play, Jeremiah Fuller picks up some yardage, but gets hit and loses the ball, which is recovered by Xavier Steele for the Warriors.
Two plays later, Ditmeyer gets sacked by Kard'aire Penn for a short loss. But on 3rd down, Ditmeyer rolls right and connects with Hughes for another first down.
Central Catholic's offense re-enters the field and begin at their own 35. On 3rd and 3, quarterback Kasyn Ditmeyer hits SolVaire Hughes on a slant pass for a first down.
However, on the very next play, WJ runs an option play and Ternosky gets the ball knocked loose by Chris Sanders and it's recovered by Central Catholic.
After a fair catch, Walsh Jesuit's offense begins at their own 49. On 3rd and 8, David Ternosky fires a deep pass intended for Sam Barrett, but it's incomplete. However, a defensive holding penalty gives Walsh Jesuit a first down at the Central Catholic 39.
Central Catholic receives the opening kickoff which results in a touchback. The offense begins at their own 20. They struggle to move the ball and go three-and-out.
15 minutes away from kickoff.
30 minutes away from kickoff.
45 minutes away from kickoff.
Preview
Who: Toledo Central Catholic vs. Walsh Jesuit
When: Friday, Sept. 4 - 7:00 p.m. ET
Where: The All Sports Complex in Cuyahoga Falls, OH
Toledo Central Catholic Has Strong Start to Season
Toledo Central Catholic (2-0) had an impressive 2025 season where they went 11-5, but lost to Bishop Watterson in the OHSAA Division III state championship game.
Now, the Fighting Irish look poised to make a redemption run, with victories over Trotwood-Madison and Portage Central to show for it. They also enter the week at No. 6 in High School On SI's Ohio High School Football Rankings.
Last week, Central Catholic came from behind to beat Portage Central 24-14. The Irish trailed the Mustangs 14-7 entering the fourth quarter, before erupting for 17 unanswered points to remain unbeaten.
Senior running back Jeremiah Fuller currently leads Central Catholic's rushing attack with 218 yards and four touchdowns on 32 carries, averaging 6.8 yards per attempt. Sophomore Robert Douglas III is the team's leading receiver with nine catches for 114 yards and one touchdown.
The Irish also feature three senior college commits, including wide recever Amari Eliano (Syracuse), offensive lineman Jalen Webb (Cincinnati), and safety Keyon Robinson (Miami (OH)).
Walsh Jesuit Also Looks Impressive
Meanwhile, Walsh Jesuit (2-0) won their season-opener 34-0 against Medina Highland. The Warriors were then scheduled to face Springfield last Friday, but the game resulted in a forfeit by Springfield.
Walsh Jesuit enters Friday at No. 4 in our Ohio rankings. The team is led by head coach Nicholas Alexander. The one player on the roster who has committed to play college football is senior offensive lineman Owen Pelkowski, who will head to Akron next year.
Last year, the Warriors ended Central Catholic's 26-game home winning streak with a 17-14 victory. They went on to finish 11-2, but fell to Avon in the Division II state semifinals.

Harry Lichtman is a sports reporter based in Montgomery County, MD and the DC area. He also writes for Capitals Outsider and LastWordOnSports, and previously wrote for MLB Report, The Sports Pulse, the Baltimore Jewish Times, the Montgomery County Sentinel, and The Bottom Line newspaper at Frostburg State University. In 2020, Harry won an MDDC Press award for a story about former high school lacrosse head coach Jeff Fritz. Harry has been writing since 2016.