Baylor Runs Away From Montgomery Bell Academy in 45-17 Rout: Tennessee High School Football

CHATTANOOGA, Tenn. — Tennessee's top-ranked Baylor played the role of juggernaut in a 45-17 takedown of previously undefeated Montgomery Bell Academy Friday night at Baylor's Heywood Stadium.
Both teams entered the game at 5-0, but Baylor showed how big the gap truly was between a Red Raiders' team on the fringe of the national title conversation and the Big Red of Nashville who were completely outclassed. The win was No. 18 in Baylor's current string of victories dating back to a 27-21 loss to their crosstown rivals from McCallie in the 2024 state championship game.
The game was never in doubt as Baylor cruised to leads of 17-0 after the first quarter and 38-3 at halftime under the steady leadership of future Ole Miss quarterback Keegan Croucher and five-star all-world running back David Gabriel Georges.
The game was so far out of reach that freshman quarterback Marshall Manning — the son of Pro Football Hall of Famer Peyton Manning — even made an appearance in the fourth quarter for the Red Raiders. It was only the second appearance by the junior Manning in a high school game after he completed a six-yard pass for a first down in the season opener against Brentwood Academy in August.
This time, Manning made an extended appearance, completing all four of his attempts for 42 yards and three more first downs. Manning's appearance ended on a 6-yard completion on a fourth-and-14 play in MBA territory that turned the ball over on downs for the game's final two minutes.
Baylor improves to 6-0 with the win headed into next week's rivalry game with that McCallie squad. MBA (5-1) will visit CPA with both those games set to take place Friday night.
If you missed our live blog, you can still catch up with all the action below:
FINAL — Baylor 45, MBA 17
Baylor 45, MBA 17
Another late touchdown from MBA accounts for the final score in Chattanooga, and that's y
On a fourth and 14, Manning completes a 6-yard pass to the middle of the field. A little over two minutes left with this running clock.
Manning with a 9-yard toss to the left sideline for another first down.
Busted play, but Manning avoids the rush for a 17-yard completion.
Marshall Manning in the game, and he completes a pass in the left flat that goes for 10 yards and a first down.
Baylor 45, MBA 10
MBA finally finds the end zone to try and make this look a little more respectable. Tough night for the Big Red, but they're still fighting to their credit.
The fourth quarter will start with MBA at Baylor's 25.
THIRD QUARTER — Baylor 45, MBA 3
And the third quarter is in the books.
MBA on the move deep in Baylor territory.
There's nothing complicated taking place here. Baylor is just 42 points better than MBA tonight, it's that simple. MBA just doesn't have the horses to hang with Baylor's thoroughbreds.
Baylor 45, MBA 3
Another long play, and just like that, Baylor makes it 45-3.
MBA forced to punt, and Baylor takes over on its own 25.
And the second half is under way. MBA starting out on its own 20.
Teams are out on the field beginning to warm up for the second half.
HALFTIME: Baylor 38, MBA 3
That's your first half from Chattanooga. Baylor has buried MBA in a deep hole halfway through this one.
Baylor 38, MBA 3
Croucher on a short quarterback keeper to add to this big Baylor lead.
Gabriel Georges down to about the 2 yard line.
And on first down, Baylor gets down inside MBA's 10-yard line looking to end any thoughts of a potential second-half comeback here.
MBA with an interception deep in its own territory. Penalty after the play will push Baylor back, but they're still starting out on MBA's 31.
Baylor 31, MBA 3
And Baylor adds to its lead after an 80-yard scoring drive. It's all Red Raiders tonight in Chattanooga.
Baylor on the march down to MBA's 41.
Gabriel George goes around left end for 70 yards and an apparent house call. But laundry on the field is block in the back on the Red Raiders, and it's called back. You still catch a glimpse of his speed on that play.
Baylor back on offense, starting at its own 20.
Baylor 24, MBA 3
MBA settles for the field goal on fourth down, and it's good. A curious call trailing 24-0, but there's also something to be said for coming away with points there.
Another incompletion on third down on another rollout. A dangerous jump ball across his body to the back of the end zone, and Baylor knocks it down.
Baylor stuffs MBA on first down. It's a loss of four, and then on second down, MBA's quarterback is forced to throw it away on a rollout around the right end.
A great push by the offensive line, and the Big Red push it all the way down to around the 1-yard line for a first and goal.
MBA down to around the Baylor 15.
MBA finally breaks a big play into Baylor territory down to the Red Raiders' 35.
Baylor 24, MBA 0
Gabriel Georges starting to look unstoppable. He carried it in from 37 yards out, and it's 24-0 Baylor.
Baylor down to MBA's 37.
Baylor on the move yet again. Gabriel-George carrying the ball into MBA territory.
Baylor opens the second quarter on offense with a three-score lead.
FIRST QUARTER: Baylor 17, MBA 0
And the first quarter comes to a close.
MBA forced into a long third and 13, and they're unable to convert. This time, the punter redeems himself with an excellent punt that rolls down to Baylor's 31. This is the first long field they've faced since the opening drive after mistakes gave them two short fields leading to this 17-0 lead.
MBA desperately needs an answer on this drive.
Baylor 17, MBA 0
Your weekly DGG highlight: his 15-yard TD run gives Baylor a 17-0 lead over MBA with 1:49 left in the first quarter. DGG with four carries for 31 yards. pic.twitter.com/GjIXsirWmw
— Stephen Hargis 🇺🇸 (@StephenHargis) September 25, 2026
MBA catches a temporary break when Baylor's David Gabriel-Georges is called for hurdling on a short run. You can't do that at the high school level, but one play later, the 5-star running back carries it in virtually untouched from about 15 yards out. Baylor has a three-score lead in the first quarter.
Another big run for the Red Raiders, and they'll have a first and goal around the 3.
Baylor on the march again with a first down in the red zone.
MBA is forced to punt, and they shank it off the side of the foot. Baylor will start on MBA's side of the field already leading 10-0.
Baylor 10, MBA 0
MBA fumbles on an option pitch, and Baylor pounces on it. One play later, they're in the end zone. And just like that, it's 10-0.
Baylor 3, MBA 0
MBA's defense tightens up from there with the help of a personal foul penalty that put Baylor behind the sticks. The Red Raiders have to settle for the field goal.
Baylor quickly on the move down to MBA's 13.
They're about to get under way. Baylor will be on offense first.
According to Accuweather, It's 75 and sunny with kickoff fast approaching.
Check in closer to game time, and we'll update the weather in the Chattanooga area.
Preview
CHATTANOOGA, Tenn. — Tennessee's top-ranked Baylor hosts Montgomery Bell Academy in a TSSAA Division II-AAA showdown featuring plenty of firepower on both sides.
Both teams enter at 5-0, but Baylor is the favorite to win at home where they are 3-0 this season, including last week's 42-0 shellacking of Christ Presbyterian Academy. The Red Raiders have won 17 consecutive games since losing to crosstown rival McCallie, 27-21, in the 2024 state championship game.
Montgomery Bell Academy has matched Baylor's record so far, but the Big Red have done it by winning a couple of close scraps along the way against Franklin Road Academy (40-36) and Christian Brothers (22-21). That experience in tight games could help them late tonight if this game is close heading into the later stages.
Who: Montgomery Bell Academy [Nashville, Tenn.] at Baylor [Chattanooga, Tenn.]
When: 7:30 p.m. ET local
Where: E.B. "Red" Etter Field at Heywood Stadium
Livestream: Montgomery Bell Academy at Baylor on sportsengineplay.com
Senior quarterback Keegan Croucher and senior running back David Gabriel-Georges remain central figures for a Baylor offense that averages more than 40 points per game. Gabriel-Georges is averaging 187.5 rushing yards per contest, while Baylor's roster also features freshman quarterback Marshall Manning, the son of Peyton Manning.
The young quarterback played two snaps against Brentwood Academy in the season opener, completing a 6-yard pass for a first down before Croucher returned to the game. Manning hasn't played since while reportedly nursing a foot injury, and his status for tonight's game is unclear.
MBA has also been potent on offense, scoring more than 37 points per game while holding opponents to under 17 on average. Junior Bennett Conyers is the highest-rated prospect listed on recruiting sites as a three-star tight end on a team that will have to rely on its collective talent to overcome the big name-stars on the Baylor side.
Kickoff is scheduled for 7:30 p.m. ET Friday at Baylor School's Heywood Stadium in Chattanooga.

Kendall began covering high school sports in East Texas as a high school student in the late 1980s. He served as the sports editor for the Gladewater Mirror early in his career while attending Kilgore College where he received an Associate of Arts with a major in journalism. He later completed his Bachelor of Journalism at The University of Texas at Austin. Webb later founded the College Football America Yearbook, publishing an annual edition every year from 2011 through 2022. Webb added a Master of Liberal Arts with a major in journalism from Harvard University in 2023, simultaneously completing a Graduate Certificate in Digital Storytelling. He has also written for The Sporting News and remains a passionate fan of sports at all levels. He began contributing to High School On SI in 2026.
Follow RoadTripSports