Kyle Tucker Becomes Another Shohei Ohtani as Blue Jays Lose Star to Dodgers
In this story:
History repeated itself in the cruelest way possible for the Toronto Blue Jays. Kyle Tucker agreed to a four-year, $240 million deal with the Los Angeles Dodgers on Wednesday, over a month after touring the same Dunedin facility where Shohei Ohtani said yes to merchandise and no to Toronto's offer just over a year ago.
The parallels are impossible to ignore. Tucker visited the Blue Jays' spring training complex in early December, met with team officials, and saw the $100 million renovated facility firsthand. Toronto showcased everything from upgraded labs to state-of-the-art fields. Then he signed with the Dodgers anyway, exactly like Ohtani did after his secret December 2023 Dunedin visit.
If you like our content, choose Sports Illustrated as a preferred source on Google.
This marks the fifth time the Blue Jays have aggressively pursued an elite free agent only to watch the Dodgers beat them. Freddie Freeman picked Los Angeles over Toronto in March 2022 despite Canadian connections. Ohtani toured Dunedin and chose his record $700 million deal with LA. Yoshinobu Yamamoto signed a 12-year, $325 million contract with the Dodgers.
Roki Sasaki went to Los Angeles last January despite Toronto's late recruitment efforts. The Blue Jays came within one win of beating the Dodgers in Game 7 of the 2025 World Series, losing 5-4 in November. Now they've lost Tucker too, completing the painful pattern where the same organization keeps denying them.
Tucker's deal pays him $60 million annually ($57.1 million present-day value after $30 million deferrals), making him one of baseball's highest-paid position players on average annual value.
Toronto believed they were legitimate contenders throughout the process and reportedly had a competitive long-term offer on the table for weeks. But when decision time came, the Dodgers closed the deal just like they always do against the Blue Jays.
Blue Jays Face Roster Crisis After Missing Top Target
The Tucker rejection forces Toronto to completely reshape their offseason plans. They've already committed over $300 million to Dylan Cease, Cody Ponce, and Kazuma Okamoto this winter. Without Tucker's bat, the Blue Jays must pivot to other offensive upgrades to complement Vladimir Guerrero Jr. in a lineup that couldn't score enough runs in Game 7.
Bo Bichette, the homegrown shortstop the team desperately wanted to retain, signed with the New York Mets instead. Within days, Toronto lost Tucker to the Dodgers and Bichette to the Mets, a stunning double blow for a franchise trying to capitalize on their previous season World Series run.
The Dodgers added Tucker to a roster that already beat Toronto in the World Series. They now project as overwhelming favorites to repeat while the Blue Jays search for answers after another painful free agency defeat. Los Angeles continues building a superteam with no financial constraints while Toronto keeps finishing second in every major recruitment battle that matters.
More Blue Jays News
Jayesh Pagar is currently pursuing Sports Journalism from the London School of Journalism and brings four years of experience in sports media coverage. His current focus is MLB coverage spanning the Blue Jays, Astros, Rangers, Marlins, Tigers, and Rockies, with additional expertise in basketball and college football.