Skip to main content

NASCAR's winners, losers in recent driver, sponsor swaps

With so much news, let's stop and review the facts:

1) Kasey Kahne will drive for Hendrick Motorsports starting in 2012. No word on where he'll drive in 2011.

2) Shell/Pennzoil will leave Richard Childress Racing for Penske Racing in 2011. The company will sponsor Kurt Busch, whose car number will change from No. 2 to No. 22.

3) Kurt Busch has been signed to a long-term deal with Penske. Terms not disclosed.

4) Miller Lite aligns with Penske driver Brad Keselowski beginning in 2011. Keselowski's car number will change from No. 12 to No. 2.

5) Sam Hornish, Jr.'s primary sponsor, Mobil 1, will be going elsewhere in 2011. Team searching for sponsorship for Hornish (No. 77).

While a lot to stomach, all of these changes connect to major themes surrounding NASCAR's future. So let's draw a few conclusions on these deals while you digest, shall we? Here are some winners and losers from the latest Silly Season drama:

WINNER: Roger Penske. One week after rival Rick Hendrick announced his blockbuster deal, Penske's punched back with a move intended to show he's not backing down in NASCAR.

"We're seeing a war waged between the sport's elite car owners," says a source. He's right. It would be impossible for Penske to stand pat without losing ground to a Hendrick organization that finished 1-2-3 in the point standings in 2009. So the second HMS grabbed its "A-level" driver of the future, Penske signed theirs (Busch) to a long-term deal while aligning its young star (Keselowski) with an "A-level" sponsor. The move will prove crucial in their long-term plan to unseat Hendrick at the top.

WINNER: Brad Keselowski / Miller Lite. While Kes was already signed to a long-term deal with Penske, pairing him with sponsor Miller Lite and the No. 2 gives him instant credibility. Only two men have driven that car since 1991: Rusty Wallace and Kurt Busch, armed with 76 wins and two championships between them.

Another word describes Keselowski's attitude this week: relief. Sponsor Verizon's contract was up the end of 2010, a deal they inherited through a merger with Alltel. But due to NASCAR's exclusivity agreement with title sponsor Sprint, they're not allowed to use its logos on the side of the No. 12 car. Penske is noncommittal with Verizon's future, but reading between the lines of statements we've seen, it's reasonable to assume the cell phone company's on its way out. After all, would you dish out millions only to not get the visual exposure of your brand on the side of the car?

Searching for backing could have posed a distraction to this team as they build for the future. Instead, Penske's put additional faith in Keselowski, aligning him not only with a long-term partner, but one who wants him to stay exactly the same. Miller Lite is comfortable with the driver's personality, expecting him to continue an aggressive, independent style of handling issues on and off the race track. Plus, at 26, they can rebuild their brand toward a younger, twenty-something market the 31-year-old Busch was on the edge of growing out of.

WINNER: Michael Waltrip Racing. One big question is where sponsor Mobil 1 will go in 2011. For the answer, I refer you to a partnership the oil company has with TRD engine suppliers, in particular Michael Waltrip Racing. Simple logic makes them the clear frontrunner to grab their support.

Sources claim the Mobil 1 deal is on the low end of sponsorships these days -- about $10-12 million -- but that's enough to give the three-car team a major boost, particularly the JTG team driven by Marcos Ambrose. Nationwide Series prodigy Trevor Bayne is also driving without sponsorship for his No. 99 car; perhaps a partnership with the oil company will lead to a fourth Cup team in the future? Considering this team was nearly booted out of NASCAR back in '07, that would be quite the accomplishment.

NEUTRAL: Kurt Busch. Sure, Busch inherits a new sponsor and a long-term deal for 2011. But will the emergence of Shell really be the "new opportunity" Penske envisions for the '04 champ? Miller Lite has always been viewed as the team's top sponsor, and now Busch loses that to Keselowski. He also loses the legendary branding of Penske's No. 2.

With a long-term contract, the move does offer greater security for Busch. But for a man looking to increase his popularity, I'm not sure what partnering for an oil company does to accomplish that.

LOSER: Sam Hornish, Jr. Penske's putting a game face on for Hornish, claiming sponsorship will keep him in NASCAR for 2011 and beyond. But with rising star Justin Allgaier in Nationwide, the pressure's clearly on for the IndyCar vet to start performing. Don't be surprised if the former Indy 500 champ makes his return to that series in 2011, paving the way for Allgaier to move into a newly-renumbered 12 car.

LOSER: Richard Childress. Childress took another devastating blow this week, losing his second primary sponsor in two years. With Harvick expected to leave the team, the six-time championship car owner now has Clint Bowyer, Jeff Burton, and no one underneath them ready to take the next step.

Moving forward, Childress is in a very difficult position to try and recover. With Hendrick support reaching out to as many as eight teams in 2011, he's far down the totem pole with GM support. But the real warning sign comes with his limited reach outside the sport. The reason Shell left Childress wasn't just performance, it was in the business-to-business relationships offered by Penske's 316 dealerships coast-to-coast. That ensured them they'd make more bang for their buck in case NASCAR's recent decline accelerated.

"Sponsors don't just want to be on the hood of a car anymore," says a source. "Those days are over." Right now, that's all Childress has to offer, and that's why he'll lose out on this deal. Budweiser might be his only hope, looking to partner with an icon in the sport for next season. If Childress could somehow get Harvick to re-sign although the chances of that are near zero, according to SI.com's Tim Tuttle, the partnership would be a perfect fit.

Otherwise, considering all driver/sponsor contracts end after 2011, would that make the 64-year-old consider retirement? It's an option.

LOSER: Kevin Harvick. Already stunned by Kasey Kahne's deal last week, Harvick's still reeling from a sponsor defection (Shell) he supposedly had locked up for 2011. That leaves the 34-year-old in dire straits; after burning that RCR bridge, the Chevy-loyal driver has almost no prospects other than good buddy Tony Stewart. Would Stewart-Haas be willing to jump from two to four teams if Kahne comes on board? There's no guarantee. Keep in mind Harvick still needs to find a sponsor, and the market's not ripe for a middle-30s driver who hasn't won a race since 2007.

Another option could be moving Harvick's self-owned Nationwide team to Cup. But he's long expressed resistance to doing so, and the money may not be there to make it happen. That leaves him backed in a corner ... and there may be no way out.

LOSER: NASCAR. Two themes emerge from the last two weeks of insanity. The first is easy: the rich get richer. Hendrick and Penske, two top-tier organizations, have poached high-level sponsorship from the sport's eroding middle class. It's now hard to see any organization competing for titles without support from the sport's Big Four: Hendrick, Penske, Roush, or Gibbs.

But the second theme is more alarming. Notice all the top-level teams fighting over expiring contracts. This week wasn't filled with announcements about Wal-Mart, Wendy's or new Fortune 500 companies entering the sport. Where's the new blood, in the form of owners, investors, and sponsors coming in to replace companies jumping ship? Heck, Mark Martin was sponsored by his car owner last week at Texas. When the championship runner-up is having trouble filling all 36 races ... it's a problem.

Sadly, the bloodshed is just beginning. With sponsor renewals at hand, NASCAR teams are asking their backers for more cash -- and that's a problem. Three straight years of declining ratings and attendance have companies laughing them out of the boardroom.

When sponsors balk, the rich survive, using their own cash to keep prices rising. But for the poor, the business model is broken: and until all parties agree to fix it, we're about to find out just how many blue collar fans follow a series comprised of just one economic breed of competitor: upper class.