All Bengals

Looking at the Bengals' Record Against QBs Selected No. 1 Overall as They Prepare for the Bears' Caleb Williams

Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Andy Dalton (14) and Cleveland Browns quarterback Baker Mayfield (6) shakes hands at the conclusion of an NFL Week 17 game, Sunday, Dec. 29, 2019, at Paul Brown Stadium in Cincinnati. Cincinnati Bengals won 33-23.

Cleveland Browns At Cincinnati Bengals Football 12 29 2019
Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Andy Dalton (14) and Cleveland Browns quarterback Baker Mayfield (6) shakes hands at the conclusion of an NFL Week 17 game, Sunday, Dec. 29, 2019, at Paul Brown Stadium in Cincinnati. Cincinnati Bengals won 33-23. Cleveland Browns At Cincinnati Bengals Football 12 29 2019 | Kareem Elgazzar, Cincinnati Enquirer via Imagn Content Services, LLC

In this story:


CINCINNATI – Sunday’s Cincinnati Bengals game against the Chicago Bears will mark the 31st time they have faced a quarterback who went No. 1 overall in his first or second season.

The Bears selected Caleb Williams No. 1 overall last year, and Sunday will mark his 25th career start.

He is 9-15 in his previous 24, but they are 4-1 in the last five.

This will be just the fifth time in the Zac Taylor era the Bengals have faced a No. 1 quarterback in his first or second season, and two of those games came against the same guy.

The Bengals are 2-2 in those games.

2021: Bengals 24, Jaguars 21 – Rookie Trevor Lawrence was 16 of 24 for 204 yards with no touchdowns or interceptions and a passer rating of 96.5

2019: Bengals 33, Browns 23 – Baker Mayfield, in his second start of the season against Cincinnati, was 12 of 27 for 279 yards with three touchdowns and three interceptions and a rating of 79.6

2019: Browns 27, Bengals 19 – Mayfield was 11 of 24 for 192 yards with no touchdowns and two interceptions and a rating of 38.9

2019: Cardinals 26, Bengals 23 – Rookie Kyler Murray was 20 of 32 for 253 yards with no touchdowns or interceptions and a rating of 87.1.

 Overall, the Bengals are 14-16 in games against No. 1-drafted quarterbacks in their first or second season.

Though it’s 30 games, there are only 18 unique names on the list as many of them were division foes who faced the Bengals multiple times in their first and/or second year.

The rest of the list

2018: Browns 26, Bengals 18 – Mayfield

2018: Browns 35, Bengals 30 – Mayfield

2013: Bengals 42, Colts 28 – Andrew Luck

2009: Bengals 23, Lions 13 – Matthew Stafford

2004: Bengals 23, Giants 22 – Eli Manning

2003: Bengals 34, Texans 27 – David Car

2002: Falcons 30, Bengals 3 – Michael Vick

2000: Browns 24, Bengals 7 – Tim Couch

1999: Bengals 44, Browns 28 – Couch

1999: Colts 31, Bengals 10 – Peyton Manning

1999: Bengals 18, Browns 17 – Couch

1998: Colts 39, Bengals 26 – Peyton Manning

1994: Patriots 31, Bengals 28 – Drew Bledsoe

1993: Patriots 7, Bengals 2 – Bledsoe

1990: Colts 34, Bengals 20 – Jeff George

1990: Saints 21, Bengals 7 – Steve Walsh

1986: Browns 34, Bengals 3 – Bernie Kosar

1986: Bengals 30, Browns 13 – Kosar

1985: Bengals 27, Browns 10 – Kosar

1984: Broncos 20, Bengals 17 – John Elway

1975: Bengals 21, Falcons 14 – Steve Bartkowski

1972: Bengals 31, Patriots 7 – Jim Plunkett

1971: Steelers 21, Bengals 10 – Tery Bradshaw

1970: Bengals 34, Steelers 7 – Bradshaw

1970: Steelers 21, Bengals 10 – Bradshaw


Published
Jay Morrison
JAY MORRISON

Jay Morrison covers the Cincinnati Bengals for Bengals On SI. He has been writing about the NFL for nearly three decades. Combining a passion for stats and storytelling, Jay takes readers beyond the field for a unique look at the game and the people who play it. Prior to joining Bengals on SI, Jay covered the Cincinnati Bengals beat for The Athletic, the Dayton Daily News and Pro Football Network.