Patience key as Evander Kane’s sex assault investigation unfolds
Another off-ice incident involving a player with a blemished reputation. Another black eye for the NHL.
But if we learned anything this past summer from Patrick Kane and his months-long journey down the legal rabbit hole, it’s that none of us are in position to make assumptions of guilt or innocence from the comfort of our armchairs.
So, let’s all take a deep breath, put our biases aside and recognize that facts, at this point, remain scarce.
We know, not from the police but from comments issued by the Sabres, that Kane is under investigation for an incident that allegedly occurred on Sunday morning in a downtown Buffalo hotel room near the First Niagara Center.
“We take the allegation made today against Evander Kane very seriously,” read the team’s statement. “We are gathering facts and have been in touch with the NHL and Evander’s representatives. Until we have more information we will not have any additional comment.”
We also know that Kane has not been charged with any crime.
Beyond that, it’s all speculation. And as we learned over the summer, that can be dangerous and misleading territory.
So let’s resolve to do better this time.
Let’s not assume that Kane’s accuser is a gold digger or an attention seeker or someone who didn’t get what she wanted from the player. Instead, let her be someone who deserves privacy during a very difficult time, along with the benefit of a thorough and impartial investigation into her claims.
Let’s not let Kane’s checkered past or questions about his character affect our assumptions of what he might, or might not, be capable of doing. Past social media miscues or friction with former teammates might indicate immaturity, but there’s no straight line to be drawn from those random incidents to sexual assault. Until proven otherwise, he deserves the presumption of innocence.
Let’s allow the Sabres and the NHL to make the call on how to handle this. The Blackhawks didn’t exactly drape themselves in glory while dealing with Patrick Kane last summer, and there are lessons to be learned from their mistakes, especially the decision to drag him in front of the press, allow him to say nothing, and then proceed with a rah-rah season-opening event. But ultimately the Hawks were vindicated in their decision to support him after the Erie County district attorney chose not to file charges.
And so was the NHL for choosing not to suspend Kane. As Deputy Commissioner Bill Daly explained over the summer, the league is limited in what it can do under the terms of the CBA in the absence of legal evidence and/or an arrest. Proceeding with caution proved to be the right course of action then and it almost certainly will be the way the team and the league handle this developing situation now.
And finally, let’s allow the authorities the time to do their jobs. Clearly, lessons were learned from the bizarre twists and turns of the Patrick Kane investigation, and those will inform how this case is pursued. It could take longer than we’d like—“We do not expect it to be resolved in the very near future,” a police source told The Buffalo News—but getting it done right is what all sides deserve.
We’d all rather be talking about the Winter Classic or the World Juniors or why scoring is down in the NHL, but this story isn’t going away any time soon. Here’s hoping the lessons we all learned over the summer will keep the discussion fair and honest.
The numbers game
• The Flames have set a franchise record of 11th consecutive home wins, bettering their 10-game run of Nov. 7 to Dec. 12, 2006. They are also the first NHL team with an 11-game home win streak since the Penguins banged out 13 in a row (Nov. 15, 2013 Jan. 15, 2014).
• The Jets are now only the fourth team in NHL history to win a game 1–0 with the lone goal being scored on a penalty shot. The others: the Rangers on Jan. 16, 1936 vs. Toronto; the Maple Leafs on March 19, 2006 at Pittsburgh, and the Canadiens on April 12, 2014 vs. the Rangers.
• Avalanche forward Jarome Iginla needs one goal to become the 19th player in NHL history to score 600.
• As epic as the Habs’ slump might be, this is no time for them to panic.
• Far from home, Nashville’s three Swedes have formed a close-knit family away from the ice.
• Over the weekend, goalie Shannon Szabados became the first woman to register a shutout in a men’s league game.
• Traveling halfway across the globe to watch the World Juniors has become a bucket list item for many Canadian hockey fans.
• Finally, you should click here, because nothing is cooler than a parrot chanting for an NHL team.