Blue Jays Big League Success Comes at Cost of Fading Farm System
In this story:
The Toronto Blue Jays are coming off an incredible run in the postseason. The Blue Jays ended up losing to the Los Angeles Dodgers in seven games, but there is a lot of reason for hope north of the border.
If you like our content, choose Sports Illustrated as a preferred source on Google.
Toronto signed Dylan Cease, brought in one of the top Japanese players on the market in Kazuma Okamoto, and made a few other good moves that will help the team win.
Now, the Blue Jays lost out on the Bo Bichette sweepstakes, and Cody Bellinger chose to re-sign with the New York Yankees. Still, the team has high hopes for 2026, and not much should change from their successful 2025 campaign. However, the Blue Jays are in win-now mode.
The Athletic's (subscription required) Keith Law released his list of top prospects and top-ranked farm systems each season. This year, Law ranked the Blue Jays' farm system 25th in the MLB.
Blue Jays Top Prospects
The 2026 top prospects have not yet been released. But Toronto's list from 2025 remains largely intact. Trey Yesavage made a name for himself in the postseason, but is still a rookie in 2026. He is the team's No. 1 prospect, but will no doubt lose his prospect status during the year.
Yesavage was ranked No. 15 on Law's top 100 prospects, but he was not the only Blue Jays on the list. JoJo Parker and Arjun Nimmala are both ranked in the top 100. Respectively, the two shortstops are the No. 2 and 3 prospects in Toronto's organization.
The Blue Jays will see Yesavage start the year on the big league club. Not only that, but they expect a massive year out of their best pitcher from the 2025 playoffs. However, Parker and Nimmala are both quite a few years away from being Major League ready.
Toronto does have some players who could make their debut in 2026, though. Ricky Tiedemann and RJ Schreck are two players who come to mind.
Tiedemann will need to prove himself a little bit more in Triple-A, but there is always a need for pitchers at the MLB level. With injuries being so common, especially on the mound, Tiedemann should be able to make his debut this season.
Schreck, on the other hand, might have a little bit more waiting to do. But the left-handed hitter slashed .242/.392/.435 with nine home runs and 33 RBI over 58 games played at Triple-A last year. He was given a non-roster invite to spring training, and the Blue Jays will get a much better look at him there.
Toronto has exciting prospects in the minor leagues. But the team is in win-now mode, and the farm system could take more of a hit in 2026 because of it.
Cameron Zunkel is a sports writer from the western suburbs of Chicago. He played Division-II baseball at the University of Illinois at Springfield where he earned a masters degree in Communication. Cameron also played independent league baseball for the Joliet Slammers and Schaumburg Boomers of the Frontier League. He has been in journalism since 2022 and has a passion for baseball specifically, but he enjoys all sports. His other work includes writing sports betting articles for ClutchPoints. In his free time, you can catch Cam at the gym, on the golf course, or coaching the youth in the beautiful sport of baseball.