The New Orleans Saints and Tampa Bay Buccaneers were praised for their offeason spending, but they're experiencing a bit of buyer's remorse with a quarter of the season in the books. Big-ticket acquisitions Jairus Byrd and Alterraun Verner haven't lived up to their billing, and they aren't alone.
• Challenge your friends and win BIG in our weekly fantasy football game
Who else has disappointed? And, conversely, which underrated acquisitions have surprised? SI.com's John DePetro, Chris Burke and Doug Farrar discuss that and hand out their quarter-mark awards.