How the 49ers have Squandered a Dynasty Under Kyle Shanahan

This is painful.

Sergio Estrada-Imagn Images

As Kyle Shanahan enters his 10th season as the 49ers head coach, he still is searching for his first Super Bowl ring. Unfortunately for the 49ers, they should have won multiple rings during the past decade, but Shanahan couldn't close the deal.

Let's revisit history.

When Shanahan took over as head coach, the 49ers had the second pick in the draft. He could have taken Patrick Mahomes, but didn't even scout him because he wanted Kirk Cousins, whom he never acquired. So, the Chiefs traded up to take Mahomes with the 10th pick. Which means Mahomes should be the 49ers' quarterback. Instead, Shanahan handed a dynasty to Kansas City.

Kirby Lee-Imagn Images

To be fair, nine teams passed on Mahomes, so he wasn't exactly a slam dunk. And in spite of the 49ers not getting him, Shanahan led them to the Super Bowl in Year 3 of his tenure despite having Jimmy Garoppolo as his quarterback. Garoppolo wasn't good, and the 49ers knew it -- that's why they let him throw only eight passes in the NFC championship.

In that Super Bowl, the 49ers actually faced Mahomes and the Chiefs. And the 49ers should have beaten them -- they had a 10-point lead midway through the fourth quarter. But Shanahan abandoned the run in the second half, stopped feeding Raheem Mostert and Deebo Samuel, the defense got tired, and the 49ers collapsed. That was the first Super Bowl Shanahan squandered.

Matthew Emmons-Imagn Images

The next year, the 49ers could have had Tom Brady, because the Patriots pushed him out of New England and he wanted to come play for his hometown team. But the 49ers decided to stick with Garoppolo because he's younger. So, Brady signed with the Buccaneers instead and won a Super Bowl in his first season in Tampa. That was the second Super Bowl Shanahan squandered.

Kim Klement-Imagn Images

The next year, the 49ers finally wanted to replace Garoppolo. But instead of trading for Matthew Stafford, the 49ers let the Rams get him, and then traded three first-round picks and a third for Trey Lance, one of the biggest busts ever. Stafford went on to win a ring in his first season in LA after beating the 49ers in the NFC championship. Of course, the 49ers had a 10-point fourth-quarter lead and blew it. That was the third Super Bowl Shanahan squandered.

Kirby Lee-Imagn Images

Finally, after all those missed opportunities, they smartly traded for Christian McCaffrey, lucked into Brock Purdy, and somehow assembled one of the most talented 49ers rosters in 49ers history in 2023. And they went back to the Super Bowl and faced the Chiefs again. But this time, the Chiefs didn't have Tyreek Hill. The 49ers were clearly better than them.

Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

And yet, the 49ers lost again, because Shanahan abandoned the run with a lead in the third quarter, and didn't know the rules in overtime. That was the fourth Super Bowl Shanahan squandered. A few months later, he let Sam Darnold leave in free agency, and now he's playing in the Super Bowl with the Seahawks.

Kevin Ng-Imagn Images

If Seattle wins a ring next week, Shanahan can say he had a hand in creating three potential dynasties -- the Chiefs, the Rams and the Seahawks.

If only he could say the same thing about his own team. He's had plenty of chances.